[duncann]

Going through: Crystal Bowersox; Lilly Scott; Didi Benami; Siobhan Magnus; Janell Wheeler; Katelyn Epperly; Paige Miles

Wrong song: Lacey Brown

Forgettable: Michelle Delamor - so calculated and perfect in every way it doesn't work

Bad: Ashley Rodriguez

Dreadful: Haeley Vaughn

Even more dreadful: Katie Stevens

[Rose60]

Originally Posted by Tortue

I didn't think any of the girls did themselves justice but I agree with you about Katie. She has that awful kermitty sound to her voice. I didn't like her at all

LOL at your spot on description of kermitty (took me a while to work out what you meant).

[Tiffani]

Originally Posted by choochoo

Be interesting to see how well Katie does with Feelin' Good as I know in previous years its been the kiss of death (apart from AL on AI and DJ on XF who both did the Muse version)

Adam Lambert and Danyl Johnson ended up in the bottom 2 after singing that song so there could be something the public dont like about it.

[twinkletoez]

Originally Posted by Tiffani

Adam Lambert and Danyl Johnson ended up in the bottom 2 after singing that song so there could be something the public dont like about it.

Also, in season six (I think) a girl and a guy both sang it, and they both went home.

I forgot that Adam was B2 though, I loved his version!

[Chi]

Ranking the performances rather than the singers who haven't done enough so for me to have an opinion.

Enjoyable:
1. Siobhan Magnus
2. Lilly Scott

Nice and polished:
4. Didi Benami
3. Crystal Bowersox

Divas trying too hard:
5. Katie Stevens
6. Michelle Delamor
7. Katelyn Epperly


8.9.10.11.12 Ashley Rodriguez/Haeley Vaughan/Lacey Brown/Paige Miles/Janell Wheeler

[simplydabest]

Originally Posted by Agent Krycek

Who ever gets the pimp spot on the opening shows has NEVER won Idol. They're pimping Katie as the chosen one at the moment, but I expect it to switch once the competition settles down a bit.

Taylor Hicks and Katharine McPhee had the pimp spots in the first semi-final round in Season 5

[danielleh]

1. Didi Benami
2. Lilly Scott
3. Siobhan Magnus
4. Katelyn Epperly
5. Crystal Bowersox
6. Paige Miles
7. Lacey Brown (like her and her voice, but didn't do too well)
8. Janell Wheeler
9. Haeley Vaughn
10. Michelle Delamor
11. Katie Stevens
12. Ashley Rodriguez

[robbies_gal]

i only really like a couple but

1. lilly scott i think shes unique and ha a great tone definitely one to watch
2. crystal-another good voice with lots of style
3. siobhan thought she done a good job on a very hard song sung by a male
4. didi-i didnt know the sound but thought she sang well
5. paige-great voice not sure shes original enough

the rest im not bothered about though i must add how annyoing is haeley she smiled like a stage school brat during her song and was all over the place wot a mess dont know why shes still there