idol had an all stars competition



this is who i'd bring back


david cook

kris allen

taylor hicks

adam lambert

david archuleta

chris daughtry

ruben studdard

kelly clarkson

danny gokey

allison iraheta

blake lewis

how about you guys

Definitely no Taylor for me, and I would need Jordin to be included. Not sure whether for Allstars it'd need to be quite highly-placed contestants, but I did like Kellie Pickler as well - might have her over Allison, but I do quite like your list

Would also add Siobhan if she's allowed

xxxx

Kelly Clarkson
Ruben Studdart
Clay Aiken
Fantasia Barrino
Carrie Underwood
Bo Bice
Taylor Hicks
Chris Daughtry
Jordin Sparks
David Cook
Kris Allen
Adam Lambert

i like your picks too

thank you

David Cook
Chris Daughtry
Danny Gokey
Bo Rice
Michael Johns
Adam Lambert

Latoya London
Carrie Underwood
Kellie Pickler
Kelly Clarkson
Melinda Dolittle
Fantasia Burrino

Those would be my favourites

Kris Allen
Casey James
Jason Castro
----------------
----------------
----------------

Syesha Mercado
Didi Benami
Kelly Clarkson
Jennifer Hudson
Allison Iraheta
Megan Joy

Thats an amazing lineup mine would be similar, but:

Chris Daughtry
Adam Lambert
Bo Bice
David COok
Elliott Yamin
Gedeon Mckinney (best singer not to make it to top 12)

LAtoya London
Melinda DOlittle
Kelly Clarckson
Jordin Sparks
Kelly Pickler
Katharine Mcphee

I would choose exactly the same. I wouldn't include Jennifer Hudson as she does not fit the Idol programme. I think she does fine on her own. I am not sure about Chris Daughtry as he is better as part of a band, rather than alone.

wildcard pick elliot yamin

David Cook
Michael Johns
Adam Lambert
Chris Daughtry
Bo Bice
Elliott Yamin
Carrie Underwood
Kelly Clarkson
Melinda Dolittle
Katherine McPhee
Carly Smithson
Allison Iraheta



That can be said for several others far more than for Jennifer.

If we're allowed Gedeon, I'd have him too - and definitely Arianna Afsar, maybe even a few others too!

xxxx

I didn't watch seasons 1, 2 and 4, and I only watched a bit of season 3, so my allstars are going to be a bit biased in favour of the later seasons.

Kelly Clarkson
Jennifer Hudson
Carrie Underwood
Jordin Sparks
Carly Smithson
Allison Iraheta

Bo Bice
Chris Daughtry
Blake Lewis
David Cook
Michael Johns
Adam Lambert

I would probably take out Jordin and Blake and replace them with contestants from this year, but it's too early to tell who yet.

Elliot Yamin
Adam Lambert
Melinda Dolittle
Chris Allen
Latoya London
Carrie Underwood
Kelly Clarkson
Melinda Dolittle
Fantasia Burrino
Chris Daughtry
David Cook
Anwar Robinson
Clay Aiken
Gedeon McKinney
Patrick Hall
Joseph Murena
Kimberley Lock


All my favs from the past and some didn't make it to the top 12

Not interested in any of them from this year, when you look back at the past seasons contestants they wouldn't stand a chance, shame

Adam Lambert
Patrick Hall
Bo Bice
Michael Johns
David Cook
Elliott Yamin

Carly Smithson
Allison Iraheta
Melinda Dolittle
Katherine McPhee
Carrie Underwood
Kelly Clarkson

good thread. i don't think i watched seasons 2 or 3, so there might be some good name missing from my list

kelly clarkson
carrie underwood
jennifer hudson
allison iraheta
siobhan magnus
crystal bowersox

chris daughtry
david cook
michael johns
adam lambert
danny gokey

interesting picks you guys

Fantasia
Elliot Yamin
Chris Daughtry
Melinda Doolittle
Carrie (Only because she won but I find her boring )
Kelly
David Cook
Adam Lambert

That's about it

David Cook
Adam Lambert
Matt Giraud
Clay Aiken
Michael Johns
Chris Daughtry

Kelly Clarkson
Alison Iraheta
Jennifer Hudson
Carrie Underwood
Latoya London
Jordin Sparks

jamar rogers

thaddeus johnson

angela martin

i'd consider

My ideal line-up would be - in sort of alphabetical order (including this season so far):

Archie
Adam Lambert
Bo Bice
David C
Daughtrey
Gokey

Carrie
Crystal
Fantasia
Jordin
Kelly C
Melinda Doolittle

With Sanjaya as the interval act

oh no not sanjaya!!!!!

My ideal top 12 would be

Kelly Clarkson
Tamyra Gray
Latoya London
Kat Mcphee
Elliot Yamin
Chris Daughtry
Adam Lambert
Melinda Doolittle
Vonsell Solomon
David Cook
Michael Johns
Diana DeGarmo