Originally Posted by rzt:
“Some reports in the last hour saying:
.
- ITV to possibly sue the BBC regarding their new ice-dancing show for ABC and halt production, as they say it's a rip-off of DOI. A BBC source replied: "We did Strictly Ice Dancing as a one-off back in 2004, two years before ITV launched Dancing on Ice."
.”
Is there any source other than the Sun for this because I just dont believe it really and the quotes are pretty laughable.
I remember in 2005, the tabloids were claiming that Simon Cowell was suing the beeb because of 'just the two of us' being similar to 'celebrity duets'.
Nothing came of that, I think Cowell made an American version which flopped for FOX and the beeb did 2 UK series and made versions in Australia, the netherlands, China, the netherlands and a few other countries.
Its very hard to show breach of copyright in regards tv shows.
Example RDF maker of Wife swap' dropped their suit against FOXs Trading Spouses as There is a test applied in the US courts where the show has to be the
exact same to be labelled a rip off.
The only difference with Trading spouses was that they gave each a wife $50,000 dollars to spent on eachothers households at the end of the swap.
Im a Celebrity was ruled not to be a rip-off of Survivor because the show was presented in a humourous way

.
Their have been numerous examples off these law suits which either never went to court or are thrown out of court.
FOX in the US have ripped off so many shows in the US its incredible, they had a Survivor rip-off Boot Camp, The Apprentice rip-off The Rogue Millionaire, a boxing show rip-off of the Contender, they also had Nanny 911 which was inspired

by Supernanny. As one judge put it television shows have always borrowed off each other and always will.
Also there is already a 'skating with the celebrities' brand seperate from both ITV and the BBC which has aired around the world including America made by A. Smith & Co. Productions. Foxs aired it in America in 2006 and Nine in Australia as 'Skating on thin ice' and im fairly sure there is a French version.Also there is a similar show called 'battle of the blades' in Canada only they swap the celbrities with hockey players.
But finally Strictly ice dancing is a spin-off of strictly come dancing and its details were announced weeks before 'Dancing on ICE', and aired over a year before 'DOI'. So its not even a rip-off like all the Fox shows were
So for all those reasons I would find it hard to believe that ITV are even thinking of planing to sue.