1) Danielle
2) Stephanie
3) Steph
4) Jessica
5) Jenny
6) Lauren
7) Sophie
2) Stephanie
3) Steph
4) Jessica
5) Jenny
6) Lauren
7) Sophie
Rank the remaining seven girls
4 of 5
for me its:
1. Stephanie
2. Steph
3. Danielle
4. Lauren
5. Sophie
6. Jenny
7. Jessica
and i believe that this is how it will go ( or at least how it should)
1. Stephanie
2. Steph
3. Danielle
4. Lauren
5. Sophie
6. Jenny
7. Jessica
and i believe that this is how it will go ( or at least how it should)
1) Danielle. Has the most Dorothy quality. Needs a bit more training.
2) Stephanie. Polished and would be a safe/good Dorothy
3) Steph (the right hairstyle and she'd be a good Dorothy. She's a superb all rounder)
4) Lauren is brilliant but she reminds me more of a society girl than a farm girl. As Sid said she's a little too polished.
5) Sophie. I love her but she's not up to a leading lady role yet
6) Jenny. She's somehow unappealing to me. She's good but I don't like watching her
7) Jessica. She needs more training and her vocal is the weakest of those left. I think she has a bright future but not as Dorothy
2) Stephanie. Polished and would be a safe/good Dorothy
3) Steph (the right hairstyle and she'd be a good Dorothy. She's a superb all rounder)
4) Lauren is brilliant but she reminds me more of a society girl than a farm girl. As Sid said she's a little too polished.
5) Sophie. I love her but she's not up to a leading lady role yet
6) Jenny. She's somehow unappealing to me. She's good but I don't like watching her
7) Jessica. She needs more training and her vocal is the weakest of those left. I think she has a bright future but not as Dorothy
1. Steph
2. Stephanie
3. Danielle
4. Lauren
5. Sophie
6. Jenny
7. Jessica
Frankly though, I think all these girls have enough talent to be major stars.
2. Stephanie
3. Danielle
4. Lauren
5. Sophie
6. Jenny
7. Jessica
Frankly though, I think all these girls have enough talent to be major stars.
1; Lauren. Best for part, best overall, and now my favourite 
2; Steph. Great all rounder, still think she is too poppy for Dorothy but second best overall
3; Danielle. Too small in her performances but got everything she needs to become a wonderful MT performer. She will learn quickly.
4; Great performances but not enough emotion on her lovely, smiley face.
5; Jessica. Dropped to my second personal favourite, but just not good enough in solo songs. Great in group though.
6; Sophie. Not my fav at all but good in group routines and at sad songs. V good vocals in sing off but not enough acting.
7; Jenny. Just gets lost and nasal in group numbers. Wonderful performance of 'songbird' but no other outstanding moments for me.
2; Steph. Great all rounder, still think she is too poppy for Dorothy but second best overall
3; Danielle. Too small in her performances but got everything she needs to become a wonderful MT performer. She will learn quickly.
4; Great performances but not enough emotion on her lovely, smiley face.
5; Jessica. Dropped to my second personal favourite, but just not good enough in solo songs. Great in group though.
6; Sophie. Not my fav at all but good in group routines and at sad songs. V good vocals in sing off but not enough acting.
7; Jenny. Just gets lost and nasal in group numbers. Wonderful performance of 'songbird' but no other outstanding moments for me.
1. Steph
2. Stephanie
3. Danielle
4. Lauren
5. Jenny
6. Sophie
7. Jessica
This is a mix of what I think of their performances and how Dorothy-ish I think they are.
2. Stephanie
3. Danielle
4. Lauren
5. Jenny
6. Sophie
7. Jessica
This is a mix of what I think of their performances and how Dorothy-ish I think they are.
I think they are all quite talented. Each in their own way.
But there are a few who I don't think would play dorithy very well.
Steph and Lauren and Jenny and Jessica.
But with Steph, i like her performences so much, that I actualy wouldn't mind if she won. The reason I don't think of her as a dorithy per say is becuase she isn't as good in simple quiet songs. And she is 21, 22 years old. She also does a flipping terrible American accent, but I'm sure she can work on it.
Lauren, looks too old. Sorry that's just my oppinion. Like her perormences sometimes, and she has a good voice.
And with Jenny and Jessica... or Jessica, it's the voice basically I don't think she has a very good one. And with Jenny I don't know what it is.
But there are a few who I don't think would play dorithy very well.
Steph and Lauren and Jenny and Jessica.
But with Steph, i like her performences so much, that I actualy wouldn't mind if she won. The reason I don't think of her as a dorithy per say is becuase she isn't as good in simple quiet songs. And she is 21, 22 years old. She also does a flipping terrible American accent, but I'm sure she can work on it.
Lauren, looks too old. Sorry that's just my oppinion. Like her perormences sometimes, and she has a good voice.
And with Jenny and Jessica... or Jessica, it's the voice basically I don't think she has a very good one. And with Jenny I don't know what it is.
Originally Posted by kates89:
“Ho hum, quite tough but...
1.) Lauren/Stephanie
3.) Danielle
4.) Sophie, purely for the look and Dorothy personality traits she seems to have
5.) Steph, no denying she is good but for me she's not Dorothy but can see her in a multitude of other musicals. In fact in most currently on in the W/E
6.) Jessica
7.) Jenny
However, 4th and 5th and 6th and 7th could quite easily swap.”
“Ho hum, quite tough but...
1.) Lauren/Stephanie
3.) Danielle
4.) Sophie, purely for the look and Dorothy personality traits she seems to have
5.) Steph, no denying she is good but for me she's not Dorothy but can see her in a multitude of other musicals. In fact in most currently on in the W/E
6.) Jessica
7.) Jenny
However, 4th and 5th and 6th and 7th could quite easily swap.”
snap!
1. Sophie - I think she has the exact personality to play dorothy. I think she's perfect in every way for the role. I cannot imagine her to play any other part and in my mind - that determines the rold is for her! She portrays the exact vulnerability of Dorothy and that's what we should be looking for.
2. Steph/Danielle - I almost think that steph is TOO good to play Dorothy. I dont think she has the right characteristics for the role, but i think shes amazing anyway and Danielle, she nearly portrays enough vulnerability, just not as much as sophie and i'd be happy to see either of these two win.
3. Stephanie - An amazing all rounder, I dont think there's anything she can't do. I'd like to see her play a more upbeat role though.
4. Lauren - I've been undecided on Lauren from the beginning, I think she sometimes comes across a little TOO polished and glossy but an amazing performer, none the less. I'd just like someone a little more honest.
5. Jenny - Jenny's voice isn't as good as the others. Although, i think she would make a BRILLIANT disney star or Glinda.. Something like that?
6. Jess - I find she ALWAYS lacks honesty and the looks just dont do it for me.
2. Steph/Danielle - I almost think that steph is TOO good to play Dorothy. I dont think she has the right characteristics for the role, but i think shes amazing anyway and Danielle, she nearly portrays enough vulnerability, just not as much as sophie and i'd be happy to see either of these two win.
3. Stephanie - An amazing all rounder, I dont think there's anything she can't do. I'd like to see her play a more upbeat role though.
4. Lauren - I've been undecided on Lauren from the beginning, I think she sometimes comes across a little TOO polished and glossy but an amazing performer, none the less. I'd just like someone a little more honest.
5. Jenny - Jenny's voice isn't as good as the others. Although, i think she would make a BRILLIANT disney star or Glinda.. Something like that?
6. Jess - I find she ALWAYS lacks honesty and the looks just dont do it for me.
01. Lauren - She hasnt had a weak week yet. She can eithe rlook very old or very young though, but I'm sure that can be sorted.
02. Sophie - When she's good she's great, but she's kinda inconsistant. I feel what she sings though, and she looks the part.
03. Stephanie - She's very well, and has everything really. I just prefer the other two, but she'd still make a great Dorothy.
04. Danielle - Like Stephanie, but I just prefer the top three.
05. Jessica - She isn't really a good singer atall. She ruined that Xtina song IMO, and when you take away her weird face and her 'quirky' manner, there's nothing there at all.
06. Jenny - She has an alright voice, but she doesn't emote enough for me, and isn't vulnerable enough for Dorothy. She's talented, but she also reminds me of Julie off Corrie
07. Steph - Easily one of the most talented singer, but she isn't, on any level at all Dorothy. She's too streetwise, too Whitneyish for Dorothy IMO. Extremely talented though.
02. Sophie - When she's good she's great, but she's kinda inconsistant. I feel what she sings though, and she looks the part.
03. Stephanie - She's very well, and has everything really. I just prefer the other two, but she'd still make a great Dorothy.
04. Danielle - Like Stephanie, but I just prefer the top three.
05. Jessica - She isn't really a good singer atall. She ruined that Xtina song IMO, and when you take away her weird face and her 'quirky' manner, there's nothing there at all.
06. Jenny - She has an alright voice, but she doesn't emote enough for me, and isn't vulnerable enough for Dorothy. She's talented, but she also reminds me of Julie off Corrie
07. Steph - Easily one of the most talented singer, but she isn't, on any level at all Dorothy. She's too streetwise, too Whitneyish for Dorothy IMO. Extremely talented though.
1. Steph - Loved her from the start. I think she seems the best all-rounder, and although I never really thought she'd fit the role of Dorothy, I'm really starting to believe that she could now. I also think she seems like a really lovely person, she doesn't come across at all cocky, like some of the others imo, and she just seems like a genuinely nice person.
2. Stephanie - Although I've never really been much of a fan of hers, she won me over this week. I absolutely loved her performance, and think her tone of voice is amazing. However, she does annoy me with the over confidence and constant over exaggeration of everything. I think she'll probably win.
3. Danielle - I haven't really enjoyed her recent two performances as much as her first two, so she's slipped from second to third in my opinion. However, I think she has the most distinctive voice out of all the girls, and I can really imagine her playing Dorothy.
4. Lauren - I've really warmed to her recently. I used to find her a little too over confident and didn't really think much of her, but I actually really love her voice and think she's a pretty good dancer and performer as well.
5. Sophie - Really gone off her recently. She was in my top three at one point, but I just find that her performances sometimes lack emotion and confidence. She looks the part though.
6. Jessica - I thought she sang well this week, but her other performances haven't been anything special imo. She gets on my nerves a bit, I don't really know what it is, but she just annoys me.
7. Jenny - I used to quite like her but have really gone off her for some reason. I think her voice is quite nasally at times, I think she's probably the weakest dancer and I just can't see her playing Dorothy.
Last edited by elise..x : 27-04-2010 at 22:22
2. Stephanie - Although I've never really been much of a fan of hers, she won me over this week. I absolutely loved her performance, and think her tone of voice is amazing. However, she does annoy me with the over confidence and constant over exaggeration of everything. I think she'll probably win.
3. Danielle - I haven't really enjoyed her recent two performances as much as her first two, so she's slipped from second to third in my opinion. However, I think she has the most distinctive voice out of all the girls, and I can really imagine her playing Dorothy.
4. Lauren - I've really warmed to her recently. I used to find her a little too over confident and didn't really think much of her, but I actually really love her voice and think she's a pretty good dancer and performer as well.
5. Sophie - Really gone off her recently. She was in my top three at one point, but I just find that her performances sometimes lack emotion and confidence. She looks the part though.
6. Jessica - I thought she sang well this week, but her other performances haven't been anything special imo. She gets on my nerves a bit, I don't really know what it is, but she just annoys me.
7. Jenny - I used to quite like her but have really gone off her for some reason. I think her voice is quite nasally at times, I think she's probably the weakest dancer and I just can't see her playing Dorothy.
Last edited by elise..x : 27-04-2010 at 22:22
1. Steph
2. Stephanie
3. Jenny (purely for her voice - Warwick Avenue was so underrated by the judges when you consider her vocal)
4. Danielle
5. Lauren
6. Sophie
7. Jessica
2. Stephanie
3. Jenny (purely for her voice - Warwick Avenue was so underrated by the judges when you consider her vocal)
4. Danielle
5. Lauren
6. Sophie
7. Jessica
1) Danielle. She is the most all rounded talent of the 7 by far. Hope she gets a belting song this week so she can strut her stuff. She is my No 1 by miles for this role, although the others are all talented
2) Lauren - very talented, just a bit too knowing & polished for the role
3) Stephanie - again, talented with a lovely, lovely voice but think she is a better singer & dancer than actress
4) Jessica - I really liked her in the auditions but she is just TOO much now. Those facial expressions are bad for TV & wouldn't work for Dorothy in MT either
5,6,&7) Sophie, Jenny & Steph all the same for me. I want them out. Sophie - just out of her depth like someone else said, Steph is very talented but not right for the role. She comes across as too mature & experienced. Jenny can sing (at times) but just can't act.
2) Lauren - very talented, just a bit too knowing & polished for the role
3) Stephanie - again, talented with a lovely, lovely voice but think she is a better singer & dancer than actress
4) Jessica - I really liked her in the auditions but she is just TOO much now. Those facial expressions are bad for TV & wouldn't work for Dorothy in MT either
5,6,&7) Sophie, Jenny & Steph all the same for me. I want them out. Sophie - just out of her depth like someone else said, Steph is very talented but not right for the role. She comes across as too mature & experienced. Jenny can sing (at times) but just can't act.
Originally Posted by RogT:
“How are the revision substitute spreadsheets showing now?”
“How are the revision substitute spreadsheets showing now?”
An update would be great - please?
[quote=Surfer2010;39917051]1) Danielle. She is the most all rounded talent of the 7 by far. Hope she gets a belting song this week so she can strut her stuff. She is my No 1 by miles for this role, although the others are all talented[quote]
Here we go again. This relentless bigging up of Danielle's acting really gets me. She may be an excellent actress. Sheila Hancock definitely seems to think so, but we have not seen anything on which to be able to judge it - but Danielle's supporters state it as fact. I really don't know how people can judge this - unless they have seen her elsewhere.
OK rant over. My order
1. Lauren
2. Steph
3. Stephanie
4. Danielle
5. Jenny
6. Jessica
7. Sophie
and I think Stephanie will win
Here we go again. This relentless bigging up of Danielle's acting really gets me. She may be an excellent actress. Sheila Hancock definitely seems to think so, but we have not seen anything on which to be able to judge it - but Danielle's supporters state it as fact. I really don't know how people can judge this - unless they have seen her elsewhere.
OK rant over. My order
1. Lauren
2. Steph
3. Stephanie
4. Danielle
5. Jenny
6. Jessica
7. Sophie
and I think Stephanie will win
1) Danielle- amaaaazing all rounder
2) Sophie- there's just something about her that makes me think she'd be a brilliant dorothy but she hasn't quite managed to be the best that she can yet
3) Steph- i just love her voice
4) Jessica- agreed with ALW sometimes there is something that makes you think she's world class
5) Stephanie- she's good but something just isn't there for me
6) Lauren- i know she's good i just can't warm to her for some reason
7) Jenny she's gooood but not dorothy for me
p.s hiiii everyone first post for me
oh and like many people my order seems to change quite a lot lol
Last edited by iamnotarobot : 28-04-2010 at 16:01
2) Sophie- there's just something about her that makes me think she'd be a brilliant dorothy but she hasn't quite managed to be the best that she can yet
3) Steph- i just love her voice
4) Jessica- agreed with ALW sometimes there is something that makes you think she's world class
5) Stephanie- she's good but something just isn't there for me
6) Lauren- i know she's good i just can't warm to her for some reason
7) Jenny she's gooood but not dorothy for me
p.s hiiii everyone first post for me
oh and like many people my order seems to change quite a lot lol
Last edited by iamnotarobot : 28-04-2010 at 16:01
[quote=henman;39918743][quote=Surfer2010;39917051]1) Danielle. She is the most all rounded talent of the 7 by far. Hope she gets a belting song this week so she can strut her stuff. She is my No 1 by miles for this role, although the others are all talented
More than welcome to rant - fine by me.
Although I don't actually mention her acting specifically in my quote that you quoted, I would agree that she is a good actress. So what is my "evidence" :
1) She was great in the glimpse we saw in the Sheila Hancock acting task (albeit that was brief)
2) Sheila has seen her perform, rates her & she is supposed to be the expert. She certainly has acting experience
3) But the biggest evidence is her performance each week in both the group & her individual numbers. She is by far the best at interpreting the words in the songs & actually trying to act them. Lauren was good acting her song last week & Steph also has great moments too but Danielle is consistently the best to me.
I rest my case - but don't expect you to agree with me!!!
Quote:
“
Here we go again. This relentless bigging up of Danielle's acting really gets me. She may be an excellent actress. Sheila Hancock definitely seems to think so, but we have not seen anything on which to be able to judge it - but Danielle's supporters state it as fact. I really don't know how people can judge this - unless they have seen her elsewhere.
”
“
Here we go again. This relentless bigging up of Danielle's acting really gets me. She may be an excellent actress. Sheila Hancock definitely seems to think so, but we have not seen anything on which to be able to judge it - but Danielle's supporters state it as fact. I really don't know how people can judge this - unless they have seen her elsewhere.
”
More than welcome to rant - fine by me.
Although I don't actually mention her acting specifically in my quote that you quoted, I would agree that she is a good actress. So what is my "evidence" :
1) She was great in the glimpse we saw in the Sheila Hancock acting task (albeit that was brief)
2) Sheila has seen her perform, rates her & she is supposed to be the expert. She certainly has acting experience
3) But the biggest evidence is her performance each week in both the group & her individual numbers. She is by far the best at interpreting the words in the songs & actually trying to act them. Lauren was good acting her song last week & Steph also has great moments too but Danielle is consistently the best to me.
I rest my case - but don't expect you to agree with me!!!
4 of 5
