i saw him at wembley arena very early on (maybe just after fill me in came out?) , and most of the material was unfamiliar to the audience. they all stood up for fill me in, and re-wind, but that was about it. he actually came across as a very middle-aged artist, playing/singing funky stuff that would have gone down well to a 40-50 year old audience.
if you look at the charts from ten years ago, almost none of he artists are still going now bar a very select few, so its no disgrace to have had ephemeral popularity wane away.
re-wind was brilliant when it came out (it bored me to tears a few months later,.. and from then on,.. but it was outstanding at first).
craig david's recent song 'insomnia' is actually really strong, and i have played it out in clubs recently. i don't know if the single 7" version did much damage in the charts, but its basically very strong, and i'm pretty happy to have played it. its the haji and emanuel mix that i like
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IifD2K2cveE&feature=fvw
the bo selecta tv show will probably have had little effect on his career - if he was brilliant he would have stayed hugely popular, if he wasn't he would have waned away.
if you look at x-factor, the 18-24 acts do much, much, much better than the 25 and overs acts. there is a huge preference out there for artists to be in that age bracket, and after ten years, he's not young/fresh anymore.