Ill start,

Id swop EMMA and replace her with ANGELA RIPPON. She really stood out to me and Id love to see her back again. She has the knowledge of been a dancer and also provided an image of "knowledge" been the oldest on the Panel. She reminded me of KRES (series 1) who I also liked. Angela also gave HER opinion aswell both good AND bad.

I'dget rid of Emma and bring back my favourite ever judge, Krez from Series 1!

Replace Emma with well anyone.

I'd replace Emma with either Bonnie, or if she couldnt do it as she's in the states, Suzanne. As they are experienced and qualified performers, can ice skate and know and love the show.

I'd replace Jason Gardiner with Craig Revel Horwood. ITV obviously are desperate to keep Jason because they love his comments, but he is so rude, nasty and personal sometimes. If they want a harsh judge, then Craig is perfect. He can be very harsh, but he is hardly ever personal. Not only that, but he has previous experience of judging celebrities on ice from the one-off Strictly special a few years ago.

I'd get rid of Emma AND Jason and wouldn't bother replacing either of them!

Robin and Nicky are both choreographers of ICE shows - Robin has done Holiday on Ice for years and Nicky has done a few smaller ones including his own Ice Times. I think they are both more than capable of judging performances of ice skating/ dancing and so is Karen as she has been on the ice dancing scene for as long as they have.

The US version of Strictly works perfectly with 3 judges - and I think DOI would be the same!

I'd replace Jason Gardiner with the much more attractive Knitted Jason Gardiner from 'Harry Hills's TV Burp'.

I'd also introduce a new category in the TV Awards for the most unprofessional, rude, odious, obnoxious, self-centred, egotistical person on TV and there's be just one nominee - Jason Gardiner.

Simon Cowell and Piers Morgan lol?

They are both cuddly pussy cats compared with the vile JG.

Jason, he is past his sell by date. Emma, nice lady, but totally useless. They should bring in a winner from the past series. Or even let either allow T & D to pass judgement.

Replace Emma with Alesha Dixon. That would be well good.

Emma with anybody in the world.............. except Ruthie Henshall

And replace Nicky with me.

I'd love to be a DOI Judge.

Replace Emma with Katie the above poster

I'd lose Emma and bring in Series 1's Bonnie Langford who has an understanding of both the performance and skating.

I'd scrap them all, and just generate the scores using one of those National Lottery machines.

On the grounds that they seem to basically pick them at random as it is, most of the time...

Emma has to go

Replace her with either Angela Rippon or Camilla Dallerup

Yay!!! We should make a facebook campaign for me to become a judge.

Ditch Jason and Emma - and stick with 3 skating judges - they know all they need to know about presentation anyway.

I would replace Jason Gardiner with a tub of lard or Roland Rat (both are more intelligent and professional) but if ITV insist on a "bad boy" then Craig Revel-Horwood or James Jordan - who are far better qualified to judge "performance" than the odious Jason Gardiner. I would replace Emma Bunton with Ola Jordan or Erin Boag for the same reason.

But really I would prefer if they just left the Judges as Nicky, Karen and Robin and bring in Torville and Dean.

I'd vote for you.

Yes, 5 judges who know what they are talking about sounds good to me.

Only 2 people have said this so I've more fans than Nicky, Emma and Jason put together.

But that would require them to actually have an opinion about the skaters

And the scores..........

Karen- 3.0
Jason- 1.5
Robin- 2.0
Jayne- 6.0
Chris- 6.0

I would love it if Jayne and Chris saved up all their real opinions over the series and then released them at the end - would be amazing to know what they really though of everybody!