probaly it's time to say what you think of him he is my favorate doctor

Well, he's still not top of my list (that's still Tom Baker), but he's certainly made the top five.

Not top of my list either, but definitely one of my favourites.

Love him! Such a quirky, brilliant doctor!

[list][*]5[*]9/11[*]3[*]7[*]10[*]4[*]2[*]1[*]6[/list]

10
4
5
3
9
8
6
7
11
2
1

Hmm, if we're doing lists I'd say for me:

1) Tom Baker
2) Paul McGann
3) Pat Troughton
4) Bill Hartnell
5) Matt Smith
6) Colin Baker
7) Sylvester McCoy
8 ) Peter Davison
9) Chris Eccleston
10) Jon Pertwee
11) Tennant

1) Tom Baker
2) David Tennant
3) Jon Pertwee
4) Patrick Troughton
5) Christopher Eccleston
6) William Hartnell
7) Peter Davison
8) Matt Smith
9) Colin Baker
10) Paul McGann
11) Sylvester McCoy

i think he's brilliant. he makes me laugh so much, maybe it's the writing but with DT I don't remember laughing very much at anything he said, but matt has me in stitches sometimes.

1) Tom Baker
2) Matt Smith

The rest...

'Nuff said, methinks

agree

1) David Tennant
2) Christopher Eccleston
3) Tom Baker
4) William Hartnell
5) Matt Smith
6) Peter Davison
7) Sylvester McCoy
8 ) Colin Baker
9) Paul McCann
10) Jon Pertwee
11) Pat Troughton

My top 11 changes quite regularly though.

I absolutely love Matt Smith, and at the moment, he is the doctor However, I couldn't give you my top 11, as it changes every time. I'm currently still watching The Krotons with Patrick Troughton (one more to go - last cliffhanger was him telling Zoe to get away), and I was thinking, what a fantastic doctor (alien, empathic, took care of his assistants and treated them well). Then I watch the Green Death with Jon Pertwee, and I think what a fantastic doctor etc. (I could go through all of them and say the same). IMO and I know I'm probably in the minority, they are all fantastic depending on my mood and which episodes I'm watching.

My list thus far:

1) Peter Davison
2) David Tennant
3) Tom Baker
4) Patrick Troughton
5) Paul McGann
6) Matt Smith
7) Sylvester McCoy
8) Colin Baker
9) Christopher Ecclestone
10) William Hartnell
11) Jon Pertwee

I am waiting till I have seen a whole series before ranking Matt Smith, it doesn't seem fair to do so based on less than half a series. That said, I think he has been terrific so far.

(1) Tom Baker
(2=) Peter Davison
(2=) William Hartnell
(2=) Sylvester McCoy
(5) Christopher Eccleston
(6) Matt Smith
(7=) David Tennant
(7=) Paul McGann
(9) Patrick Troughton
(10) Jon Pertwee
(11) Colin Baker

100% better than David Tennant.

It does seem a bit unfair to give him a position just yet when the series hasn't finished as Muttley says...but going on gut feeling, he is just below Ten and Two, but there with Four....But my God I love all of them!!!


Matt is doing a fantastic Job none the less!!!

For me Matt Smith has been just outside my top five since after TEH. You have a point that I've made before regarding other aspects of the series that we should wait until the series has finished. I don't think he'll go up that much further in my list but I still rate him a good Doctor.

1) David Tennant
2) Tom Baker
3) Jon Pertwee
4) Patrick Troughton
5) William Hartnell
6) Peter Davison
7) Paul McGann
8) Matt Smith
9) Christopher Ecclestone
10) Sylvester McCoy
11) Colin Baker

My top three are equal really could, love them to bits.

This for me, too! I can't rank the Doctors in a list. They're all fantastic at some point. That's what makes the Doctor such an amazing character. He isn't 1, 2, 3, 4, etc, etc. He's the Doctor and with every regeneration he's different, but the same. It's flipping amazing what they've done over the years in creating his character. I totally believe they are all the same person, even with all the changes that come with each incarnation.

Just give me a good story and any of the Doctors and I'll be quite content to label them fantastic.

Not a fault of Matt Smith, but so far I am wondering if Amy is the new doctor and he is the assistant as his charactor seems rather pushed back. It's Amy doing most of it at the moment and solving the problems.

David Tennant and Tom Baker are still my top two.

Really maybe she solved the problem in TBB-but the last two epsiodes were not resolved by Amy- clearly the Doctor was saving her

Sorry, as a huge Dr Who fan I don't like him. Obviously not as bad as Colin Baker, Sylvester McCoy etc but of the new generation i'm not keen - He looks like Frankenstein's Monster.
(BTW I thought Chris Ecclestone and David Tennant were Great- Brilliant )

Smith is definitely up there with the best of them.

The first regeneration I remember was John Pertwee>Tom Baker. I was about 7 and Baker was officialy "Stupid" and "Rubbish" in the playground at the time. Of course a few weeks later he was the best ever Dr.

I'm one of those who saw Smith in Party Animals so I could see his potential and thought he was an inspired choice. But even so I think this has turned out to be the least controversial changeover yet. Whilst most were skeptical it seems that most were won over after the first episode.