What was Robin thinking?!

-Sid-

31-01-2010

A 3.0 for Emily's clumsy and heavily aided routine and only half a mark more for Mikey who was so much more competent and dynamic?

I have a great deal of respect for Robin, but that was a very strange way to score indeed.

soapgirlhere

31-01-2010

He did admit afterward that he was slightly generous to Emily though.

yohinnchild

31-01-2010

It probably helped equal out Dumb (Nicky) and Dumbers (Jason) scores

-Sid-

31-01-2010

Originally Posted by soapgirlhere:
“He did admit afterward that he was slightly generous to Emily though.”

True, but then I expected him to adjust his subsequent scores and be a little generous to everyone.

0.5 points between two routines of such differing standards was bewildering.

azureanne

31-01-2010

The whole judging this year has been a bit haphazard. I think they want the attention Jason gets so are all being a bit controversial (sp)

iem

31-01-2010

Originally Posted by azureanne:
“The whole judging this year has been a bit haphazard. I think they want the attention Jason gets so are all being a bit controversial (sp)”

I think you are right about that!

Fudd

31-01-2010

Originally Posted by yohinnchild:
“It probably helped equal out Dumb (Nicky) and Dumbers (Jason) scores”

I thought Nicky's scores and comments were accurate tonight TBF. Maybe it was Robin's night to be strange?