Wow Sherlock! Actually, I DO like Charlie - I had her top of my list last week, if you want to look for it. The pattern's in your head! I think you think I'm being bitchy because of Emily's youth and beauty but it's her skating I find fault with.

LOL!

I've often championed attractive young females on reality shows - Rachel Stevens on Strictly, Sophie and Nicola on Big Brother, Suzanne Shaw on DOI.

Your theory is totally flawed.

You seem to have a chip on your shoulder because I happen to have disliked contestants that you do like.

I suggest you stick to defending your favourites instead of getting personal with other users - it's not very good forum etiquette.

Yeah, MACTOWIN, your theory stinks - I got no end of stick on these forums previously for supporting beautiful blonde Zoe Salmon from the 'she's all looks and no substance' brigade. I just think Emily's skating is pants, OK?!

I think its Fred that is geting voted through, Emily is lucky to have him.

Ditto!

I was full of praise for and often defended Zoe last year.

I voted for Emily. I think she seems fun.

Maybe, just maybe, Sid dislikes Emily because her skating is awful and she behaves like a spoiled immature Princess? I know thats my reason for disliking her, she simply isnt very good. End of. No jealousy at all.

I would agree if it wasn't for the fact Fred has been in more skateoffs than practically all the other Pros put together - 12!!!!!

If Fred was THAT popular he would've performed far far better with all of his female celebs

She is one of the prettiest girls ever on DOI but also one of the most mediocre female skaters.

Zoe was a weird one for me some weeks I liked her some weeks she had me flinging things at the tv!

I like Emily and generally stick a vote her way, partly because I think she has potential, partly for Fred and cos I think she's quite funny. I vote for Mikey and Daniella as well and as long as it neither of those two I don't mind her staying at the expense of someone higher up the leaderboard.

Thanks Vodka

Half my girlfriends are cute blondes. So to suggest I dislike Emily because she is cute and blonde is preposterous!

I judge on skating and personality. And Emily hasn't impressed me with either yet.

Firstly Zoe is not attractive she is not in the same league as Emily and also my theory does not stink it has been shown a number of times that good looking women on reality shows tend to do badly as the majority of voters are females who tend to vote for the Men. I am sorry but I cant help the fact that women tend to be intimidated by good looking confident Females.

If Fred was that popular Zaraah would've won and Melinda would've made the final!

Zoe was a beauty queen and won Miss Northern Ireland contest.

I think Zoe is beautiful.

That's cool Jill

I've often voted for celebrities in these sorts of shows just because I happen to like them or because of who they're partnered with. Nothing wrong with that at all

Mikey and Daniella are totally winning me over. I adore them both.

I've not voted so far this series though. Bit broke after Big Bro and Strictly!

OK MACTOWIN I'll stop being argumentative. After all I started it by highlighting your comment and challenging it. I'm not intimidated by Emily, I'm just not keen on her skating. Is that OK with you?

Yes but she was the only one that entered.

OK score draw.

Im sorry, but this is your personal opinion only. You might think that Zoe is not attractive, but plenty of men do. Zoe was quite stunning looking imo. But this is my own personal opinion. You shouldnt assume that everyone will agree with you about what is attractive and what is not.

I tend to agree with those who say your theory is daft as well. There have been plenty of good looking women do well in reality shows, Alesha Dixon, Leona Lewis, Rachel Stevens, Sophie Reade etc. I could go on.

I find some of your comments to be quite personal. Trawling through people's posting histories and finding mud to sling at them is unessecary and direspectful.

Post not showing

I get that feeling with her too ........

Cheers!

Zoe also was 20th in the FHM's sexiest 100 Women poll.

Yeah. Zoe was incrediably pretty. Tall and slender, quite model like. I know its only personal opinion, but I find Emily quite bimbo-ish looking. Too much back combing off her hair, and far too much make up. Maybe if she toned it down a bit?