Originally Posted by C14E:
“He definitely likes them, but they have both done very well out of the experience and have new opportunities to move on to (although Amanda is rapidly using up her opportunities in the UK!). And Piers always seems pretty aware that there's a good chance of him being fired at some point. I think Piers could stay on AGT (it's Howie Mandel that I'd have never hired... good old NBC!)
There's one very high profile, funny, former talent show judge currently looking for work... Jonathan Ross? He would be divisive, but so is Piers.
And I liked her on Jonathan Ross the other week... how is Charlotte Church doing on Over The Rainbow? Those 2 with Simon and Ant & Dec could make for a great line-up, IMO. If the ratings come down quite a bit this year (as they almost certainly will) then that would be a really high profile revamp.”
Hmm, I'm not sure about Jonathan Ross. He'd be fine on it but I doubt he'd bring many new viewers in and wouldn't be much if at all better than Piers, who is surprisingly funny on it. Charlotte Church would be good, but if these Lloyd Webber shows run on an annual basis again it may be problematic for her to quit one show to join their biggest rival. Her, Piers and Simon would be a good line up. If they could replace piers with a big star name then they should go for it but I don't think there's a great deal of point in replacing him with Jonathan Ross. Effectively, it would be replacing one chat show host with another chat show host whose chat show gets lower ratings (and Piers frequently points out!).
Quote:
“I think if Paul O'Grady does around 3.7m+ then ITV will stick with it. With The Bill gone, ITV aren't going to start programming scripted series on Thursdays and Fridays. And I think they'd be better trying to find something cheaper to fill Fridays and then focus on Mondays & Thursdays for their top programming.”
Paul O'Grady will probably do reasonably well but they aren't going to be able to get him to do it all year round and so far none of their other Friday entertainment ideas have worked, and they're showing no signs of coming up with any others that will work (I don't think 71 Degrees North or Magic Numbers are set for Fridays), so unless they get something going quickly they could find themselves in a situation like Sundays in 2008 when the soaps were moved for Dancing on Ice and no thought had gone in to what was going to be shown there once DOI had finished, and it took them 18 months to get it sorted.
Quote:
“Another very subdued night last night. ITV just collapsed from Push The Button. I think that's it done now. And 12 episodes a year of Life Stories is too much. Although I did think Geri Halliwell would be a better rating. The ratings for the show vary so much, it had 5.6m just the other week!”
Push The Button hasn't worked and it's back to the drawing board for Ant and Dec. I don't know whether coming up with their own formats is the best idea for the near future for them, it may be better to go with something ITV give them for now. I think the problem with Life Stories is that the quality of guests is so variable. I thought Geri Halliwell would do better as well, but who wants to sit and watch an hour long interview with Joan Collins or Boris Becker or Kym Marsh? Michael Winner's will probably bomb next week too. They need to get better guests on, and they've shown they can as episodes with the likes of Simon Cowell, Richard Branson, Vinnie Jones and Bruce Forsyth have done very well. If they can get some decent household names on it every week it could do very well and be much more consistent. Obviously big, big names won't do it but examples of people who probably would, and who's episodes would do well include Davina McCall, Alan Sugar, Paul O'Grady, Gordon Ramsay, Noel Edmonds and probably plenty more. ITV just need to actually think when they're casting for the next series, and get people who are actually popular.