I have requested a poll

Your favourite guy?

Aaron Kelly
Alex Lambert
Andrew Garcia
Casey James
Lee DeWyze
Michael Lynche
Tim Urban
Todrick Hall

Casey, Lee and Alex are the only 3 I'd like to go far.

Andrew and Michael are alright too.

Casey is the only decent one. Luckily he is brilliant.

The rest are meh.

Lee - zero personality, zero likeability, a wet blanket, should go soon.
Andrew - overrated, ruined YGMS last week, not good at all.
Alex - overrated completely. Look, voice is horrible and no star quality.

Mike is probably the only other decent one thinking about it.

But every other male is dull dull dull this year :sleep:

The boys have really thrown me this year, thus far;
Aaron has a great, big voice but doesn't seem comfortable on stage;
Alex, who I couldn;'t believe had actually gotten through was rather good this week (even with the mullet);
Andrew has an amazing voice but needs to pick an actually good song;
Casey, who I didn't think should have been picked was great the first week and okay the second and really needs to finish his phrasings when he sings;
Lee is now the front-runner, which is great because I don't remember seeing him during the whole auditions process!;
Michael should/will do well;
Tim is a bit useless;
Todrick is um...unique!

Casey is the only one with any charisma, and he needs to get his vocals sorted.

Lee has a gravelly rocker voice but is dull as ditchwater.

Michael has stage presence and a good voice and will do well in his niche.

Todrick is okay but overcooks everything so unpredictable.

Can't stand the rest - all bland, overhyped, and not worthy so far. Tim Urban being the worst.

I'd like to see Casey, Lee, Andrew and Alex go further. Not too bothered about the others at the mo.

Casey at the moment by a mile, but he's way below several of the girls.

Andrew - massive disappointment, seems very one trick with Straight up
Lee - sorry, not seeing it, started to get very nasally on his vocals and that's a pet hate of mine.
Alex - could be a dark horse, vast improvement this week, but needs to conquer the nerves
Todrick - umm, no real idea how he's still there, not great vocals and some very negative stories out there.
Michael - okay, but doesn't thrill me at all
Aaron - decent voice, doesn't seem at ease on the stage at all.
Tim - getting the tween/teen vote I suspect, awful and I wish he'd go, but suspect he's there for a fair few more weeks yet.

Lee and Casey, with Andrew being 3rd.

My fave is Casey. Also, my boyfriend likes Andrew.

Lee DeWyze, but at the same time, I rate 6/8 of the girls higher than him. Alex is second man, and the rest I really dont care about.

Lee. Easily.

Alex Lambert at the mo.

Also like Andrew and Lee.

Alex Lambert.

Voted for Alex Lambert this week. I also like Lee and Casey.

Casey is still my favourite although he wasn't great this week. I also quite like Andrew, but he hasn't matched his Hollywood performances yet.

Lee is good but he looks far too self-absorbed to me and therefore I find him unlikeable. Alex is OK but I wish he'd lose the awful Mullet.

Casey is head and shoulders above the rest for me. Not just in height either.

He seems like the most real and authentic artist, who has a liking for rocking out. Now that's my type of performer.

Is Lee joint-winning? lmao
The boys losing out to him MUST be dire.

Alex and Lee

Other than Big Mike, they all kind of stink.

Alex being there at all is a huge waste of our time.

It seems Alex really splits opinion. I thought he was great this week but some people really don't like him...

I can’t vote on this yet. It’s too early for me.

Lee is probably the best, although if Aaron and Alex both have excellent voices and if they just got a bit more confident, they could do very well.

I really love Andrew Garcia although he needs to think about choosing songs he can bring some intensity to (like he did with Straight Up), instead of taking intense songs and making them mellow (like he did with Sugar).

It’s going to be fun finding out who excels and who falls behind.

I can’t believe 5 people voted for Tim Urban! Come… on!

I know right. I really want to know why...

So come on Tim Urban voters - what is it about him that got the votes?

Actually I can sort of see the appeal of Tim. He’s not a fantastic singer, but he is such a charismatic guy that you sort of want to vote for him because he’s your mate or something. (Or, as Simon usually says… “You have, what I call, the likeability factor”.)

Lee for me.

Alex, Lee and Casey I think. Theyre obviously wanting a girl to win this year. so much stronger.