...it always moves me to tears.

I love hearing it sung full pelt.

Who do you think has sung it best (including non-Dorothy's) ?

After tonight, I would say Jessica although Jenny also did a great job too. They both ended with lovely smiles to the other girls which was nice

Jessica for me

From the show: Amy by miles.

Off the show: I love Ella Fitzgerald > Everybody else.

me too

god watching stephanie the other week i dont know how she got through the song, and little steph sheds a tear each time. i think its just watching someones dreams getting shattered for a moment you cant help it but it tugs on the heart strings.

Gutted to see Jess leave, I love watching her shes so entertaining but yes i agreed with Andrew i think she needs a more entertaining leading role rather than Dorothy, she sung her finale wonderful though.


Lump in throat every time

Ella Fitzgerald > Everybody else.

That said, I think Amy did it best on OTR.

I cried tonight! I loved Jess and she sang like a star!

On the show- Dani. Amy was the most in tune but she made it sound too poppy.

Off the show- I actually don't like the song very much.

I always get a wet-eyed when it's sung...
I think Jess was great tonight! I shed a few tears

I didn't like Emilie's blunder a few episodes back. And I liked Jenny but I did detect some goaty vocals last night. Those 3 stood out to me.

On the Show: Jess

Off: Eva Cassidy

Jessica.

My god, she sang it beautifully. Amazing. God I'm going to miss her!!!

Before that the best ones were Amy and Jenny

Jessica.

Same

Oh my god! Only just seen Jessica's OTR bloody hell - go girl!
That was outstanding and all the girls seem to LOVE her not one dry eye!

Awww!

The correct answer is of course a score draw between Eva Cassidy and Israel Kamikwakwakakwakakaow

I thought both Jess & Jenny did a really good job, can't say I have a performance from previous weeks that sticks in my mind as outstanding but I would say Dani and Bronte were also at a good standard.

I feel a bit sorry for Stephanie that she couldn't really keep her emotions under control for her go as it could have been a lot better.

I thought Jessica was fantastic tonight ... her version really sent shivers through me and she was so perky as well! I think her leaving tonight was a big mistake ....

Great to see Izzy K get a mention, I love his version. Wonder if the girls will ever perform this, it's more of a mash-up than anything they've done so far!

I personally prefer Garland's OTR to Cassidy's though, it's so pure - it never fails to move me.

Out of the girls, I agree with the above poster, Jess was just superb tonight singing this and the optimism of the song shone through, she has a bright future.

I think Dani had the best Somewhere Over The Rainbow, but nobody has been too bad. Even Stephanie, in spite of her evident misery, managed to do it credit.

I think Amy sung it the best out of all of them by far

I love the Izzy K version, always reminds me of Mark dying in ER

On the show: Jess and Jenny

Off: Judy Garland, Rachel Tucker, Daniel Boys

Don't like Eva Cassidy's version.

Jessica definitely, really showed of her vocals and how she could have played Dorothy.

Big mistake Andrew.

Jessica, then Amy. Dani had a good one too. Jenny was good, but not as stunning as in some of her other performances.

I also really liked Emilie's "Over The Rainbow", it was surprisingly good despite missing that big final note.


xx

p.s. But Stephanie's was the only one that made me cry! So emotional. xx

I think Amy has sung it the best, Jenny was brilliant to but my favourite is Jessica's.
Jess' was different to the others, it had her stamp all over it. The shrugs and the way she used her eyes were very Jessica . It was a more optimistic version and I loved that, proved that she is a star and going to be a huge talent .