Don't shoot me down for saying this, but she reminds me of another companion. One that was fond of nito 9
Yup, Amy is the modern Ace, with the annoying "professor" whine
Yup, Amy is the modern Ace, with the annoying "professor" whine
There's something about Amy?
3 of 3
Originally Posted by maidmary:
“What does irritate me is her total lack of empathy and/respect for him. She comes across as annoyingly arrogant”
“What does irritate me is her total lack of empathy and/respect for him. She comes across as annoyingly arrogant”
I don't know how you can say that about the character that made the "Very old and very kind and the very very last" speech
.
Originally Posted by johnnysaucepn:
“Lack of warmth? As far as I can see, she loves hanging out with the Doc. Even the bits where she almost dies.
You can't seriously be telling me that 'the banter' is a purely Scottish trait? People take the mickey out of their best friends all the time.”
“Lack of warmth? As far as I can see, she loves hanging out with the Doc. Even the bits where she almost dies.
You can't seriously be telling me that 'the banter' is a purely Scottish trait? People take the mickey out of their best friends all the time.”
But she doesn't just seem to be taking the mickey to me. If she didn't have such a hostile look on her face perhaps it wouldn't be so cold.
She really bugs me. I liked the young Amy she had a more endearing quality about her and I connected with her.
I also understood the older Amy's initial anger and disappointment with the Doctor after he had appeared to have abandoned her.
But how long is she going to stay like this, it's tedious. She is being given the chance to see stuff that most humans could only dream about afterall, so why still so frosty?
Originally Posted by maidmary:
“It doesn't matter that she doesn't treat him with awe. Other companions would have a go at him if they think he was getting carried away with his own importance. What does irritate me is her total lack of empathy and/respect for him. She comes across as annoyingly arrogant”
“It doesn't matter that she doesn't treat him with awe. Other companions would have a go at him if they think he was getting carried away with his own importance. What does irritate me is her total lack of empathy and/respect for him. She comes across as annoyingly arrogant”
And do you think that the Doctor treats her with empathy and respect? Threatening to throw her off the TARDIS? Telling her to shut up because she's dying? That she looks like she swallowed a planet? I'm surprised that those exchanges don't bother you in the same way - why does the Doctor get a pass?
The back-and-forth banter is what defines their relationship - it was much the same with Donna ("Oi, spaceman!").
Originally Posted by maidmary:
“And I don't buy into a young human continually relegating the Doctor to 2nd place after her.”
“And I don't buy into a young human continually relegating the Doctor to 2nd place after her.”
I have no idea when this ever took place. Amy's problem is that she grew up with a bad case of hero worship, which is quite the opposite.
Originally Posted by maidmary:
“Her put downs need to be tempered by a bit more kindness towards him. Even a few more smiles would do to balance out the hard stares lol.”
“Her put downs need to be tempered by a bit more kindness towards him. Even a few more smiles would do to balance out the hard stares lol.”
I would have thought her speech at the end of The Beast Below would make it clear the respect and understanding she has for him. That hug between them was downright beautiful.
Originally Posted by ukgnome:
“Don't shoot me down for saying this, but she reminds me of another companion. One that was fond of nito 9
Yup, Amy is the modern Ace, with the annoying "professor" whine”
“Don't shoot me down for saying this, but she reminds me of another companion. One that was fond of nito 9
Yup, Amy is the modern Ace, with the annoying "professor" whine”
I see your point lol.
Originally Posted by maidmary:
“so why still so frosty?”
“so why still so frosty?”
If thats "frosty" I could do with a few more frosty people in my life
We ARE watching different programmes.
Originally Posted by johnnysaucepn:
“And do you think that the Doctor treats her with empathy and respect? Threatening to throw her off the TARDIS? Telling her to shut up because she's dying? That she looks like she swallowed a planet? I'm surprised that those exchanges don't bother you in the same way - why does the Doctor get a pass?
The back-and-forth banter is what defines their relationship - it was much the same with Donna ("Oi, spaceman!").
I have no idea when this ever took place. Amy's problem is that she grew up with a bad case of hero worship, which is quite the opposite.
I would have thought her speech at the end of The Beast Below would make it clear the respect and understanding she has for him. That hug between them was downright beautiful.”
“And do you think that the Doctor treats her with empathy and respect? Threatening to throw her off the TARDIS? Telling her to shut up because she's dying? That she looks like she swallowed a planet? I'm surprised that those exchanges don't bother you in the same way - why does the Doctor get a pass?
The back-and-forth banter is what defines their relationship - it was much the same with Donna ("Oi, spaceman!").
I have no idea when this ever took place. Amy's problem is that she grew up with a bad case of hero worship, which is quite the opposite.
I would have thought her speech at the end of The Beast Below would make it clear the respect and understanding she has for him. That hug between them was downright beautiful.”
I just cannot take to her character at all. And it annoys me that she keeps saving the day.
Now the banter with Donna was great and didn't leave me feeling sorry for the Doctor. They had chemistry and real friendship. Their relationship really serves to highlight the lack of it between Doc 11 and Amy, particularly after rewatching some of their episodes.
Originally Posted by Ja88ed:
“You are reading in something that simply isnt there. .”
“You are reading in something that simply isnt there. .”
Originally Posted by johnnysaucepn:
“
I have no idea when this ever took place.”
“
I have no idea when this ever took place.”
Originally Posted by Ja88ed:
“
We ARE watching different programmes.”
“
We ARE watching different programmes.”
Pretty much all the above
I don't mind people criticising characters- but I think it should at least be based on an assessment of what actually happened in the programme and what the character actually did and said and not a fictional re write
Originally Posted by dvirgo:
“Is it just me or is there something missing with Amy? I don't know what it is but something just isn't right. I don't know if its the acting or the characterisation but I'm finding it hard being that interested with her on board the Tardis.
This was further highlighted when Rory joined the crew and I instantly connected with him. So, whats wrong with Amy? I wasn't a huge fan of Rose or Donna but i can understand why viewers loved them but with Amy I'm sure she's that likeable.
what did Rose and Donna have that Amy doesn't?”
“Is it just me or is there something missing with Amy? I don't know what it is but something just isn't right. I don't know if its the acting or the characterisation but I'm finding it hard being that interested with her on board the Tardis.
This was further highlighted when Rory joined the crew and I instantly connected with him. So, whats wrong with Amy? I wasn't a huge fan of Rose or Donna but i can understand why viewers loved them but with Amy I'm sure she's that likeable.
what did Rose and Donna have that Amy doesn't?”
It's exactly the same for me. Even though Rose and Donna could be sharp with the Doctor at times I never doubted their rapport with him.
Originally Posted by wildyounghearts:
“Pretty much all the above
I don't mind people criticising characters- but I think it should at least be based on an assessment of what actually happened in the programme and what the character actually did and said and not a fictional re write”
“Pretty much all the above
I don't mind people criticising characters- but I think it should at least be based on an assessment of what actually happened in the programme and what the character actually did and said and not a fictional re write
”
I am basing my opinions of Amy on whatI have seen so far and I don't have a problem with other people interpreting her differently. I can only do my assessment on how she comes across to me.
The young Amy - great, funny, real chemistry with Doc11.
I was really excited, expecting to have another interesting and compelling duo in the Tardis who bounce off each other really well.
Then, what disappointment I have felt since then. They simply don't have the connection for me that the Doctor and his companions should have.
As I said earlier - Rory and the Doc connect better for me (and I mean in a strictly platonic way lol)
Originally Posted by maidmary:
“I just cannot take to her character at all. And it annoys me that she keeps saving the day.”
“I just cannot take to her character at all. And it annoys me that she keeps saving the day.”
"Keeps"? Really? She hasn't even done it once that wasn't at the Doctor's prompting.
Should the companion take no part in the resolution of the story? Why does it bother you?
Given that Rose managed to save the day about five times in her first series and no-one here seems to be moaning about that, I think a slight double standard is being applied.
Originally Posted by johnnysaucepn:
“Yeah, they certainly had a database of Earth culture and history, wouldn't be too surprising that they would have access to the language.
On the other hand, if they knew that the crack led to Earth at the point that Zero escaped, why did they have to follow the Doctor to get here? Why didn't they just come here immediately? And why would they broadcast the message in English, and not in Zero's native language, since it was an instruction to Zero and not a warning to the humans?
Fridge logic - gotta love it.”
“Yeah, they certainly had a database of Earth culture and history, wouldn't be too surprising that they would have access to the language.
On the other hand, if they knew that the crack led to Earth at the point that Zero escaped, why did they have to follow the Doctor to get here? Why didn't they just come here immediately? And why would they broadcast the message in English, and not in Zero's native language, since it was an instruction to Zero and not a warning to the humans?
Fridge logic - gotta love it.”
I'd like to add another one to that which occured to me the other day....why wasn't the atraxi message on the stailite/web link that the experts were usuing to contact each other....when even MP3 were playing the message?
Originally Posted by abercrombie:
“Well, now let's see. Put Amy into the same situation. Doctor has deeply felt residual emotional feelings for a previous assistant with whom he has an extended shared past and who has pined for him for years. She sees them laughing and joking together away on their own, sharing private in-jokes.
Or,
Strange woman turns up who the Doctor does not know and wants to escape from, has little to no chemistry with and and seems to resent. In addition to which they treat each other with bickering and an almost platonic aquaintance.”
“Well, now let's see. Put Amy into the same situation. Doctor has deeply felt residual emotional feelings for a previous assistant with whom he has an extended shared past and who has pined for him for years. She sees them laughing and joking together away on their own, sharing private in-jokes.
Or,
Strange woman turns up who the Doctor does not know and wants to escape from, has little to no chemistry with and and seems to resent. In addition to which they treat each other with bickering and an almost platonic aquaintance.”
I don't agree with this. Rose behaved the way she did because she was a jealous type of character....which became apparent as early as Boom Town, and in Parting of the Ways, where she was making eyes at the fact that the Doctor was giving Lynda a bit too much attention. While Amy can be selfish.....there is no evidence so far that she could be very jealous....she may feel jealous, but she seems to proud to show it. For example I'd say there were tiny hints to her jealousy twords River, but overall she was mesmerised by the mystery of who and what she was for the Doctor, that any jealousy didn't take precendent. So I can imagine her behaving pretty much the same if any of his past companions turned up as she did with River. She is quite relectunt to share feelinsg that would make her weak...and jealousy would be one of those that she is likely to keep well under wrap. The way Rose got jealous was because that is who Rose is....just like Donna didn't get jealous of Martha who the Doctor told her about, but did seem to mark her territory and was protective of the Doctor when she came face to face with River. All three are different, and would react differently....Rose would still get jealous if she knew Amy was travelling with him.
Originally Posted by maidmary:
“I just find Amy rude rather than feisty.
Yes, Donna could be rude as well, BUT, and this is a big but, Donna wasn't rude all the time and she realised how hard decisions were for him at times.
I too often get the impression that Amy actually dislikes the Doctor and thinks she's a cut above him and it's getting tedious for me now. I find it incredible that a TIMELORD would continue to allow her to keep on putting him down, she even called him "pointless"!
And in some ways the Doc being described as such has some merit in this series as Amy seems to be perfectly able to save the day without his input.
It's just my personal preference, but I like the Doctor to be the star of the show, not his starey-eyed companion.
Wish he and Rory would ditch Amy on an inhospitable planet somewhere so she could moan and gripe to her little heart's delight and let them have fun somewhere a long way from her smug attitude. She ruins this series for me - many apologies to her fans, it's just my opinion afterall.”
“I just find Amy rude rather than feisty.
Yes, Donna could be rude as well, BUT, and this is a big but, Donna wasn't rude all the time and she realised how hard decisions were for him at times.
I too often get the impression that Amy actually dislikes the Doctor and thinks she's a cut above him and it's getting tedious for me now. I find it incredible that a TIMELORD would continue to allow her to keep on putting him down, she even called him "pointless"!
And in some ways the Doc being described as such has some merit in this series as Amy seems to be perfectly able to save the day without his input.
It's just my personal preference, but I like the Doctor to be the star of the show, not his starey-eyed companion.
Wish he and Rory would ditch Amy on an inhospitable planet somewhere so she could moan and gripe to her little heart's delight and let them have fun somewhere a long way from her smug attitude. She ruins this series for me - many apologies to her fans, it's just my opinion afterall.”
Really?
If any companion has ever disliked the Doctor...and at one time thought she was cut above him....well that was Donna in the Runaway Bride....Amy was annoyed with him in TEH, and when Rory died....but overall she has done nothing to show that she dislikes him. She may try to show that she is equal to him, but then so did Donna, Rose and Martha...and hey even Mickey did...
You may not like the rapport between them....but there is no evidence to suggest that she dislikes him. And to tell you the truth, half of the things that are being said about Amy, like that she is staring a lot, or dislikes the Doctor or whatever....is no difference to those who kept saying that all Donna did was shout. I think its a case of looking at one aspect of the character that bugs you so much that you just can't seem to get past it.
Originally Posted by justine01:
“Well, it was handled as a deliberate putdown (like the "heel, boy" part). That's pretty much a slight to diminish the Doc's relationship (of whatever sort) to River and fits into her attempt to retain superiority.”
“Well, it was handled as a deliberate putdown (like the "heel, boy" part). That's pretty much a slight to diminish the Doc's relationship (of whatever sort) to River and fits into her attempt to retain superiority.”
That was just Amy teasing her friend....pretty much in the same way Donna did when making fun of the idea that River called him "pretty boy"
Originally Posted by lach doch mal:
“Actually to be fair, that comment really made me like her more. If I had just lost the best friend and person I loved due to someone else (i.e. Rory and her wouldn't have been in this situation if it hadn't been for the doctor), I probably would have screamed blue murder at him and blamed him as well. I thought that was well handled, her remark at the end of VoV was far mor annoying (got my spaceship and my boys).”
“Actually to be fair, that comment really made me like her more. If I had just lost the best friend and person I loved due to someone else (i.e. Rory and her wouldn't have been in this situation if it hadn't been for the doctor), I probably would have screamed blue murder at him and blamed him as well. I thought that was well handled, her remark at the end of VoV was far mor annoying (got my spaceship and my boys).”
Exactly...even Donna got reasonably angry at him when he couldn't save the people of Pompeii, and Rose in Dalek, and Martha in Sound of Drums. And Jack in Utopia
Originally Posted by Vabosity:
“That's because IMHO Amy and River are the same person. Amy Pond, later in life, dyes her hair, takes elecution lessons and changes her name to another one with a "watery" sound to it, i.e. River Song.
When River said that she "killed the best man she ever knew" it's because in the Series 5 finale she is going to kill Rory.
On the other hand, this speculation could be the biggest load of cobblers ever posted on this forum.”
“That's because IMHO Amy and River are the same person. Amy Pond, later in life, dyes her hair, takes elecution lessons and changes her name to another one with a "watery" sound to it, i.e. River Song.
When River said that she "killed the best man she ever knew" it's because in the Series 5 finale she is going to kill Rory.
On the other hand, this speculation could be the biggest load of cobblers ever posted on this forum.”
I hope not
Originally Posted by johnnysaucepn:
“Well, it would throw New Who continuity out of whack, since you're not supposed to make physical contact with earlier versions of yourself (see "Father's Day").”
“Well, it would throw New Who continuity out of whack, since you're not supposed to make physical contact with earlier versions of yourself (see "Father's Day").”
Thank God!!!
Originally Posted by maidmary:
“It doesn't matter that she doesn't treat him with awe. Other companions would have a go at him if they think he was getting carried away with his own importance. What does irritate me is her total lack of empathy and/respect for him. She comes across as annoyingly arrogant
And I don't buy into a young human continually relegating the Doctor to 2nd place after her.
This is supposed to be DR Who, not the Amy Pond adventures with the Doctor as the companion's sidekick.
Her put downs need to be tempered by a bit more kindness towards him. Even a few more smiles would do to balance out the hard stares lol.”
“It doesn't matter that she doesn't treat him with awe. Other companions would have a go at him if they think he was getting carried away with his own importance. What does irritate me is her total lack of empathy and/respect for him. She comes across as annoyingly arrogant
And I don't buy into a young human continually relegating the Doctor to 2nd place after her.
This is supposed to be DR Who, not the Amy Pond adventures with the Doctor as the companion's sidekick.
Her put downs need to be tempered by a bit more kindness towards him. Even a few more smiles would do to balance out the hard stares lol.”
People have said that series 1 and two felt like the Rose show....and some say series 3 and 4 feel like the David Tennant show.....so there is always someone who says that it doesn't feel like Doctor Who. For me its still Doctor Who.
Originally Posted by maidmary:
“But she doesn't just seem to be taking the mickey to me. If she didn't have such a hostile look on her face perhaps it wouldn't be so cold.
She really bugs me. I liked the young Amy she had a more endearing quality about her and I connected with her.
I also understood the older Amy's initial anger and disappointment with the Doctor after he had appeared to have abandoned her.
But how long is she going to stay like this, it's tedious. She is being given the chance to see stuff that most humans could only dream about afterall, so why still so frosty?”
“But she doesn't just seem to be taking the mickey to me. If she didn't have such a hostile look on her face perhaps it wouldn't be so cold.
She really bugs me. I liked the young Amy she had a more endearing quality about her and I connected with her.
I also understood the older Amy's initial anger and disappointment with the Doctor after he had appeared to have abandoned her.
But how long is she going to stay like this, it's tedious. She is being given the chance to see stuff that most humans could only dream about afterall, so why still so frosty?”
But she stopeed being angry at him the moment he asked her to trust him when he gave her the apple back....since then she has only been proper angry at him once and that was in Amy's Choice...even when he had a go at her in the Beast Below....she still didn't have a huge go at him....I would have done. Donna got angry at the Doctor in the Runaway Bride alone more than Amy has done in half a series.
Originally Posted by maidmary:
“I just cannot take to her character at all. And it annoys me that she keeps saving the day.
Now the banter with Donna was great and didn't leave me feeling sorry for the Doctor. They had chemistry and real friendship. Their relationship really serves to highlight the lack of it between Doc 11 and Amy, particularly after rewatching some of their episodes.”
“I just cannot take to her character at all. And it annoys me that she keeps saving the day.
Now the banter with Donna was great and didn't leave me feeling sorry for the Doctor. They had chemistry and real friendship. Their relationship really serves to highlight the lack of it between Doc 11 and Amy, particularly after rewatching some of their episodes.”
She only did that in three stories......Rose also saved the Doctor many times, and Donna, and Martha....
What really jars with me is the lack of sparks between Amy and the Doc.
I understand that it's a good idea to get away from the hero-worship of the previous series but for me and a few others it's gone a bit too far the other way and there's a lack of any real connection as of yet between the two lead characters which in turn can leave things a bit flat.
A few kind words here and there don't constitute a properly warm relationship and Amy is in danger of appearing petulant too often imo.
It's time now for the Doctor to start winning her over a bit more, that would make things more interesting between them than the numerous putdowns.
Leave in some of the putdowns, yes, that's realistic and funny - too many and it stops being entertaining,
I understand that it's a good idea to get away from the hero-worship of the previous series but for me and a few others it's gone a bit too far the other way and there's a lack of any real connection as of yet between the two lead characters which in turn can leave things a bit flat.
A few kind words here and there don't constitute a properly warm relationship and Amy is in danger of appearing petulant too often imo.
It's time now for the Doctor to start winning her over a bit more, that would make things more interesting between them than the numerous putdowns.
Leave in some of the putdowns, yes, that's realistic and funny - too many and it stops being entertaining,
Originally Posted by maidmary:
“What really jars with me is the lack of sparks between Amy and the Doc.
I understand that it's a good idea to get away from the hero-worship of the previous series but for me and a few others it's gone a bit too far the other way and there's a lack of any real connection as of yet between the two lead characters which in turn can leave things a bit flat.
A few kind words here and there don't constitute a properly warm relationship and Amy is in danger of appearing petulant too often imo.
It's time now for the Doctor to start winning her over a bit more, that would make things more interesting between them than the numerous putdowns.
Leave in some of the putdowns, yes, that's realistic and funny - too many and it stops being entertaining,”
“What really jars with me is the lack of sparks between Amy and the Doc.
I understand that it's a good idea to get away from the hero-worship of the previous series but for me and a few others it's gone a bit too far the other way and there's a lack of any real connection as of yet between the two lead characters which in turn can leave things a bit flat.
A few kind words here and there don't constitute a properly warm relationship and Amy is in danger of appearing petulant too often imo.
It's time now for the Doctor to start winning her over a bit more, that would make things more interesting between them than the numerous putdowns.
Leave in some of the putdowns, yes, that's realistic and funny - too many and it stops being entertaining,”
Okay lest do it this way....please name every put down there have been so far....and once your done with your list...I'll do a Donna list...may even throw a Rose and Martha one in for free...and then we can have a proper comparison....would do you say?
Originally Posted by Vabosity:
“That's because IMHO Amy and River are the same person. Amy Pond, later in life, dyes her hair, takes elecution lessons and changes her name to another one with a "watery" sound to it, i.e. River Song.
When River said that she "killed the best man she ever knew" it's because in the Series 5 finale she is going to kill Rory.
On the other hand, this speculation could be the biggest load of cobblers ever posted on this forum.”
“That's because IMHO Amy and River are the same person. Amy Pond, later in life, dyes her hair, takes elecution lessons and changes her name to another one with a "watery" sound to it, i.e. River Song.
When River said that she "killed the best man she ever knew" it's because in the Series 5 finale she is going to kill Rory.
On the other hand, this speculation could be the biggest load of cobblers ever posted on this forum.”
Originally Posted by crazzyaz7:
“I hope not”
“I hope not
”
I hope not too, it was just an idea that occurred to me.
Originally Posted by crazzyaz7:
“If any companion has ever disliked the Doctor...and at one time thought she was cut above him....well that was Donna in the Runaway Bride....Amy was annoyed with him in TEH, and when Rory died....but overall she has done nothing to show that she dislikes him. She may try to show that she is equal to him, but then so did Donna, Rose and Martha...and hey even Mickey did...”
“If any companion has ever disliked the Doctor...and at one time thought she was cut above him....well that was Donna in the Runaway Bride....Amy was annoyed with him in TEH, and when Rory died....but overall she has done nothing to show that she dislikes him. She may try to show that she is equal to him, but then so did Donna, Rose and Martha...and hey even Mickey did...”
Exactly the sort of thing Rory was talking about - the Doctor makes people want to impress them.
Originally Posted by maidmary:
“ And it annoys me that she keeps saving the day.”
“ And it annoys me that she keeps saving the day.”
The Eleventh Hour
Amy knocked unconcious by Prisoner Zero. The Doctor guides her to think of what she saw in her house. Prisoner Zero is captured. The Doctor calls the Atraxi back and bitch-slaps them off the planet.
Saviour of the Day: The Doctor
The Beast Below
Amy follows the Doctor's advice and takes a keen note of everything going on around her. She realises that the Star Whale is kind and makes the Queen abdicate. The Star Whale and Starship UK are both save. The Doctor is saved from having to kill an innocent creature.
Saviour of the Day: Amy Pond
Victory of the Daleks
The Doctor discovers that Bracewell is a bomb. After lamping him to the floor, he opens his chest and determines that they can defuse the bomb by making him feel human. The Doctor's plan is right, but he fails to understand humanity well enough to impact Bracewell's state of mind. Amy steps in and makes a better suggestion. When the Doctor sees its working, he joins in and both talk down the Bracewell-bomb.
Saviour of the Day: Joint Effort
Time of Angels
Amy manages to stop herself being killed by an Angel, thanks to the Doctor's advice, but also gets her brain infected by one, because she ignored his advice.
The Doctor realises that the statures are all Angels and leads the team to the base of the crashed spaceship. Amy gets stuck to a handrail - is saved by the Doctor biting her hand. The Doctor then formulates a plan, firing a gun and assumedly saving the team; but we won't know until next week.
Saviour of the Day: The Doctor
Flesh and Stone
Amy nearly dies from Angel brain poisoning. The Doctor finds a way to keep her alive. River saves Amy by using a teleporter. The Doctor tricks the Angels into falling into the crack and kills two birds with one stone. Clever dick.
Saviour of the Day: The Doctor
Vampires of Venice
Rory saves Amy from fish dude. Amy save Rory from fish dude. Amy and Rory find the Doctor, who has a plan. He tells them to tear apart a chair, whilst he climbs a building and deactivates the weapon/rain machine/thing.
Saviour of the Day: The Doctor
Amy's Choice
Rory dies. Amy loses the will to live and decides to try her chances, rather than live without him. The Doctor works out the whole puzzle and destroys the TARDIS, waking everyone up from the dream.
Saviour of the Day: The Doctor (even if Amy's choice is the emotional centre of the story)
---------------------------------
So there we go. Amy has saved the day once and had a joint hand in saving the day once. The doctor has saved the day FIVE times and had one joint effort.
I don't get where this "Amy is always saving the day" thing comes from. I've read it over and over on here, but it's just not backed up by, y'know, the amount of times she's actually saved the day!
I think that some people just didn't like the fact that she did it in her second episode and then had a equal hand in saving the day in the following story. I could understand why people might have thought Amy was saving the day too much after only three episodes, but we're long past that number now and she hasn't kept saving the day week-in, week-out.
Originally Posted by allen_who:
“I know what you mean... I'm not sure her it's her though. I think it's because Ledworth is boring and she has no apparent family background. Meaning that her character has no obvious depth to it...
However Karen Gillan is a very good actress and I'm hoping we are given more to go on with her as the series progresses”
“I know what you mean... I'm not sure her it's her though. I think it's because Ledworth is boring and she has no apparent family background. Meaning that her character has no obvious depth to it...
However Karen Gillan is a very good actress and I'm hoping we are given more to go on with her as the series progresses”
I'm not sure its a good idea answering myself but Amy certainly found some depth in this story. About 43 thousand feet of depth ....
3 of 3
