Bronte and Lauren, for me.
Gutted both were in the bottom two but overall they had the best sing off.
Gutted both were in the bottom two but overall they had the best sing off.
Best sing off?
2 of 2
Jessica and Danielle. take that bloody look off your face ALW.
That was probably the only one I really enjoyed at all.
That was probably the only one I really enjoyed at all.
Originally Posted by Ignazio:
“Be good Ruby - you've started an interesting thread - don't spoil it by taking another swipe at Emilie.
I might get cross.
”
“Be good Ruby - you've started an interesting thread - don't spoil it by taking another swipe at Emilie.
I might get cross.
”
Disagree totally with OP.
I am not going to categorically state Emilie's sing off by far the best,that would be mere opinion,but it was very good and she was certainly better on the night than Sophie.
It was a good interpretation.She could sing MT perfectly well,and she was an excellent dancer and actress.And as someone who went to the show said,she had a very good stage presence.
I accept on the whole her voice had faults.She was'nt versatile enough to sing a wide range of different songs.In this sense her voice let her down.Unfortunately rather than pick up on what she was obviously good at,most simply condemned her in a rather unpleasant manner.
Originally Posted by elder7uk:
“Disagree totally with OP.
I am not going to categorically state Emilie's sing off by far the best,that would be mere opinion,but it was very good and she was certainly better on the night than Sophie.”
“Disagree totally with OP.
I am not going to categorically state Emilie's sing off by far the best,that would be mere opinion,but it was very good and she was certainly better on the night than Sophie.”
It really wasn't. I promise.
Originally Posted by elder7uk:
“I accept on the whole her voice had faults.She was'nt versatile enough to sing a wide range of different songs.In this sense her voice let her down.Unfortunately rather than pick up on what she was obviously good at,most simply condemned her in a rather unpleasant manner.”
“I accept on the whole her voice had faults.She was'nt versatile enough to sing a wide range of different songs.In this sense her voice let her down.Unfortunately rather than pick up on what she was obviously good at,most simply condemned her in a rather unpleasant manner.”
I think it's got more to do with the fact that Emilie stayed in when other girls who had more to offer went out. You always position it in terms of them all having strengths and weaknesses and seem to think people are being nasty because they ignored Emilie's strengths. In reality her vocal was so far behind the others' the playing field didn't look like that at all. Having said that, I thought that Emilie had a very engaging presence on stage, looked perfect for the part and was a reasonable actress. However her vocals were very, very poor and for that reason I wouldn't have let her near a musical theatre role.
To be honest, I haven't been particularly impressed with any of the sing offs. Lauren's and Bronte's was probably the best, but compared to the Nancys, these sing offs have been quite disappointing.
Nothing this series has come close to Rachel and Sarah's master class in singing and acting. It still gives me chills. Rachel and Sam's Memory was amazing as well. I love Sam's voice in that. Keisha and Niamh's The Rose was simply beautiful.
nothing could ever beat the Rachel Tucker vs Sarah Lark in IDA for me .... In OTR it's got to be Lauren vs Jenny! When Lauren sang "when pain is all around" i actually got goosebumps 
i did love the Jess vs Danielle too!
i did love the Jess vs Danielle too!
Originally Posted by littleRB:
“I have forgot what Bronte and Lauren, and Emilie and Sophie sang?”
“I have forgot what Bronte and Lauren, and Emilie and Sophie sang?”
Lauren and Bronte sang "What I did for Love" from A Chorus Line
2 of 2
