Originally Posted by leaby:
“I think what bothers me about the charts is that it isn't necessarily the 'best' one of the bunch that gets #1 - it's the one that's had the hype, publicity and promotion... this may well be linked with the fact that it's a 'good' song - but I really do think this is rare, otherwise the charts would surely be more versatile than they are.
I'm not one of these types that will write off a song because it's in the charts and therefore it must mean that it's rubbish - Owl City/Alesha Keyes? Hell yes! But to say that sales = units of credibility to a tune is quite likely untrue... It's highly unlikely to be coincidence that The X Factor dictated the majority of #1's from October - December last year, for example. And would ANYBODY admit that Jedward feat. Vanilla Ice was actually good? I love the song, I downloaded it myself, but it got to #2 and it really is a pile of crap, musically speaking
I wish I'd lived in a time when publicity didn't dictate the charts (as my Dad put it, once upon a time people would go out and buy a record because it was good), but when you've essentially got corporate fatcats behind the whole thing, obsessed with making money above everything else, it's unlikely to ever be that way again.
Best thing is to not take it too seriously I guess - great music is always out there in some form or other (and now more accessible than ever)... listen to The Chart Show, complain a bit, maybe hear a half decent track or two, and then stick your Pod on and forget about it
”
“I think what bothers me about the charts is that it isn't necessarily the 'best' one of the bunch that gets #1 - it's the one that's had the hype, publicity and promotion... this may well be linked with the fact that it's a 'good' song - but I really do think this is rare, otherwise the charts would surely be more versatile than they are.
I'm not one of these types that will write off a song because it's in the charts and therefore it must mean that it's rubbish - Owl City/Alesha Keyes? Hell yes! But to say that sales = units of credibility to a tune is quite likely untrue... It's highly unlikely to be coincidence that The X Factor dictated the majority of #1's from October - December last year, for example. And would ANYBODY admit that Jedward feat. Vanilla Ice was actually good? I love the song, I downloaded it myself, but it got to #2 and it really is a pile of crap, musically speaking

I wish I'd lived in a time when publicity didn't dictate the charts (as my Dad put it, once upon a time people would go out and buy a record because it was good), but when you've essentially got corporate fatcats behind the whole thing, obsessed with making money above everything else, it's unlikely to ever be that way again.
Best thing is to not take it too seriously I guess - great music is always out there in some form or other (and now more accessible than ever)... listen to The Chart Show, complain a bit, maybe hear a half decent track or two, and then stick your Pod on and forget about it
”
There was never such a time, people look back with rose tinted glasses to a 'better time' as long as there has been popular music and charts there have been people manipulating them with the publicity machines, its just now we can see the mechanisms more clearly...and just as many 'crap songs' charted all those years ago, its just only the 'good' ones have lived on leaving the impression music was much better back then.
In 20 years will we remember Jedward and Tinne Tempah? Most probably not (we'll probably forget 99% of the music and artists of today) Will we claim that people only bought good music in 2010 compared to the mufactured crap in 2030? Most probably yes!!!



