Originally Posted by mushymanrob:
“the guiness book is used as the official guide and it does not feature in that, besides radio london is local.”
Umm - but the GBHS is based on various charts starting with the NME and then Record Retailer from 1960 onwards. And I was referring to Big L - the pirate radio station Radio London not any local station that came along in the 1970's.
But the point is that until 1968 there was no official chart, although Record Retailer was used by the music industry as a pointer. It was the diversity of charts that resulted in the BBC and RR out sourcing to BMRB in 1968 to claim the title of official chart. This was later taken over by Gallup.
My point is until 1968 there was no official chart, regardless of what the GBHS says and many people followed their own preference, whether it was NME, Melody Maker, Disc And Music Echo, Record Mirror (which was the Record Retailer chart after 1962) and from 1965 to 1967 the pirate stations.
Pirate radio charts were often considered to be a truer reflection of public preferences.
It is difficult to define exactly the term hit or official chart entry prior to BMRB as each publication has a legitimate claim. In fact historically the NME chart preceeded all others by two years when it published it's first chart in November 1952. Record mirror who were the next did not appear until 1954.
Neil Diamond's Solitary Man reached no 25 on the pirate Radio London chart in June 1966 and reached no 41 on the Disc and Music Echo chart in July 1966.
And GBHS is not perfect by any means, especially the earlier editions.