Isn't that because His Evelness disapproves of his darling daughter sh@gging Ollie? If there's $500k to be won again.....they'll get over it

Wait.. Daniele and Ollie? I cant handle all these random pairings of ex-players getting together.

I just don't buy it. Immediately after Will's eviction Boogie was back in the game, throwing the endurance comp, knowing both Erika and Janelle had to take him to the Final. Knowing that Dr Evil would work the Jury for him. Oooohhh almost as if he planned it that way.......

I guess so, but I think him throwing the challenge was completely overated, especially when he then went allout in the next two rounds to win HoH. I think that was just him trying to showboat.

Out of interest, does anyone actually think that either woman would have taken the other to the final? I think Erika would have taken Mike anyway, but I think Janelle would have gone for Erika.

I think he tried hard for round 2 cuz there was a car on offer. And everyone knows how much Chilltown liked prizes

LOL I dont think it was that way done. Both Janelle and Erika knew Boogie was the bigger threat to win. I mean wasnt Erika going round the house in one of the last days practically talking to herself how Boogie HAD to go?

From what I recall, Erika had said in the diary room she was going to be evicting Janelle. But then I also read she'd been talking to herself saying she'd evict Boogie. I think her best choice would have been Janelle though - Erika did nothing, but she could have argued that the limited stuff she did actually worked unlike Janelle who pretty much caused everyone around her to go home.

Nah. I think either way the penny went for Erika, she would have been doomed. With Boogie gone she may have had at least one near-certain vote other than Marcellas for her to win

Nah, Boogie spent the rest of that night and the next day still gobsmacked that Janelle had the balls to vote Will out. He kept saying that he couldn't believe it. He was almost in tears, he wanted himself and Will to be at the end together.

Out of interest, do you think Boogie would have won against Janelle? I think it would have been a real 50/50 scenario - Boogie would 100% have had Erika and Will, Janelle would have had Howie and Marcellas...

Im really not sure about Danielle. I saw a video of her a few hours before her eviction trying to help Janelle out, but she also told her she would be voting on game alone because she got screwed in her original season. I think that's an extra vote for Boogie.

Who knows what George would have done. Im inclined to believe he'd have voted for Janelle because he respected her for winning so much, but then he voted for Boogie over Erika which I wouldnt have expected either.

James.. James would be an absolute mystery to me. I think by the end of that season all his loyalty to Janelle was completely worn out, but at the same time, James is a challenge beast and may have appreciated Janelle for that too.

Im really really not sure

I think Janelle would have won.

I think it would really have come down to the Jury questioning and how well Janelle coped with it.

then again we can wonder this 'what-if' scenario all day/week/year really

This is an interesting thread. There are some interesting things as to HouseGuests that have said they wouldn't do Big Brother again, so my list will take this into consideration.

Big Brother 8

Definites:
Jen -- Big drama causer, and a shoo-in to be asked back. The fact she represented BB8 in the BB10 food challenge shows that she must be regarded at least somewhat highly by the producers.

Eric -- A good strategic player that was hampered by the memorable America's Player twist the first time around. Hosting BB9's opening HoH competition shows the producers like him.

Choose 1 (one) of these 3 (three):
Jessica -- They gave her another try for BB11 so they must want her back in some regard. Fairly popular as well.

Daniele -- All-Stars 2 without a Donato just wouldn't be All-Stars. I read somewhere recently that Dick was "done with BB", so that'd make her a likely choice.

Dick -- He was memorable, that's for sure. Just in case he changes his mind, I'd put him here.

Big Brother 9

Definites:
Chelsia -- Fairly popular player that brought a lot of excitement to the house. Could definitely see her being asked back, and was kind of surprised she wasn't asked to represent the Off-Beats last year.

Pick 1 (one) of 4 (four):
Ryan -- Just a laid-back guy that was pretty popular.

Crazy James -- Wouldn't rule it out since he was popular. Kind of a lousy player though.

Sheila -- An older female, could probably only be in if Renny isn't.

Definitely Not:
Adam or Matty -- Likely will be incarcerated.

Big Brother 10

Defnites:
Dan -- It's a Summer show, and he's a teacher. He loves the game, is popular, and would probably enjoy being back.

Brian -- Even though he was out early, I could see him being asked back because CBS likes him, and he was popular.

Pick 1 (one) of 2 (two):
Renny -- Only could be asked back if Sheila isn't. Could see her doing it again.

Keesha -- Only if Daniele isn't in I think. She was well liked though, so she has a decent shot.

Big Brother 11

Definites:
Ronnie -- Villains tend to be asked back (Jase, Allison, and Jessie). So evil, loves the game, and would probably give it another shot.

Possible:
Casey -- Funny and well-liked. Even though he was out kind of early, definitely could see him going back.

Russell -- Brings excitement to the house, fairly good player.

Michele -- Had longevity, definitely desperate for attention. Warning: Completely changed since her time on the show.

Kevin -- OK strategic player, really deep in the maybe pile though.

Unlikely:
Jeff or Jordan -- Jordan said somewhere she was done with Reality TV and Jeff said he'd only do TAR again, not BB.

Big Brother 12

Possible:
Terry -- So far I like the cut of his jib.

Overall:

Eric
Jen
Daniele
Chelsia
Ryan
Dan
Brian
Renny
Ronnie
Casey
BB12
BB12
Any Other

There's no way Dick would turn All Stars down, no matter what he says, he's the one person I expect to definitely be there.

I really REALLY hope that the cast is absolutely nothing like this. They would really have a hard time trying to explain how at least 4 of those people are Allstars.

And also, I really cant see Dick or Jeff turning them down. I'd put money on them both being there - im not a fan of either, but they are two of the genuine stars to come from the second era.

This thread has made me realise how much I loved the contestants in BB10; Dan, Keesha, Rennie, Libra, Brian...

I think I'd quite happily miss all of the BB9 contestants out and just have more of BB8 and BB10.

If Dick is on All-Stars, I hope everyone would vote him out soon.

bb8-Jen, Eric
bb9-Sharon
bb10-Dan, Libra, Memphis, and Renny
bb11-Jeff, Kevin, and Michelle

I really want Annie and Eric to go in to AS2 and have a twist alliance

I think if Annie had made it to the point that she needed to she'd have been a certainty for Allstars 2, but I guess not now.

There's quite a few others I could see as potential Allstars, but it all depends on how they do I suppose.

Thinking at the moment that Andrew has guaranteed a place on Allstars if he wanted it, just for that speech alone.

I'd be very surprised if Rachel didnt return too. She's different to many of the other women who could realistically return, and she's already established herself as a major player this season. Even if she goes in the next few weeks, I think Rachel will be back next year.

Matt would be a safe bet too, and depending on their performance, I could possibly see returns for Enzo, Hayden, Brendon and Britney.

I think Britney would definitely come back if she makes it through next few weeks. I think Rachel too.

Yep, from this season right now I'd say Rachel and Britney are extremely likely, they are gauranteed to make the Jury now too (unless Rachel suddenly decides to turn on Britney and nominate her this week).

From the men, I'm not sure. Matt thinks he's All Star material, I'm not so sure. I think Brendon could have a shot if he makes it further, and same goes for Enzo.

I really hope All Stars 2 is next year. I'm actually looking forward to seeing some of these people play again, especially Dan, Jen, Keesha, and yes, even Dick.

I guess Britney has the advantage of being totally different personality wise than the other blonde girls. I could see Britney & one of the others being around, whereas its hard to imagine a Jordan/Keesha/Daniele combination.

Im totally down in my hopes of Keesha coming back. Even though she was successful and popular in her season, Jordan was more successful and more popular in hers. I'd like to see both back, but I just dont think it'll happen.

Keesha should die her hair red or something if she wants to come back.

I'm not sure if Jordan would want to play again, so that might help Keesha's chances.