phillipa defo 
Results:Who should be the 11th Dorothy?
Camille
23 (9.62%)
Claire Harbourne
14 (5.86%)
Claire Hillier
24 (10.04%)
Emilie
29 (12.13%)
Emma
18 (7.53%)
Katie
15 (6.28%)
Phillipa
26 (10.88%)
Sarah
6 (2.51%)
Tasheka
42 (17.57%)
Tegan
42 (17.57%)
Voters: 239. You can't vote on this poll right now - are you signed in?
Poll : Who should be the 11th Dorothy?
3 of 3
Had to go for Tasheka, but could have chosen at least another 3 or 4 who I think could do justice to the part of Dorothy.
I honestly think the right ten went through and none of this 10 have a chance of actually winning the show.
However on this poll I voted for Sarah; I would like to hear more of her-she sounded like she had a good voice.
I don't really mind who does get through so long as it's not Emilie-her voice was the worst of all of them and she was out of tune for the majority of both of songs.
However on this poll I voted for Sarah; I would like to hear more of her-she sounded like she had a good voice.
I don't really mind who does get through so long as it's not Emilie-her voice was the worst of all of them and she was out of tune for the majority of both of songs.
Originally Posted by xfactorfan27:
“I honestly think the right ten went through and none of this 10 have a chance of actually winning the show.
”
“I honestly think the right ten went through and none of this 10 have a chance of actually winning the show.
”
I did think that but then again we have had to engage with these 10 more so than the "top" ten so far so it could mean that whoever eventually goes through as the eleventh does quite well as she'll already have supporters.
Is there a spoiler for this?
Surely they cant be hosting the other nine Dorothy's in London and practicing their songs, when they knew at 8:30pm on Sat evening who would have had the most votes?
Surely they cant be hosting the other nine Dorothy's in London and practicing their songs, when they knew at 8:30pm on Sat evening who would have had the most votes?
Originally Posted by Evilredzebra:
“I did think that but then again we have had to engage with these 10 more so than the "top" ten so far so it could mean that whoever eventually goes through as the eleventh does quite well as she'll already have supporters.”
“I did think that but then again we have had to engage with these 10 more so than the "top" ten so far so it could mean that whoever eventually goes through as the eleventh does quite well as she'll already have supporters.”
Very true. Just look at David Sneddon from Fame Academy 1 - he was the public voted-in wildcard and he went onto win the show........
Originally Posted by Evilredzebra:
“I did think that but then again we have had to engage with these 10 more so than the "top" ten so far so it could mean that whoever eventually goes through as the eleventh does quite well as she'll already have supporters.”
“I did think that but then again we have had to engage with these 10 more so than the "top" ten so far so it could mean that whoever eventually goes through as the eleventh does quite well as she'll already have supporters.”
Normally I would agree and I think that will keep the 11th girl in for a few weeks, but I still don't see anyone there talented enough to outsing the likes of Dani, Sophie, Steph, Stephanie, Amy, in fact any of the other ten!!!
I'm also shocked Claire Harbourne didn't go through. She looks like the total package to me. And it looks like she hasn't a hope in hell of getting the wildcard slot.
I think Emilie has a very good chance and she comes across beautifully on stage, though vocally she's a bit unreliable - but I'd still be pleased to see her go through. Though I don't rate Claire Hilliard's voice she was the only one who sang OTR in such a way that gave me a reason to vote for her. She was defiant and aggressive and I thought she would be a good alternative Dorothy for the lineup.
Camille would make a very safe, traditional Dorothy, but there are already a couple through like that so I'm not sure I see the point. I find Katie's stage presence irritating and I cannot listen to Sarah's voice.
Emma is pretty as a picture but vocally very weak. Tegan is way too over the top for me, but she did act OTR well. Phillippa was good in her group numbers, but gave such an insipid rendition of OTR that I couldn't bring myself to vote for her. Tash didn't make much of an impression either way.
Hmm, so hoping for a Claire Harbourne miracle.
I think Emilie has a very good chance and she comes across beautifully on stage, though vocally she's a bit unreliable - but I'd still be pleased to see her go through. Though I don't rate Claire Hilliard's voice she was the only one who sang OTR in such a way that gave me a reason to vote for her. She was defiant and aggressive and I thought she would be a good alternative Dorothy for the lineup.
Camille would make a very safe, traditional Dorothy, but there are already a couple through like that so I'm not sure I see the point. I find Katie's stage presence irritating and I cannot listen to Sarah's voice.
Emma is pretty as a picture but vocally very weak. Tegan is way too over the top for me, but she did act OTR well. Phillippa was good in her group numbers, but gave such an insipid rendition of OTR that I couldn't bring myself to vote for her. Tash didn't make much of an impression either way.
Hmm, so hoping for a Claire Harbourne miracle.
Originally Posted by celebmania:
“Very true. Just look at David Sneddon from Fame Academy 1 - he was the public voted-in wildcard and he went onto win the show........”
“Very true. Just look at David Sneddon from Fame Academy 1 - he was the public voted-in wildcard and he went onto win the show........”
Actually it was Sinead that the public voted in as a wild card. David was rejected and only joined later after a girl dropped out due to illness.
We didn't do too well at picking the winner; Emilie came a mere third in our poll
3 of 3
