Originally Posted by yellowlabbie:
“Noooooooooooooooo not the Barrowman, anyone but the Barrowman.”
“Noooooooooooooooo not the Barrowman, anyone but the Barrowman.”
Like I said, lots of excellent "debates" to be had!!
Which judge would you swop and who would you replace them with?
3 of 3
Originally Posted by mandyxxxx:
“I'd replace Emma with John Barrowman. Ok, I know he's been a bit overexposed (possibly in more ways than one
) on tv lately, but....he has judging experience, can dance and perform, can skate (to some extent at least), knows what it's like to be a contestant and most importantly....he is loud enough to drown out Jason!!
As an added bonus, people seem to either love or hate him, so we could have some lovely arguments here.”
“I'd replace Emma with John Barrowman. Ok, I know he's been a bit overexposed (possibly in more ways than one
) on tv lately, but....he has judging experience, can dance and perform, can skate (to some extent at least), knows what it's like to be a contestant and most importantly....he is loud enough to drown out Jason!!As an added bonus, people seem to either love or hate him, so we could have some lovely arguments here.
”
Oh no mandy - the thought of him leaping out of his seat screaming - "Fantastic, fantastic, fantastic," or whatever fills me with dread.
He has a lot to answer for - I do believe he was a model for Meatloaf on Popstar to Operastar.
Originally Posted by heyjude:
“Against popular opinion, I'd get shot of Nicky, he has been so inconsistant with his marking and the comments of not enough speed on the ice:yawn:
Also there is only room for one argumentative judge - Jason wears that crown”
“Against popular opinion, I'd get shot of Nicky, he has been so inconsistant with his marking and the comments of not enough speed on the ice:yawn:
Also there is only room for one argumentative judge - Jason wears that crown
”
Jason has no divine right to be on the panel - let alone wear a crown.
Before DOI how many on this forum had heard of him? The only claim to fame of this talentless idiot is the rehearsed put down and the self satisfaction he displays after each insult.
Not much to offer when compared to the international skaters he is so keen to dismiss.
I used to quite like Jason but after this year loathe him. I would swap him for almost anyone. I do think at times he has a point but it is getting fewer and far between and his insults and put downs are beyond the pale at times.
Edited to add, I have just seen Mrs Robinsons post ^^ and agree Donal would be a brilliant judge and is so adorable.
Edited to add, I have just seen Mrs Robinsons post ^^ and agree Donal would be a brilliant judge and is so adorable.
I'd like to get rid of both the non skaters and replace them with - nobody. Three judges is enough and I'd like to hear all three of them after every skater, for the sake of consistency. Having five judges means that only two or three get heard and Jason is heard disproportionately often.
Originally Posted by The Swampster:
“I'd like to get rid of both the non skaters and replace them with - nobody. Three judges is enough and I'd like to hear all three of them after every skater, for the sake of consistency. Having five judges means that only two or three get heard and Jason is heard disproportionately often.”
“I'd like to get rid of both the non skaters and replace them with - nobody. Three judges is enough and I'd like to hear all three of them after every skater, for the sake of consistency. Having five judges means that only two or three get heard and Jason is heard disproportionately often.”
With three judges, maximum score would be 18 - doesn't sound as impressive as 30
3 of 3
