Oops. Just re-watched the best Doctor Who episode ever

2 of 2

tingramretro

22-05-2010

Originally Posted by silentNate:
“I think anyone declaring any episode as 'the best' is on a sticky wicket. Personally I'd say This one is bestest ”

Which episode of it, though? A story is not the same as an episode-an episode is a single discrete installment, a story can be one episode or several.

robdx

22-05-2010

I have just watched trial of a time lord, after picking it up at a second hand market for 3 quid and others for 1 quid each complete bargain!!!!
I think they ought to bring back the one and only Sil !!!!

tingramretro

22-05-2010

Originally Posted by robdx:
“I have just watched trial of a time lord, after picking it up at a second hand market for 3 quid and others for 1 quid each complete bargain!!!!
I think they ought to bring back the one and only Sil !!!!”

I agree. Nabil Shaban was a terrific villain.

daveyboy7472

22-05-2010

I respectfully disagree with the OP's choice, good episode as it was I still love Doomsday......

Callummm

22-05-2010

Originally Posted by Dizx:
“I think The Empty Child and The Doctor Dances are the best episodes.”

AGREED!

Listentome

22-05-2010

Originally Posted by Callummm:
“AGREED!”

I agree about The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances somewhat too. I wouldn't say they are my favourite episodes, but on watching them again recently, they really are terrific.

Not so sure about Silence in the Library and Forest of the Dead. I liked the library stuff and the Vashda Neradi, but found the whole Kal thing and Donna's parallel life a bit of a bore.

Human Nature and Family of Blood are still standout episodes for me. But then most of series 3 works brilliantly for me and is my favourite series until this new one.

crazzyaz7

22-05-2010

Originally Posted by alphonsus:
“Much agreenes!

City of Death was very good - plot was excellent. Paris irrelevent, IMO.

After two or three viewings, this is really growing on me, and could be one of the better episodes of the new series.”

Sorry I know slightly off topic....but I like that word!!!

Karis

22-05-2010

Originally Posted by Salford_Who:
“Well according to the news last night, a computer effectively transmitted a DNA code into a cell, and the cell reproduced - could this be a way to bring River back after her death - but of course that opens the door for Adric too....”

I sure hope they'd get a new actor for Adric! I'm sure the original must be 6000 by now...

Listentome

22-05-2010

Originally Posted by Karis:
“I sure hope they'd get a new actor for Adric! I'm sure the original must be 6000 by now...”

Actually Matthew Waterhouse is nearly 50 and looking quite attractive.

2 of 2