Are they going to be back or not?

contracts are up for negotiations in January

But Cheryl was announced as a replacement for Sharon as late as June in 2008

So unless both of them are sure on their decision to return, and I don't think either are, then we might not hear for a while yet who will return (and who will replace any who leave)

I don't think dannii will come back... But i do think cheryl will.

To be honest, if Dannii does leave, I think they should keep it as 3 judges, the orginal line up was the best.

Dannii no, Cheryl yes.

absolutely, 100%, nailed on, cast iron.

probably

Dannii yes and Cheryl yes.

How many times are they going to say the same story Dannii vs Kelly vs Mel B

I can't see Dannii returning, we've seen over the last three years that she doesn't do things by halves and I think she'll want to devote her time to being a mum and enjoying life back in Australia with her family whilst possibly returning to Australia's Got Talent.

Cheryl on the other hand I feel is just looking for publicity. I think she needs the X Factor a lot more than it needs her, I'm sure she'll be back.

I do not think Dannii will be back, because she is pregnant and has AGT. She does not need the show now anyway, because it has helped her increase her popularity and her profile

As for Cheryl, I definitely think she will be back. She doesn't need the show, because she is popular and is doing well as a solo singer right now. She wants to win again though according to this article, so will be back.




http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/xfactor/...hat-trick.html