He is cr*p, but he's never in the skate-off. Even Emily has improved a bit, but he's got worse.

He works for ITV.... you do the maths !!! It ain't the general public.

People with an even more warped sense of humour than me. The ones that like the slips, the falls and the high risk of injury to both him and his partner.

I'd consider voting for him next week.

I like him and my favourites are dropping like flies

The point of the public vote isn't necessarily to vote the best skater (what's the point of a vote if it merely echos the judge's table?) but who you want to see more of.

Clearly a lot of people enjoy Hilary being on the show

Everyone knows how these shows work. There are always those who stay longer than they should on merit & those who leave too soon.

Nice guy, much better than Todd Carty, however, he should be voted off. Jeremy was way better than Dr Hilary and this is from someone who likes Dr Hilary.

Why would anyone want to keep someone as bobbins as dr hilary in? No entertainment factor at all.

He's lovely, unassuming man, who really wants to do well. And despite the 37 year age gap between us, I would

I can see why people vote for him!

I reckon all the money GMTV makes from their breakfast competitions goes towards paying lots of people to phone in and vote for him.

He's certainly the John Sergeant of DOI.

He's absolutely great - when he's not on the ice. I really hope this doesn't turn into a joke of Coleen Nolan-style proportions.

Oh god he is hopeless - how can someone with so many hours of intensive training, with pros, be so utterly useless?

Get him out FGS

Who's voting for Hilary? Who the hell is voting for Tara?

I didn't but I was tempted to this week although I wanted him out first last week. This week I warmed to him after he stumbled and made a complete hash of the inside 3. The dear man does at least show just how bloomin' hard it is to learn to do this stuff especially the older you get and I thought he is actually doing pretty well considering.

Being sidelined through a couples dance injury myself I have more sympathy.

I don't watch GMTV.

Thats exactly what Iam wondering I have never heard of Tana before and can't imagine many people have so its seems strange that she can have so many people voting to keep her in when shes not very good or even entertaining?

I wish people wouldn't vote for him. He's not improving, hes gotten worse. Good Talents are gonna go everyweek so that deadweight stays!. *Sigh*

To be honest I did think that yesterday he seemed to have improved and although he wobbled he wasn't the only one, I felt he was a bit undermarked, this may have engendered a certain amount of extra public support.

My mum

He wasn't that bad!

It was only Hilary's second performance. It's not like the guy fell flat on his face - he had one wobble.

Perhaps, but Jeremy was better than Dr Hilary by a country mile. Which doesn't say lot for Dr Hilary, does it?

Hi Sid <smooooch>!
Are any of your favourites left in?? Over on SCD I have tended to like the ones you like but I've not been over keen on any of the DOI celebs that have left so far. I like Mikey, Gary, Daniella and Hayley
I like Dr Hilary - but don't think he'll be a Donal.

Is it Gordon's fault, do we think?

It might well be

Hello you <smooch!> x

Donal is going to be a hard act to follow. I'm settling for Dr H but I'm not massively passionate about him.

I liked Sinitta and Jeremy and they've both gone

Mikey () Heather () and Tana () are my remaining favs....


Be nice! (no, I admit it doesn't )

I think you might be disappointed there too, Sid XX

I think if you 'settle' for Mike now it might be less disappointing for you.

And as for Tana being one of your favs... is all I can say...