6 idol contestants take on 6 x factor contestants

name your singers top 12

runner ups and other highly placed contestants may be included

my draft picks for ai

david cook

adam lambert

taylor hicks

ruben studdard

danny gokey

kris allen

x factor draft picks

rhydian

joe mcelderry

leona lewis

shayne ward

danyl johnson

jls





host ryan seacreast

judges would be

from x factor

simon cowell
cheryl cole

from ai

randy jackson
kara dioguardi

if this were to go down who would you pick

You haven't picked the best XF contestants there or judges, I'd of picked Diana Vickers, Ruth Lorenzo, Rhydian Roberts, Leona Lewis, Shayne Ward, JLS & Ben Mills.

Judges, Simon because he's a dick obviously, and Dannii since she knows what she's on about and is constructive and isn't a tabloid fodder.

AI

Kelly Clarkson
Carrie Underwood
David Cook
Adam Lambert
Chris Daughtry
Bo Bice


XF

Shayne Ward
Leona Lewis
Alexandra Burke
Joe McElderry
Rhydian Roberts
G4


Host

Dermot O'Leary


Judges

From XF

Simon Cowell
Dannii Minogue

From AI

Paula Abdul
Kara Dioguardi

AI
Carrie Underwood
Bo Bice
Melinda Dolittle
David Cook
Adam Lambert
Allison Iraheta

XF
Journey South
Leona Lewis
Ben Mills
Rhydian
Alexandra Burke
Joe McElderry

Host
Ryan Seacrest and Dermot O'Leary together

Judges
XF - Simon Cowell and Dannii Minogue
AI - Paula Abdul and Randy Jackson

American Idol:

Kelly Clarkson
Carrie Underwood
David Archuleta
David Cook
Adam Lambert
Kris Allen

X Factor:

Shayne Ward
Leona Lewis
Ray Quinn
JLS
Alexandra Burke
Joe McElderry

Host: Dermot O'Leary

Judges: Simon Cowell, Dannii Minogue, Randy Jackson and Kara Dioguardi

Host - Ryan Seahorse


Judges -

AI
Kara Dioguardi
Randy Jackson

X Factor
Cheryl Cole
Sharon Osborne


Contestants -

X Factor
Leona Lewis
Brenda Edwards
Rhydian Roberts
Laura White
Shayne Ward
Tabby Callaghan

(would include JLS, but against AI it's all solo artists)

AI
Kelly Clarkson
Adam Lambert
David Archuleta
Jennifer Hudson
Fantasia Burrino
Clay Aiken

(if we can choose from current contestants, I'd swap David Archuleta for Siobhan)

I found it difficult to leave Siobhan as she's a stand-out this season but it's an easy season to be a stand-out and the only other girl who I could see giving her a run for her money, Shelby, wasn't even put through to the last 24.

I stuck therefore to contestants who had at least made the final. Otherwise, I would have also included Patrick Hall among the chosen AI contestants.

for the purposes of this game,
x factor
groups
will
be

considered
a
solo
act,
so
jls
is
perfectly

fine

being american you'd expect me to support idol people only, but i love x factor just as much and can't wait till we get it

imagine the interaction between dermot and ryan