One of my main gripe with these shows, is that we don't see the girls sing Over The Rainbow until they're kicked off. That means I'm constantly going "yeah that's a good decision, they're the weakest... oh no, that's beautiful, bring her back!"

So far in the elimination singing I've loved Amy, Bronte, Dani and Jenny's versions.

Last week, when the girls were singing with the dogs on stage, the singing of 'Over The Rainbow' was the most interesting bit so far, as far as I'm concerned - we got to see most of the girls (bar Lauren who couldn't handle a dog... unlike Jenny ) sing a bit of Over The Rainbow.

Danielle is my favourite, but I can't remember her singing it ! I was very very shocked (in a good way) by Sophie and Steph, I thought they sounded amazing, as did Jenny ().

So yeah, judging from short clips, and based on singing Over The Rainbow entirely - who was the best for you?

I want Danielle to win the competition, and failing that - any but Lauren.

Judging from the singing of Over The Rainbow,... well I had Steph picked for so many other roles but not Dorothy, but she sang Over The Rainbow so well!
I'd probably have Sophie/Steph (or Amy or Jenny or Bronte) .. or Danielle! Argh!

They didnt really show Danielle singing, just playing with the dog!! Which is sad because I do want to hear her sing it, but not in the normal context!

My favourite so far has been Jess, Dani, and the clip of Steph

I think Amy and Sophie have done the best versions thus far.

Jessica.

Jessica but also Bronte.

I think Steph sounds waaaay too mature. Even singing in the medley they did we were saying it.

It was a shame that they didn't show longer clips of the girls singing OTR with the dogs to the children, that would have been very interesting. However maybe the producers thought that the audience would get OTR overload as it's sung every week already.

I liked Jessica's OTR best, then Amy's. Jessica's was very graceful and I loved that. Dani's and Jenny's were good too although in the latter case I had thought some of her other singing was much better.


xx

I like Jenny's best so far though I did like Bronte's too.

I think they all sang the song exceptionally, except maybe Stephanie which I can completely understand.

I can't wait to hear Lauren's version (though I am very happy to wait until 22nd May )!

Jenny, Jess and Bronte for me.

For me it was Jessica, Bronte and the Jenny

And Emilie???

I liked Amy's and Jessica's versions.

Though we only heard the first line of Sophies, I loved it and think once we heard all of it, it could be the best rendition of the Dorothys bar maybe Laurens. I want to hear more of it but hopefully not next week .

Jessica's

The end of Stephanie's was great, shame about how upset she was tho

I also really liked Amy's and Dani's

Do you reckon the final will involve singing over the rainbow, just like in IDA they both sang as long as he needs me?

I expect they will but it will probs only be the final 2

Jessica.... I thought she would have been average at best at it. But she surprised me. She put a lot more meaning into the words than the others have imo.

Stephanie...

Sophie sounded lovely from the bit I heard.

I loved Stephanie's rendition, even though she was very upset and lost it a bit in the middle, the last bit was beautiful.
Of the other voted-out Dorothys I thought Dani sang it the best.

From all the girls so far, my fav starts with:

Jenny
Amy
Dani
Stephanie (even though she broke down a little)
Jessica
Emilie
Bronte

My Ranking:

1. Amy
2. Dani
3. Jessica
4. Bronte
5. Jenny
6. Stephanie
7. Emilie

Amy gave the best vocal, Jessica gave the best performance

Only one person Jesssica Robinson.

Jessica - acted it, sang it, and stayed amazingly calm in those very trying circumstances.

Amy, Bronte and Dani have sung it the best so far out of the eliminated Dorothy's.

Out of the eliminees, Jessica.