• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • TV Shows: Reality
  • Past Reality Shows
  • Over the Rainbow
Week 1 - rank the performances
<<
<
1 of 2
>>
>
N X M
03-04-2010
Amy
Bronte
Dani
Danielle
Emilie
Jenny
Jessica
Lauren
Sophie
Steph
Stephanie

That's just the alphabetical list - not my order
ianswaiting
03-04-2010
Amy 11th
Bronte 7th
Dani 10th
Danielle 6th
Emilie 5th
Jenny 3rd
Jessica 8th
Lauren 1st
Sophie 4th
Steph 9th
Stephanie 2nd
amp1991
03-04-2010
LAUREN
DANIELLE -shes my favourite
BRONTE
SOPHIE
JESSICA
STEPH
STEPHANIE
EMILIE
AMY
DANI
JENNY

lilhunni_Jo
03-04-2010
1. Sophie
2. Jenny
3. Bronte
4. Lauren
5. Steph
6. Amy
7. Stephanie
8. Danielle
9. Dani
10. Jessica
11. Emilie
reclinewithme
03-04-2010
Ist - Steph - sublime, just love her!
2nd - Sophie - mesmerising
3rd - Jessica - a natural
4th - Jenny - she has that spark
5th - Bronte - very loveable
6th - Lauren - natural talent
7th - Danielle - likeable and sincere
8th - Stephanie - so pretty and vivacious
9th - Amy - surprisingly good voice, but not Dorothy
10th - Dani - tried too hard
11th - Emilie - she blew her vocal
Leanne87
03-04-2010
Danielle
Bronte
Sophie
Stephanie
Jenny
Dani
Steph
Emilie
Lauren
Jessica
Amy
N X M
03-04-2010
1. Bronte - OMG I'm starting to love this girl! Beautiful, beautiful voice and despite what the panel thought I found it totally convincing

2. Danielle - not a tencnically perfect vocal but still one that totally connected for me. There's something absolutely magnetic about her. It's those eyes

3. Stephanie - tons of character, very likeable just needs to tone down the jazz hands a bit

4. Steph - love her voice, nicely restrained performance, maybe too restrained for the GBP

5. Jenny - slightly irritating and over the top but her energy just about won me over

6. Lauren - pleasant and...err...that's about it. Definitely looks like a Dorothy though

7. Sophie - decent enough performance but every time I see her I can't help thinking 'pub singer'

8. Amy - I do like her as a singer but she's about as suited to the role as ALW would be

9. Dani - You'd never guess she was sixteen would you? From that awkward and unconvincing performance you'd think she was twelve

10. Jessica - more Whinehouse than Winehouse, more ham-dram than am-dram. Yuk

11. Emilie - how the hell did the GBP vote her through??? Looks like the love-child of Bonnie Langford and Jimmy Tarbuck and sings like it too. Rubbish...
Psychosis
03-04-2010
1. Bronte
2. Lauren

3. Stephanie
4. Danielle
5. Jenny

6. Sophie
7. Jessica
8. Steph
9. Dani

10. Emilie
11. Amy
-Sid-
03-04-2010
1. Jessica - I think she's made for this part. I adore her.

2. Emilie - I found her performance very sincere.

3. Bronte - I can envisage her as Dorothy.

4. Lauren - Surprised me actually. Loved her vocal and thought she meant what she sang.

5. Steph - Aww I know the judges don't see her as right for the role, but I adore everything about her - her personality, her voice, her stage presence....

6. Danielle - Started well, then lost it a bit. Not that memorable.

7. Sophie - Didn#t love or hate her performance really.

8. Dani - I can't see what ALW sees in her.

9. Jenny - Over-rated, has a nasally voice and her new look is too edgy. And I can't bear people who feel the need to tell us how 'crazy' they are. It usually means they're actually pretty dull and ordinary.

10. Stephanie - Decent voice but contrived facial expressions and gestures.

11. Amy - I have no idea what she's doing auditoning for Dorothy. She's all wrong for the part and I'm really annoyed with John Partridge for pushing the other judges to let her through (which is what I sense happened) when we could have enjoyed Tasheka or Tegan who were far more suitable for the role.
jackier
03-04-2010
1. Bronte
2. Sophie
3. Danielle
4. Steph
5. Jessica
6. Emilie
7. Jennie
8. Lauren
9. Stephanie
10. Amy
11. Dani
threecheeses
03-04-2010
Top Half
Danielle
Jenni
Bronte
Amy
Steph
Stephanie



Bottom Half
Sophie (but top of the bottom bunch)
Lauren
Jessica
Emilie
Dani
jules1000
03-04-2010
I with you I like Jessica and Emile as well..I think they will be in the top 5.
About
03-04-2010
[LIST=1][*]Bronte[*]Amy[*]Lauren[*]Jessica[*]Dani[*]Danielle[*]Sophie[*]Steph[*]Stephanie[*]Jenny[*]Emilie[/LIST]
Froggitt
03-04-2010
Lauren Jenny and Bronty for me.
simbarro
03-04-2010
1. Danielle - Not the most powerful vocalist, but it's lovely to listen to, she has that something. She is my Dorothy so far.

2. Steph - Distinctive voice, I can always tell its her, she is alwats on point. Not sure whether she is too old to play Dorothy.

3. Amy - suprisingly her vocals are great, but very commercial, she isn't Dorothy.

4. Jessica - Didn't like her to begin with but her hip flick in all that jazz was hilarious, she made that performance watchable. There is something about her I just find amusing to watch.

5. Emilie - Not the strongest vocalist, but I think she will grow.

6. Lauren - ok

7. Sophie - ok, not stand out

8. Dani - ok

9. Bronte - I don't really remember her performance, just her name which isnt good.

10. Stephanie - Tries too hard, just can't warm to her as Dorothy.

11. Jenny - Oh dear, memorable for all the wrong reasons.
babyshez
03-04-2010
Jessica - absolutely adore her, her facial expressions are amazing, ok the notes werent perfect but like Sheila said, it didnt even matter!
Stephanie - WOW, her dancing and acting is incredible, lovely voice too
Sophie - love her, voice is amazing aswell as everything else
Jenny - LOVED her today, really stood out and totally got into it, kept me entertained
Bronte - i love her look, and can just see her as dorothy, aswell as her voice being amazing
Dani - cant believe shes only 16, her acting is fantastic, i can see all the emotion through her eyes, lovely voice also
Steph - lovely voice
Danielle - think shes lovely just not MY dorothy
Lauren - lovely voice also
Emelie - i dont quite get why she's through, i would have preferred tegan, emma, claire or sarah (LOVED her quirkyness) but maybe she felt pressured at the fact the panel didnt pick her anyway and she didnt want to prove them right..?
Amy - too older looking for dorothy IMO
peeve
03-04-2010
1. Jessica - I really like her - quirky, very musical theatre.
2. Danielle - mesmerising. Good vocal and contained. Possibly my favourite.
3. Lauren - that surprised me, as not previously a favourite. Absolutely loved her vocal, her diction and her performance.
4. Jenny - hate that song, but she sold it.
5. Stephanie - not really a 'Dorothy' song, was it? But she has nerves of steel to go out first and sell it.
6. Bronte - very enjoyable. Something very likeable about her.
7. Sophie - I was a bit disappointed with this performance, because she's one of my favourites.
8. Steph - good vocal, but so not Dorothy. Too sophisticated.
9. Dani - very poor vocals, but she's 16 and I guess the occasion got to her.
10. Amy - far too sophisticated for Dorothy.
11. Emilie - I can't understand why the public put her through, to be honest. Poor vocal and very nervous.
marie67
03-04-2010
1 Stephanie
2 Danielle
3 Jenny
4 Steph
5 Jessica
6 Sophie
7 Amy
8 Bronte
9 Lauren
10 Dani
11 Emilie
xfactorfan27
03-04-2010
1st-Steph
2nd-Amy
3rd-Sophie
4th-Danielle
5th-Bronte
6th-Lauren
7th-Stephanie
8th-Jenny
9th-Jessica
10th-Dani
11th-Emilie
Vivadiva
03-04-2010
1st- Stephanie: I don't like the song but a really good performance. Great choice for Dorothy.

2nd- Bronte: She sang this convincingly and I really think she could be the one to watch.

3rd- Sophie: Beautiful voice and a solid performance, if not her best.

4th- Danielle: I really like Danielle and this was a wonderful choice for her.

5th- Steph: I think she is just a bit too feisty for Dorothy but great voice and presence.

6th- Lauren: I am not too big a fan of Lauren but she surprised me tonight- her pronunication was a bit too forced at time though.

7th- Dani: Bad song choice but she has potential.

8th- Amy: Not right for this show at all but by no means bad.

9th- Jenny: For me, a hideous performance which lacked any real heart or energy. That raspberry at the end summed it up for me.

10th- Emilie: I thought maybe I had missed something that the public must like about Emilie but that was dire and flat.

11th- Jessica: I must be missing something as I found that so forced and stage school. It was laboured and embarassing.
ordovicious
03-04-2010
Ist - Danielle - still the one to beat
2nd - Lauren - in the show as a safe bet if the others fail
3rd - Bronte - a star? Of course she is.
4th - Sophie - such a beautiful girl, talented too.
5th - Jessica - she annoys some people but I love her.
6th - Stephanie - not so good tonight
7th - Emilie - poor tonight, but she's got it.
8th - Jenny - putting on a good show
9th - Steph - a bit forgetable
10th - Dani - perhaps she'll improve
11th - Amy - better than you'd expect but miscast
Ricky85
04-04-2010
1st Danielle - My early favourite
2nd Lauren- Good and safe performance
3rd Steph - Great performance and voice
4th Bronte - Good performance
5th Dani- A little weak but safe
6th Jessica - good and safe
7th Sophie - Good but a little weak
8th Stephanie - should have done better, poor choice of song
9th Jenny - Good but not sure about her
10th Emillie - good but maybe too weak
11th Amy - good voice but seems too fake.
River Man
04-04-2010
1. Bronte
2. Lauren
3. Jess
4. Jenny
5. Steph
6. Sophie
7. Danielle
8. Stephane
9. Amy
10. Dani
11. Emilie
mr.bojangles
04-04-2010
1. Bronte - I thought a sincere performance and a great voice.

2. Lauren - tough song with a bit of wishy washy meaning dealt with admirably. Think she could be a good actress.

3. Sophie - not the best performance, but I think she has something quite captivating

4. Stephanie - I find her a bit annoying but she probably is a good overall package and hopefully will get a better song next week

5. Steph - amazing performance but not sure she's a Dorothy. Might have a bit too much attitude but I think she would be wonderful in many other things

6. Emillie - ok, vocals dodgy, but I think she performs with sincerity so hope she returns.

7. Danielle - nice but bland

8. Jessica - not bland but I laughed for the wrong reasons. I feel she might have one acting face. Steers clear from the bottom simply because she looks like Judy Garland in certain lights. Yes, judge me for bringing in that name.

9. Dani - could turn out to be better than that I guess.

10. Amy - was all a bit Girls Aloud. Certainly has presence and confidence, but I struggle to see her as Dorothy

11. Jenny - whoa. Does she want people to dislike her?
DimSum
04-04-2010
1. Danielle
2. Bronte
3. Jessica
4. Sophie
5. Lauren
6. Steph
7. Jenny
8. Amy
9. Dani
10.Emilie
11. Stephanie
<<
<
1 of 2
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map