Originally Posted by laur_od:
“Thats because they asked them too early they thought melinda in particular would come higher. They predicted Roxy over Coleen as well, though Roxy would have got in anyway cos coleen said she wouldn't do it so they'd have to have gone down to 6th. they messed up not asking Donal, Melinda effectively took Donals slot, they probs thought she'd come about 5th and he'd come about 7th. They predicted the wrong top 5! That's the only reason it went down so far.
Todd got in because of the YouTube thing (I also think given that they thought he might come higher) and because they needed extra person from that current year (cos before that it was five new and four from previous) cos Clare said she couldn't do it, and they ignored Donal as they didn't think he'd do very well. So they were lacking in past skater so took 6, not the case this year seemingly, so I don't know five maybe will do it from this series and four from others. although given the talent this year they may take 6 again.
So that's why 6th, 7th and Todd got in.
Only way Heather will get in is if other people (the predicted top 5) can't tour and it goes down the line, or they predict the wrong top five or six like last year (though 6th would have got in as Coleen didn't want it).
I can't see Heather getting a slot over Danny, Keiron, Gary, Hayley, Daniella or Mikey unless they refuse it, cos all bar one of them are gonna be the top 5, even if you just judge on skating ability. One if these mightn't even get in if they want to take 4 previous stars on tour. They also appear to have Ray, Suzanne, Kyran, Chris and Clare competing for 3, max 4 slots.
I personally can't see Heather touring...
It's too competitive this year touring and also I can't see people turning down good work...”
“Thats because they asked them too early they thought melinda in particular would come higher. They predicted Roxy over Coleen as well, though Roxy would have got in anyway cos coleen said she wouldn't do it so they'd have to have gone down to 6th. they messed up not asking Donal, Melinda effectively took Donals slot, they probs thought she'd come about 5th and he'd come about 7th. They predicted the wrong top 5! That's the only reason it went down so far.
Todd got in because of the YouTube thing (I also think given that they thought he might come higher) and because they needed extra person from that current year (cos before that it was five new and four from previous) cos Clare said she couldn't do it, and they ignored Donal as they didn't think he'd do very well. So they were lacking in past skater so took 6, not the case this year seemingly, so I don't know five maybe will do it from this series and four from others. although given the talent this year they may take 6 again.
So that's why 6th, 7th and Todd got in.
Only way Heather will get in is if other people (the predicted top 5) can't tour and it goes down the line, or they predict the wrong top five or six like last year (though 6th would have got in as Coleen didn't want it).
I can't see Heather getting a slot over Danny, Keiron, Gary, Hayley, Daniella or Mikey unless they refuse it, cos all bar one of them are gonna be the top 5, even if you just judge on skating ability. One if these mightn't even get in if they want to take 4 previous stars on tour. They also appear to have Ray, Suzanne, Kyran, Chris and Clare competing for 3, max 4 slots.
I personally can't see Heather touring...
It's too competitive this year touring and also I can't see people turning down good work...”
I doubt if its on where you come but how good and watchable you are if available. (Obvious exception for Todd when its how bad you are) On that basis in 2009 you would go for Melinda, Roxy, Jessica and Zoe. Melinda looked good and was probably even more capable than they let her show on the show. Roxy would have a go at the headbanger type moves when no one else last year could. She was more essential for wow factor because Suzanne didn't have Matt and Clare wasn't there. Zoe and Jessica were the two top girls so they were certains. Clare and Bonnie were not available, Suzanne was and was the previous champion. Donal wasn't very good anyway and certainly not so good that you would take him over a Kyran or a Chris. Ray and Todd had places for opposite but inevitable reasons.
For 2010, would Heather have the time or the need even if her leg allowed her - she would attract a lot of interest though if she was on tour? Unless Emily gets up to Melinda's level though they have a shortage of good girls and need some of the past greats back. As you say they look like having a lot of good boys and too few girls. Thats what comes of going for taller, older girls and then losing Sinnita who probably had more potential than several (was she available though anyway?) .



