• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • TV Shows: Reality
  • Past Reality Shows
  • Dancing On Ice: All Stars
Who would you have saved in every skate off so far this series?
xKatieLx
14-03-2010
OK all posts must be about this and not arguing about why would you save this person etc.

Post here who you would save and why you'd save them.

Here's who's been in the skate off

Week 1- Sinitta & Sharron
Week 2- Gary & Bobby
Week 3- Sharron & Jeremy
Week 4- Tana & Danny
Week 5- Heather & Kieron
Week 6- Danny & Hilary
Week 7- Emily & Sharron
Week 8- Emily & Danniella
Week 9- Mikey & Danniella
Week 10- Kieron & Danny


Week 1- I would of saved Sharron although Sinitta was better judging solely on that skate Sharron was better as Sinitta messed up the frog lift.
Week 2- I'd of saved Gary cause he could skate and move around the rink.
Week 3- Sharron because although I loved Jeremy for pure skating reasons Sharron did great difficult lifts and skated well.
Week 4- Danny because everything was better than Tana.
Week 5- Kieron cause he skated better, did better lifts, skated on his own and did a fun skate.
Week 6- Danny because I have a brain.
Week 7- Emily because Sharron was a b*tch and Emily was a better skater in that skate off.
Week 8- Danniella cause she skated better although that skate off was closer than I expected.
Week 9- Not sure that was the hardest decision but I probobaly would of saved Danniella cause she performed better and she was very close to doing the required element correctly and skated much better than Mikey.
Week 10- Kieron cause Danny mucked up.

So overall I saved everybody that went through in the skate off.
reclinewithme
14-03-2010
I would have saved Sinitta in week 1 because although the frog lift went wrong, overall she was more elegant and assured than Sharron.

All the other weeks I've agreed with the judges' majority verdict.
CombatHamster
14-03-2010
Originally Posted by reclinewithme:
“I would have saved Sinitta in week 1 because although the frog lift went wrong, overall she was more elegant and assured than Sharron.

All the other weeks I've agreed with the judges' majority verdict.”

Ditto. In light of Sharron's last week I'm betting the judges all wish they had saved Sinitta back in week 1
ianswaiting
14-03-2010
OK all posts must be about this and not arguing about why would you save this person etc.

Post here who you would save and why you'd save them.

Here's who's been in the skate off

Week 1- Sinitta & Sharron Sharron
Week 2- Gary & Bobby Gary
Week 3- Sharron & Jeremy Sharron
Week 4- Tana & Danny Tana
Week 5- Heather & Kieron Kieron
Week 6- Danny & Hilary Danny
Week 7- Emily & Sharron Emily
Week 8- Emily & Danniella Danniella
Week 9- Mikey & Danniella Danniella
Week 10- Kieron & Danny Danny
Fudd
14-03-2010
Week 1- Sinitta & Sharron
Week 2- Gary & Bobby
Week 3- Sharron & Jeremy
Week 4- Tana & Danny
Week 5- Heather & Kieron
Week 6- Danny & Hilary
Week 7- Emily & Sharron
Week 8- Emily & Danniella
Week 9- Mikey & Danniella
Week 10- Kieron & Danny

Week 1: I would've saved Sinitta
Week 2: I would've saved Gary
Week 3: I would've saved Sharron
Week 4: I would've saved Danny
Week 5: I would've saved Kieron
Week 6: I would've saved Danny
Week 7: I would've saved Emily
Week 8: I would've saved Danniella
Week 9: I would've saved Mikey
Week 10: I would've saved Danny
Strictly_Irish
14-03-2010
The only time I disagrees with the judges was the week Mikey went home. Thought the required element should have saved him.

Though I kind of wish Sinitta had been saved just because the week 1 skate off is no indication. Gary has obviously gained popularity and Donal came 2nd after the week one skate off. They should just scrap it, to be honest!
Eejit
14-03-2010
Only time I've disagreed with the judges really was Sinitta. She should really have stayed.

They generally get it right though.
Jim Kowalski
14-03-2010
I would have saved Sharron every time;I would never tire of those outfits
Tiger Rose
15-03-2010
Only time I have disagreed was last week when Mikey should have been saved. I felt their overall performance was about the same level (only 0.5 difference in their scores so judges also seemed to agree here) and that's when the required element should come into play with Mikey clearly the best.
Eviesmum
15-03-2010
Week 1- Sinitta & Sharron
Week 2- Gary & Bobby
Week 3- Sharron & Jeremy
Week 4- Tana & Danny
Week 5- Heather & Kieron
Week 6- Danny & Hilary
Week 7- Emily & Sharron
Week 8- Emily & Danniella
Week 9- Mikey & Danniella
Week 10- Kieron & Danny

That's not to say I agree with who's been in the bottom 2 every week, this week being one of them.
Rach1989
15-03-2010
Week 1- Sinitta & Sharron Sinitta
Week 2- Gary & Bobby Gary
Week 3- Sharron & Jeremy Jeremy
Week 4- Tana & Danny Danny
Week 5- Heather & Kieron Kieron
Week 6- Danny & Hilary Danny
Week 7- Emily & Sharron Emily
Week 8- Emily & Danniella Danniella
Week 9- Mikey & Danniella Danniella
Week 10- Kieron & Danny Kieron
CaroUK
15-03-2010
Week 1- Sinitta & Sharron Sharron
Week 2- Gary & Bobby Gary
Week 3- Sharron & Jeremy Sharron
Week 4- Tana & Danny Danny
Week 5- Heather & Kieron Kieron
Week 6- Danny & Hilary Danny
Week 7- Emily & Sharron Emily
Week 8- Emily & Danniella Danniella
Week 9- Mikey & Danniella Danniella
Week 10- Kieron & Danny Kieron
Olls~
15-03-2010
Week 1- Sinitta & Sharron
Week 2- Gary & Bobby
Week 3- Sharron & Jeremy
Week 4- Tana & Danny
Week 5- Heather & Kieron
Week 6- Danny & Hilary
Week 7- Emily & Sharron
Week 8- Emily & Danniella
Week 9- Mikey & Danniella
Week 10- Kieron & Danny
MaryS
15-03-2010
I've agreed with the judges apart from 3 weeks.I would have saved Sinitta,she had a more difficult routine & i thought showed more promise.I thought Mikey deserved to go through,his required element was bang on & there wasn't much diference in their routines & scores.I think Danny should have stayed too,i think he put more into his routine.Ok,he dropped the hat but the required element didn't seem to matter much last week!
lach doch mal
15-03-2010
To be truthful, I don't know. I think Sunita maybe should not have gone in the first week (maybe we shouldn't have a skate off in the first two weeks).

In Emily's and Daniella's week, it was really difficult as both messed up a lot.

I also agree with some that last week the required element wasn't as important, and this week it seemed to be important.

Difficult, most of the time, they probably do get it right, I'm just pleased I'm not one of the judges.
River Man
15-03-2010
Week 1- Sinitta & Sharron (she had miles more potential than the wooden Sharron
Week 2- Gary & Bobby
Week 3- Sharron & Jeremy (Jeremy was starting to show some potentail)
Week 4- Tana & Danny
Week 5- Heather & Kieron
Week 6- Danny & Hilary
Week 7- Emily & Sharron
Week 8- Emily & Danniella (as much as I love Danniella, it was her worst week and Emily's best.
Week 9- Mikey & Danniella (not even close)
Week 10- Kieron & Danny
Saturn
15-03-2010
Week 1- Sinitta & Sharron
Week 2- Gary & Bobby
Week 3- Sharron & Jeremy
Week 4- Tana & Danny
Week 5- Heather & Kieron
Week 6- Danny & Hilary
Week 7- Emily & Sharron
Week 8- Emily & Danniella
Week 9- Mikey & Danniella
Week 10- Kieron & Danny
Reality Sucks
15-03-2010
Week 1- Sinitta & Sharron - I think Sharron was saved because they thought she would potentially be better as she was an Olympic athlete
Week 2- Gary & Bobby - Who???
Week 3- Sharron & Jeremy
Week 4- Tana & Danny
Week 5- Heather & Kieron At that point I thought Heather was doing better than Kieron
Week 6- Danny & Hilary
Week 7- Emily & Sharron
Week 8- Emily & Danniella
Week 9- Mikey & Danniella
Week 10- Kieron & Danny
d.tugby
15-03-2010
Week 1- Sinitta & Sharron
Week 2- Gary & Bobby
Week 3- Sharron & Jeremy
Week 4- Tana & Danny
Week 5- Heather & Kieron
Week 6- Danny & Hilary
Week 7- Emily & Sharron
Week 8- Emily & Danniella
Week 9- Mikey & Danniella
Week 10- Kieron & Danny
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map