Sorry if this has been mentioned before. You are more than allowed to shoot down if ya want aswell.

But, what if the two parts of time space that aren't ment to meet are the Doctor and Amy?

But they're already met.... and no universal implosions....

wibbly wobbly timey wimey!!! what have we learnt???

time is not linear, more spherical isn't it?

OP- i like your thinking.... you've left me pondering butterflies and their effects!

No. The cracks are caused by the TARDIS exploding on Amy's wedding day. Bet ya a tenner.

How can there be a wedding if the groom has been erased from existence?

Wedding day? Too who?

OP, nice thought, but can I be a pedant and suggest it should be Two PENCE worth.

Or at the very least, Tuppence worth.

He could do something against the rules again to bring him back, piss off the time and cause those cracks to start happening.

Yes it could be like when Donna kept hearing the future Donna/Doctors one heartbeat.


Well that's Doctor Who for you, they'll probably come up with badly explained solution to bring back Rory. Like they did for Rose in 'The Stolen Earth/Journey's End', and being able to bring back the Time Lords from the time locked Time War in 'The End of Time'. When the Doctor said they could never come back.

Perhaps Amy and Rory's wedding is a fixed point in time, for some reason. Maybe one of their descendents does something amazing so they have to get married and have children. But because Rory never existed the wedding can not take place, fixed point in time collapses causing the cracks which suck Rory up so Rory never existed and the wedding can't take place, fixed point in time collpases causing the cracks etc. etc. Is this wibbly wobbly timery wimey enough for Moffat?

Theres speculation that there are two Doctors. Could one of them fly the Tardid into the crack (which is why the Doctor found the piece today) But because the other is still there the Doctor and Tardis still exist. Or is that impossible?

It could do with more wimey and less wobbly

Thats not being pedantic thats being annoying, Two Cents worth is just as valid as it is a proper saying. Do we even know the OP is from this country?

What somebody being pedantic on a forum...surely I would of heard about it lol ...

I'm from the UK. I did try and change it as soon as someone pointed it out, but it was too late.