Ray
Suzanne
Hayley
Kyran
Gaynor
Suzanne
Hayley
Kyran
Gaynor
whos the best Dancing on Ice Winner?
2 of 3
Originally Posted by footygirl:
“1. Kran Brackan - by a country mile
Decison based on the fact of no dancing or skating experience whatsoever
The others I think have had some tuition in one or the other”
“1. Kran Brackan - by a country mile
Decison based on the fact of no dancing or skating experience whatsoever
The others I think have had some tuition in one or the other”
Not so - Kyran had skated.
Originally Posted by Ignazio:
“Not so - Kyran had skated.”
“Not so - Kyran had skated.”
I've never seen this anywhere but this forum, and I've seen Kyran saying he never skated before DOI.
And as someone has pointed out it is unlikely he would have been allowed to skate whie playing rugby because of insurance, they're not allowed to participate in anything that could lead to injury.
Ray Quinn
Kyran Bracken
Suzanne Shaw
are my top three.
Bonnie Langford was robbed - Gaynor Faye should never have won the first Dancing on Ice and, in my opinion, was the least worthy champion.
Kyran Bracken
Suzanne Shaw
are my top three.
Bonnie Langford was robbed - Gaynor Faye should never have won the first Dancing on Ice and, in my opinion, was the least worthy champion.
Kyran/Suzanne
Ray
Hayley
Gaynor
Of the Runner-ups Chris and Claire were unlucky but both Suzanne & Kyran were worthy winners as well. I thought that John Barrowman was the best skater in S1 and also like Stefan. As for Bonnie she was good but became a better skater after the series than she was during as she often carry in lift by Matt.
Ray
Hayley
Gaynor
Of the Runner-ups Chris and Claire were unlucky but both Suzanne & Kyran were worthy winners as well. I thought that John Barrowman was the best skater in S1 and also like Stefan. As for Bonnie she was good but became a better skater after the series than she was during as she often carry in lift by Matt.
Originally Posted by tabithakitten:
“Ray was the best. He's the best skater to have won (only Chris Fountain challenges him there imo) and his performance skill rivals Suzanne and Hayley.
Suzanne's probably next. I think she demonstrated more skating skill than Hayley and by the end of the series was absolutely sparkling on the ice.
I'd put Hayley and Kyran about equal. She's much better than him on performance but he's better on skating skill. She's still a fairly decent skater though and he did a lot with his performance skill during the series, especially considering his background.
And then, to quote Kyran, we have Gaynor Faye who won the first series... To be fair, it wasn't so competitive then and we didn't really know what to expect.”
“Ray was the best. He's the best skater to have won (only Chris Fountain challenges him there imo) and his performance skill rivals Suzanne and Hayley.
Suzanne's probably next. I think she demonstrated more skating skill than Hayley and by the end of the series was absolutely sparkling on the ice.
I'd put Hayley and Kyran about equal. She's much better than him on performance but he's better on skating skill. She's still a fairly decent skater though and he did a lot with his performance skill during the series, especially considering his background.
And then, to quote Kyran, we have Gaynor Faye who won the first series... To be fair, it wasn't so competitive then and we didn't really know what to expect.”
My opinion exactly.....
I look forward to seeing how Hayley fares on tour in competition with Ray, Chris and Claire.....
1. Ray
2. Kyran
3. Suzanne
4. Hayley
5. Gaynor
Though I can't really remember anything about Gaynor
I guess we'll see how good she is on this year's tour
2. Kyran
3. Suzanne
4. Hayley
5. Gaynor
Though I can't really remember anything about Gaynor
I guess we'll see how good she is on this year's tour
My order as follows:
1. Kyran Bracken - Despite no performance or skating training previously, some really strong skating and yet approached everything with a great sense of humour which really came out in his performances. And to this day, I think he's done the best ever props routine!
2. Ray Quinn.
3. Hayley Tammadon
4. Suzanne Shaw
5. Gaynor Faye.
1. Kyran Bracken - Despite no performance or skating training previously, some really strong skating and yet approached everything with a great sense of humour which really came out in his performances. And to this day, I think he's done the best ever props routine!
2. Ray Quinn.
3. Hayley Tammadon
4. Suzanne Shaw
5. Gaynor Faye.
1. Ray (altho im not a fan of him, he is a fab skater)
2. Kyran (loved his performances especially props week)
3. Hayley (great all round performer)
4. Suzanne (never took to her for some reason)
5. Gaynor (altho i liked her at the time, she is technically the worst of the winners imo)
2. Kyran (loved his performances especially props week)
3. Hayley (great all round performer)
4. Suzanne (never took to her for some reason)
5. Gaynor (altho i liked her at the time, she is technically the worst of the winners imo)
Originally Posted by Multimedia81:
“Anyone who claims Suzanne was not the best winner is in my opinion skating on very thin ice!”
“Anyone who claims Suzanne was not the best winner is in my opinion skating on very thin ice!”
Suzanne was without a doubt not the best winner.
Ray Quinn was the best winner and Chris Fountain the best skater not to win. Both miles ahead of the finalists this year. And both relied on only sheer skating talent and not stage school grins and showmance with dance partner.
Originally Posted by Lorri Lou:
“Ray Quinn was the best winner and Chris Fountain the best skater not to win. Both miles ahead of the finalists this year. And both relied on only sheer skating talent and not stage school grins and showmance with dance partner.”
“Ray Quinn was the best winner and Chris Fountain the best skater not to win. Both miles ahead of the finalists this year. And both relied on only sheer skating talent and not stage school grins and showmance with dance partner.”
Why did you feel the need to denigrate this years contestants? Some people are just bad losers.
Originally Posted by Lorri Lou:
“Ray Quinn was the best winner and Chris Fountain the best skater not to win. Both miles ahead of the finalists this year. And both relied on only sheer skating talent and not stage school grins and showmance with dance partner.”
“Ray Quinn was the best winner and Chris Fountain the best skater not to win. Both miles ahead of the finalists this year. And both relied on only sheer skating talent and not stage school grins and showmance with dance partner.”
Best ever non winner - Clare Buckfield.
Originally Posted by Ignazio:
“Best ever non winner - Clare Buckfield.”
“Best ever non winner - Clare Buckfield.”
Clare's my favourite ever female but Chris was much better.
Ray is the best, Suzanne is my favourite. I never really understand the insistence on this thread of pointing out who's the best 'technical' skater, it is dancing on ice and not skating on ice.
Forum Member
Kyran
Ray
Gaynor
Suzanne
Hayley
My preferred order, although I do think Chris Fountain was one of the best skaters not to win too!
Kyran
Ray
Gaynor
Suzanne
Hayley
My preferred order, although I do think Chris Fountain was one of the best skaters not to win too!
1. Ray
2. Kyran
3. Gaynor
4. Hayley
5. Suzanne
Chris would be number one if he'd won like he should have
2. Kyran
3. Gaynor
4. Hayley
5. Suzanne
Chris would be number one if he'd won like he should have
Suzanne is my favourite.
Ray is the best
Hayley is the 2nd best
Kyran and Gaynor weren't as great as those 3 imo. Although I remember rooting for Kyran that year.
Ray is the best
Hayley is the 2nd best
Kyran and Gaynor weren't as great as those 3 imo. Although I remember rooting for Kyran that year.
Originally Posted by phasers:
“1. Ray
2. Kyran
3. Gaynor
4. Hayley
5. Suzanne
Chris would be number one if he'd won like he should have”
“1. Ray
2. Kyran
3. Gaynor
4. Hayley
5. Suzanne
Chris would be number one if he'd won like he should have
”
I always got the impression from him that he knew he was the best and that he should have won. He was great, but that put me off him a lot.
Originally Posted by yellowlabbie:
“Why did you feel the need to denigrate this years contestants? Some people are just bad losers.”
“Why did you feel the need to denigrate this years contestants? Some people are just bad losers.”
Nothing to do with being a bad loser - I didn't think any of this years contestants were even close to being as good as Ray, Chris Fountain. Hayley was the best (of a bad bunch) this year but not close to the skill or Ray or Chris.
1. Kyran. I have always enjoyed watching him more than the others.
2. Ray
3. Suzanne. Easily best ever female winner.
A bit of a gap now...
4. Hayley
And an even bigger gap....
5. Gaynor
2. Ray
3. Suzanne. Easily best ever female winner.
A bit of a gap now...
4. Hayley
And an even bigger gap....
5. Gaynor
1 Suzanne and Ray. I can't separate them I really enjoyed both. She is just beautiful to watch and i love how strong her skating is. He was just so far ahead of everyone his year and dance wise he is just brilliant.
2. Kyran
gap
3. Hayley
big gap
4. Gaynor
I do think Clare is the best not to win as well.
2. Kyran
gap
3. Hayley
big gap
4. Gaynor
I do think Clare is the best not to win as well.
1. Suzanne - I loved her progression throughout the show, I really felt she was what the show is all about.
2. Ray - His dancing on ice was really great to watch.
3. Kyran - He really pushed himself especially with the performance.
4. Hayley - Everything was nice but nothing wowed me.
5. Gaynor - would never have won any other series!
I'd also have Clare as the best not to win.
2. Ray - His dancing on ice was really great to watch.
3. Kyran - He really pushed himself especially with the performance.
4. Hayley - Everything was nice but nothing wowed me.
5. Gaynor - would never have won any other series!
I'd also have Clare as the best not to win.
2 of 3
