Originally Posted by AdzBrown:
“Britney has progressed but I wouldn't exactly say it's her, it's her producers and writers who have changed and progressed.
Gaga hasn't had a chance to properly progress yet, she has only released 8 new songs since her debut album. Although Speechless is good songwriting and is extremely different from the rest of her stuff.
Success doesn't mean progression, just look at Westlife. They are consistently successful even though most of their songs sound the same.”
I agree with this. I appreciate about Britneys songwriters progressing for her. That's what I was touching on but I still feel her musical style has definitly changed.
You also have to ask yourself - is there a need for change and revolution? Some bands constantly evolve and release material that they , and their fans enjoy.
Some bands revolve and somehow manage to keep the soul of their songs and impress their fans (The Beatles from Blues to rock and roll to various other genres).
Some acts know that even the slightest change in their formula would result In failure - your westlife comment for example. You can't do anything with Westlife without having a backlash from their fans. Sure a few originally penned songs and some urgency (a bit like what with Take That did) wouldn't go a miss but generally in the end you risk losing popularity.
Westlife have suffered this fate where Take That have had their second number one on the trot.
Pop music is a strange thing. One artist will be slated for "always releasing the same stuff" , others will be slated for "trying something fresh when what they had worked well" and others will ask themselves : "why should I step out of my comfort zone?!?....I'm quite comfortable in here thanks!

".