Yes Another River Song Thread!

2 of 2

k4thy

10-05-2010

I think its interesting that Silence in the Library is set in the 51st Century which is Captain Jack Harkness' century too.

I don't think River and Amy are the same person, different colour hair, different colour eyes and different personalities.

Presumably the first time River meets the Doctor he already knows who she is and he first introduces the concept of spoilers.

It would be interesting to know if it is the Doctor she killed and which version.

Blagga19

10-05-2010

Originally Posted by Good Wolf:
“It's not that she references the library, but the way she casually shouts "spoilers" as if they've already had the conversation about her diary and spoilers, when although they have had that conversation in his timeline, they haven't had it in her timeline.”

Ur good! U know there was something about this that I cldnt put my finger on.... this is it !

Corwin

10-05-2010

Originally Posted by k4thy:
“I think its interesting that Silence in the Library is set in the 51st Century which is Captain Jack Harkness' century too.
”

It's just Moffats "time period of choice", just as RTD kept returning to the year 5 Billion plus.

Jack is from there, River is from there, the Girl in the Fireplace was (partly) set there.

Originally Posted by Blagga19:
“Ur good! U know there was something about this that I cldnt put my finger on.... this is it !”

But as said earlier the Doctor and River will have the Spoiler conversation every single time they meet with the Doctor probably starting it off in their first meeting from Rivers point of view.

2 of 2