Top 3
Danielle
Stephanie
Sophie
Bottom 3
Jessica
Emile
Danielle
Danielle
Stephanie
Sophie
Bottom 3
Jessica
Emile
Danielle
Your Top 3/ Bottom 3
2 of 3
Originally Posted by FXDUX:
“Top 3
Danielle
Stephanie
Sophie
Bottom 3
Jessica
Emile
Danielle”
“Top 3
Danielle
Stephanie
Sophie
Bottom 3
Jessica
Emile
Danielle”
You might want to correct FX
Originally Posted by Tortue:
“Thats interesting. What's your like and dislike list then?”
“Thats interesting. What's your like and dislike list then?”
Actual likes and dislikes
Top 3:
1, Jess
2, Emilie
3, Lauren (hang in there girl!)
Bottom 3:
1, Steph
2, Sophie (consistent)
3, Danielle
I can't say I hate any of the girls, or find any of them lacking talent. But I just have yet to find MY perfect Dorothy. Campest sentence ever
On liking them and wanting to see them win:
Top 3
1) Danielle
2) Sophie
3) Jessica
Bottom 3 (with 1 being worst!)
1) Emilie
2) Lauren
3) Stephanie (I don't mind her too much but I like Jenny & Steph more)
On talent & suitability for the role:
Top 3
1) Danielle
2) Stephanie
3) Steph/Jenny (can't choose between them, neither is right for Dorothy in my opinion but they are both talented & could play a protagonist).
Bottom 3
1) Emilie
2) Jessica
3) Lauren (she is very talented but she's just not a protagonist, it just seems like major mis-casting to put her in such a role)
So yes, Danielle is my favourit as she's the only one I've really taken to who I think has shown the talent for the role. I really like Sophie but, unless it's nerves, she's not quite there. I like Jessica but she's showing herself to be a bit ropey vocally in the last couple of shows.
Jenny and Steph I like but don't think are right for the role. Stephanie I'm sort of 'meh' about. Lauren I haven't really taken to & also think she's wrong for playing a lead as she doesn't have the quality that makes you empathise with her. Emilie is just too weak & is really starting to annoy me with her refusal to take on board criticism!
Top 3
1) Danielle
2) Sophie
3) Jessica
Bottom 3 (with 1 being worst!)
1) Emilie
2) Lauren
3) Stephanie (I don't mind her too much but I like Jenny & Steph more)
On talent & suitability for the role:
Top 3
1) Danielle
2) Stephanie
3) Steph/Jenny (can't choose between them, neither is right for Dorothy in my opinion but they are both talented & could play a protagonist).
Bottom 3
1) Emilie
2) Jessica
3) Lauren (she is very talented but she's just not a protagonist, it just seems like major mis-casting to put her in such a role)
So yes, Danielle is my favourit as she's the only one I've really taken to who I think has shown the talent for the role. I really like Sophie but, unless it's nerves, she's not quite there. I like Jessica but she's showing herself to be a bit ropey vocally in the last couple of shows.
Jenny and Steph I like but don't think are right for the role. Stephanie I'm sort of 'meh' about. Lauren I haven't really taken to & also think she's wrong for playing a lead as she doesn't have the quality that makes you empathise with her. Emilie is just too weak & is really starting to annoy me with her refusal to take on board criticism!
Top 3:
Danielle
Lauren
Stephanie
Bottom 3:
Emilie
Jessica
Sophie (although I much prefer her to the other two in my bottom 3, it wouldn't be the end of the world for me if she won it)
Adore Steph too and think she'd probably be the best in terms of leading a show and sustaining 8 shows a week, but I just don't think she's right for the role.
Danielle
Lauren
Stephanie
Bottom 3:
Emilie
Jessica
Sophie (although I much prefer her to the other two in my bottom 3, it wouldn't be the end of the world for me if she won it)
Adore Steph too and think she'd probably be the best in terms of leading a show and sustaining 8 shows a week, but I just don't think she's right for the role.
For Dorothy
Top 3
1. Danielle
2. Stephanie
3. Sophie
Bottom 3
1. Emilie
2. Jenny
3. Steph (she's fab but she's not Dorothy)
Overall
Top 3
1. Danielle
2. Steph
3. Stephanie
Bottom 3
1. Emilie
2. Jenny
3. Lauren
Top 3
1. Danielle
2. Stephanie
3. Sophie
Bottom 3
1. Emilie
2. Jenny
3. Steph (she's fab but she's not Dorothy)
Overall
Top 3
1. Danielle
2. Steph
3. Stephanie
Bottom 3
1. Emilie
2. Jenny
3. Lauren
Top 3
Danielle
Lauren
Sophie
Bottom 3
Steph
Emilie
Jessica
I think Steph is incredibly talented though, just not right for Dorothy.
And my top choices are based on the fact that experience HAS to win over 'raw talent', IMO.
Danielle
Lauren
Sophie
Bottom 3
Steph
Emilie
Jessica
I think Steph is incredibly talented though, just not right for Dorothy.
And my top choices are based on the fact that experience HAS to win over 'raw talent', IMO.
Top 3
1. Lauren
2. Stephanie
3. Steph
Bottom 3
1. Emilie
2. Jessica
3. Sophie
Though I actually don't mind my bottom 3.
Like pretty much everyone, even Emilie.
1. Lauren
2. Stephanie
3. Steph
Bottom 3
1. Emilie
2. Jessica
3. Sophie
Though I actually don't mind my bottom 3.
Like pretty much everyone, even Emilie.
Top Three
Lauren
Jenny
Emilie
Bottom Three
Sophie
Stephanie
Danielle
Not a Dorothy but would suit other roles
Jessica and Steph
Lauren
Jenny
Emilie
Bottom Three
Sophie
Stephanie
Danielle
Not a Dorothy but would suit other roles
Jessica and Steph
Top Three
Lauren - the 'complete package' for me
Danielle - good voice, great actress
Stephanie - good at everything but she'll need to ditch her accent!
Bottom Three
Emilie - not anywhere near strong enough vocally
Jessica - hams it up too much for me
Sophie - not strong enough & very nervous
Jenny is OK; Steph is great but not Dorothy for me - more of a pop singer.
Lauren - the 'complete package' for me
Danielle - good voice, great actress
Stephanie - good at everything but she'll need to ditch her accent!
Bottom Three
Emilie - not anywhere near strong enough vocally
Jessica - hams it up too much for me
Sophie - not strong enough & very nervous
Jenny is OK; Steph is great but not Dorothy for me - more of a pop singer.
2 of 3
