She was BY FAR the worst. Vocally it was all of the place and barely in-tune.

If it wasn't for the wild-card underdog thing she'd probably deserve to go wouldn't she? She'll probably stay for that reason though.

it wasn't the best vocal but I don't think it was the worst.
For me Jessica's vocal was a lot worse and the over performing of everything was annoying.

I was surprised Emilie got through.

So was I, what a disappointment.

I think with the right vocal training she actually has the best look and presence for Dorothy.

I am really glad she got through as I thought she was great last week (although not tonight). I hope she gains confidence as the weeks go on though. I am sure if she is in the bottom two tomorrow night ALW will save her to give her a chance to improve.

I was surprised she was voted in really........especially over Teegan, Tasheka, and Camille who seemed to have a popular fan base.

She miffed her words last week as well and wasn't the best performer, but obviosuly she was the public's choice.

Personally, I don't think she was the worst at all.

I'm a bit puzzled by the strong negative reaction to Emily's performance.

She was one of the few who I thought sang with sincerity (even though she didn't hit every note).

Very disappointed in her performance, i liked her last week but singing on her own has shown how the judges didnt pick her last week, i would be happy for her to be first out tomorrow

She didn't any of the notes..

I thought she wasn't good last week and thought she was worse tonight.

Didn't like her performance

Neither did I. But perhaps next week she'll be better.

She wasn't my choice for the wild card and it rather surprised me that she got it but I didn't think she was the worst tonight...but then I don't think the judges picked the right top 10 so it doesn't surprise me that some were outperformed by the wildcard.

I think she got through on looks more than anything (as in looking like a dorothy) i said in the original thread about the 11th that her she sang off key in the original 20-10 show.

Poor choice for wild card because she has no chance, there were far better people in the wild card but they werent championed as Emilie was.. shame.

I voted for Emilie. She was one of my four favourites from week one. It was hard to pick out of any of them after they had sung just one song. When the Maria competition was on it became more clear as to who could stand up to the pressure and perform a variety of emotions each week as the competition went on.
I agree with Lord Lloyd Webber. It is a gamble but Emilie does have that extra sparkle and the 16 year old look to be Dorothy.

WOOHOO. Emilie is a fantastic performer.. I've come on here to back her up because we are good mates and I can tell you now she has SO much more to give.. I don't think 'Breakaway' was maybe the best song for her but she is an absolutely AMAZING singer and performer and would be an awesome Dorothy so VOTE VOTE VOTE for her! WOOHOO.

She is safe for a bit. People are used to voting for her

In any case I am still hoping for an Emilie Bronte duet

She was really flat

Sorry but I have to beg to differ with regards to her singing ability. She really is one of the poorer ones.

No doubt she looks the part and has performance skills, but when it comes to her voice but she can't hold a tune. She is competant and could maybe learn to pitch properly with a decent singing coach but surely Dorothy needs to be more of a finished article at this stage.

Of course there's nothing wrong with being a loyal & supportive friend, but you can't kid the viewers that her voice is AMAZING