Should BB6 be an all stars show?

2 of 2

cgbrannigan

07-04-2004

Originally Posted by TheBlueOne:
“Once again, just voicing my opinon. OK, Jade says stupid things - it was fun in Big Brother, but you see how pear-shaped it went in Back To Reality. Jade has changed since the experience.

Housemates who were loved by the public for one trait, e.g. stupidity, will play up on it big time in Big Brother: All Stars - and it will turn into a botch show. Craig playing his 'nice builder' image, Helen and Jade being 'stupid', Kate probably frolicking with a man, Brian upping the tempo on the 'campness' and Jon, if he goes in, will mention Science a lot more.

Big Brother housemates are not normal people, they are media wise contestants to as seen in a previous thread have had acting experience amongst other things. They might not even be the 'bubbly' characters of which we see in Big Brother. Jade was in the first ever episode of London's Burning, Alison has appeared in television programmes, as has Jonny.”

thats exactly why they need to change it from the social experament format it is now to the game format it should be where people can freely discuss nominations and strategies. Theres also the age old problem of arseholes in the editing suit as we saw last year with the tickle talks trek debacle and the whole producers set up for Cameron to win

TheBlueOne

07-04-2004

Originally Posted by cgbrannigan:
“thats exactly why they need to change it from the social experament format it is now to the game format it should be where people can freely discuss nominations and strategies. Theres also the age old problem of arseholes in the editing suit as we saw last year with the tickle talks trek debacle and the whole producers set up for Cameron to win”

I agree, but use the US Game format in the All-Stars game, and see if that works. We don't necessarily need that, we just need housemates who do not get on. Big Brother 4 taught the producers one thing, I hope, that the British public enjoy seeing fights, arguments, tantrums - not people getting on, who will be bland and won't strike up controversy.

EDIT: Thought of a lovely idea which would spark up some nice telly. The head-of-house, who nominates the two people for the public to vote, has to tell the person who they nominated that they are leaving. Making last-night-fights for people, it would be so nasty, but so enjoyable.

cgbrannigan

08-04-2004

Originally Posted by TheBlueOne:
“I agree, but use the US Game format in the All-Stars game, and see if that works. We don't necessarily need that, we just need housemates who do not get on. Big Brother 4 taught the producers one thing, I hope, that the British public enjoy seeing fights, arguments, tantrums - not people getting on, who will be bland and won't strike up controversy.

EDIT: Thought of a lovely idea which would spark up some nice telly. The head-of-house, who nominates the two people for the public to vote, has to tell the person who they nominated that they are leaving. Making last-night-fights for people, it would be so nasty, but so enjoyable.”

Obviously the HoH nominating 2 people and the housemates voting them out wouldn't work with any public voting system so they'd have to do something else but similar and none of your "we want tickle out so lets have a double eviction" bullshit

2 of 2