I see you didn't pick up on the negative comments then that were knocking her personality.


And that is relevant how???[/quote]

I'm sure she is but unfrtunatly this is not a competition about who is nicest.

Me too. Just because I think she is weakest atm doesn't mean I hope she performs poorly next week.


I completely agree she is talented. But unfortunately I also think she is currently the weakest in the competition, But that may not be the case next Saturday.

I agree, but there are some contestants in talent shows that have a kind of Eve Harrington quality about them. You almost feel they would trample on anyone elses soul to get to the top.

In case it is not clear the only reason i mentioned about her coming across as nice was because i was reading the opposite about her in this thread. I was giving my opinion like everyone else and was reacting to what i read in this thread.

Errr did you go to school? Don't you remember being mean to people or people being mean to you? We're capable of it, even at primary school.

I know what you mean.

5 year olds are capable of it. lol. Is Emilie still a baby, that's really the only age people can't have the intention to be cruel. even then i'm not so sure.

Don't hold your breath.

Don't hold your own.

The only reason she is still on the show is cos people feel sorry for her and she turned on the tears. Its very unfair that she is being kept over much better singers like Bronte and Dani and its totally ridiculous the likes of Danielle and Lauren being in the bottom 2 and Emilie still being safe.

Do you know that for a fact - or is it opinion?

I've watched plenty of these shows and I know the British public always feel sorry for the underdog and once she started crying the votes would coming flooding in.

Then you must be right although .......... the British public voted for her in the last couple of weeks before she shed any tears which sort of shoots holes into your theory: not only that but I too am a member of the British public, are you saying you know how my mind works?

But then Lauren got criticised for her supposed arrogance last week, and for much less cause IMO.

I like Emilie. She doesn't always hit the notes as perfectly as some of the other girls do, but there is a lot of personality that comes out when she sings and I like that. She is always good in the group songs too. I am glad that she has made it through this week.

Do you know each and every voter and their reasons ?

Man, gappy Langford sucks!
Let's hope she's bottom two next week.
I'll be over the moon (and so will she!).

100% agree with you. This was her best performance yet and the comments about the meaning of the song and the male dancer were nothing to do with her. She didn't choreograph it! Emilie seems like a lovely girl and the british public know how to back an underdog.

I've only just got round to watching the show and you are absolutely right. Sheila Hancock and John are talking out of their backsides. That was such a lovely vocal from Emilie, her best ever. The utter stupidity of this panel. The choreography had nothing to do with Emilie . Why they put that bloke there was totally confusing to Emilie and us the viewers. Don't they know Moon River is about a river. Nasty stuff from this John bloke.

I am sorry to say this but I cant look at Emilie without her reminding me of Joan Sims from the Carry On films in her younger days.

Her face is a dead ringer for her and the gap in her teeth is also.

I just cannot take her seriously, it is a shame.

I was a little surprised at the criticism of the choreography.... they don't do their own do they? Also I've always thought of 'Moonriver' as an introspective song, kind of like a person singing their thoughts out loud to themself - so I thought the 'dancer' was out of place.

I also can't understand why the panel were going on about wanting to watch how the girls danced and then gave a few of them ballads to sing! Odd.

I'm not an Emilie fan but I thought she sang quite well on Saturday night and that the comments about her not engaging with the dancer were just picking fault for the sake of it. She must have a lot of support and some of 'em (the Lord) don't want to be thwarted like he was when Jodie won IDA

She is terrible, we can't understand how she is staying in each week, will become a joke as more and more talented singers leave if she stays in.

People think that Emilie thought too much off herself for her comments to VT..... I'm guessing that all the girls do a piece to VT and at stages they all 'big' themselves up, it just depends on what the production crew decided to show.

The girls are asked specific questions until they give the answers the producers want. All reality shows work this way, the VT is always manipulated.

Lauren and Jess have already been subtly branded cocky, this week was Emilie's turn.

Next week someone else will get it, and Emilie will get good VT.

Swings and roundabouts, sadly not everyone votes on performance. These girls are all young, the producers should know better than to screw their chances by doing this.

The arrogance thing could well be down to editing and I'll give her the benefit of the doubt on that but to say Emilie was best is just ridiculous. Whenever she sang the line "we're after the same rainbow's end" she wasn't able to hit the "same" note properly. The first time she almost got there but after the little dance bit she missed it by the proverbial mile.

Here is the link to the show:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode...w_Programme_7/

jump to pretty much dead-on the thirty minute mark . She is so off-key it is, quite frankly, painful. The judges should have commented on this to stop it looking like they were picking on her. mentioning the dance was pointless when she was so out of tune.

I've just watched the group performances from the first live show (when she was with Amy, Danielle and Claire Hillier) and she more than held her own in 'If My Friends Could See Me Now' despite being in a group with 3 very big voices. The Emilie in that performance is very different to the Emilie i've been seeing for most of the shows since. All these people on here questioning why she was the wildcard based on her performances after being named the wildcard are looking at things wrong.

I actually think Saturday was a big improvement on the 2 Saturdays previously and her best yet. With the right song i think she can deliver. I don't think she is as bad as a lot of people are making out. Nerves probably got the better of her for the first live show involving a solo performance and she probably just needs more time than others to get confident up there by herself. She sounds and looks much more comfortable when singing the group songs.

Her confidence has slowly been dropping and now it has been well and truely kicked out of her thanks to John on Saturday. I found his comments completely unnecessary. I'm all for constructive criticism but he really went for her and it came across as nothing more than bitchy.

I'm not an Emilie fan. She isn't one of my favourites. But some of the comments i've been reading on this forum are bordering on childish and pathetic. All these posters saying she should go home before the better girls i agree with, but for Emilie's sake just as much as for the better girls sake.