If Rose WAS to return in series 5...

2 of 2

J_Peasmould

13-04-2010

Personally I don't think it would be a good idea. Rose, who was such an important character when the show came back, has had her day, and to bring her back at the moment would further devalue Rose as a character.

I would like to see David Tennant back...but in few years when the show reaches its 50th birthday (!). To bring him back now would overshadow Matt Smith! David Tennant was great, but it's time to look forward to the future!

November_Rain

13-04-2010

Originally Posted by molybecks:
“Before everyone goes off on one, read first..

If Rose WAS to return for the finale of Series 5 (which has kind of been rumoured around facebook-along with the return of David Tennant as the clone doctor) and it was really good i.e. done right, not rushed and delievered a good storyline i.e. which is needed for the whole thing to work, would those who are anti-Rose still enjoy it?

I personally wasn't too keen on Martha and wouldn't like to see her return, but if she did and it was done right, I would say fair dos as it worked.

Your thoughts?”

Bringing Rose back in itself would be a bad move, the series has moved on, and not a moment too soon.

CheeseyDude1337

13-04-2010

Shes gone, why do we need to think about what will happen if she hadn't. Its like me starting a thread called "If the Brigadier WAS the 12th Doctor" or whatever.

sigsig

13-04-2010

Originally Posted by CheeseyDude1337:
“Its like me starting a thread called "If the Brigadier WAS the 12th Doctor" or whatever.”

Make it happen.

CheeseyDude1337

13-04-2010

Originally Posted by sigsig:
“Make it happen.”

lol

TwEeD.NK

13-04-2010

Originally Posted by amos_brearley:
“Although we don't actually know what timeframe that scene was from. By my calculations, dreadlocks aren't back in fashion until at least 2023...”

That weren't dreadlocks at all...

daveyboy7472

13-04-2010

It's an interesting thread but academic. Have read somewhere today that Billie Piper is definitely not coming back as Rose and as has already been said on here already, I think it would be a backwards step for the new series if she did. The New series is proving to be fresh and original, lets hope it stays that way.

DavetheScot

14-04-2010

Originally Posted by Rorschach:
“I always held the impression that RTD had fallen in love with the Doctor/Rose love story and didn't think he had given it a proper ending with their seperation (apparently being completely unaware of the long tradition of tragic love stories like, for example, Romeo and Juliet or The Prisoner of Zenda).

It was therefore his desire, rather than something fans were demanding, to bring her back and give them a happy ending of sorts (as happy as lumbering her with a psychopathic clone can be).”

That is, of course, only your impression as you say. If it was correct, though, it would show that writers aren't always the best judges of the quality of their own work, because the ending of Rose and the Doctor's story in Doomsday was perfect and the add-on ending in Journey's End was mince.

I don't think for a moment that she'll come back again, but I can't imagine that such a return would be desirable. Believe me, I love Rose; she's my favourite companion ever, but like all companions her time came to an end and we now have a new - and excellent - companion. I'm all for cherishing the memories, but let the past be the past.

steven1977

15-04-2010

If that happened I would scream at the TV in anger of bringing her back every god why series.

2 of 2