She often seems to marks the same way as Jason.
I really don't like her being a judge on the show because I don't believe her comments are sincere at all.
She can be really mean to some competitors and really simperingly nice about others. It all depends who her friend Gardiner likes.

Her remarks are completely random IMO. Why do they think they need 2 judges who don't know about skating? What does her 'expertise' in performance consist of exactly - walking and singing at the same time or a few wacky dance routines in the Spice Girl years?

why don't they get Ricky Gervais on the panel, he's a good dancer!

I actually think she's really good, she's marking on what she knows and that's exactly what she should do.

. I agree with you on both. Emma is a bit like Jason imo. From the minute she sat on the panel she has been cocky, she is out to make a name for herself on the show a bit like the other nonentity. She was a bit more simpering last night but i agree her comments are random and quite frankly irelivant.

Emma's comments seem fine to me, I don't always agree with her but she seems able to justify her point of view if she needs to. The other judges can make some bizarre comments and give inexplicable scores sometimes, and they are professionals, so she's not doing too badly.

I agree & I like her on the panel

I find Emma insincere, it is just a gut feeling

Cant stand her on the panel she is pointless. I would get rid of her and Robin and keep the other 3.

Why Robin, hes the one on the panel who actually knows what hes talking about!

His marks are awful, he is boring.

Like him or not Jason makes the right noices and also like Nicky.

I don't mind her, her comments are just as relevant as the rest. After all we don't all agree on this forum - there is some personal preference that's all we can speak on really!

Have to agree robin bores me to tears