Originally Posted by tiny_tim:
“I could certainly never imagine him as a TV commentator and I guess Sky couldn't either otherwise they would surely have given him a go on Football First or Champions League.”
Are you sure that Sam has never done a Football First/Champions League commentary for Sky Sports? It would be good if someone who keeps records from the TV side of the kind thing we post in this thread can confirm this.
I must say I'd be slightly surprised if they've never ever given Sam the chance to do a football commentary, given his experience in radio, during his three seasons with Sky.
I know Nigel Pearson, who is a contracted speedway and darts commentator for Sky, has done a handful of Football First commentaries for them (all of which I think were on non-televised Sunday games that had been moved due to UEFA Cup/Europa League games, so they never interfered with his talkSPORT commitments on Saturdays), so if they were willing to give him a try-out then I'm not sure why it'd be any different with Sam.
Then again, with Sam often commentating for Premier League Radio on Saturdays and Sundays, and with his Sky Sports News presenting opportunities during the week, perhaps his other commitments prevented him from getting the chance to commentate on a game for Sky.
Originally Posted by tiny_tim:
“It suggests to me that Talk are moving in a totally different direction and I wonder if this decision was taken before Jim Proudfoot's move to Absolute?”
Those are interesting points.
Perhaps Moz Dee has brought in Sam in reaction to Absolute nabbing Jim Proudfoot away from them. You might remember that Sam presented Rock & Roll Football for Absolute at the back end of last season, so perhaps they were hoping to use him on their coverage regularly before/after the signing of JP?
I have a gut feeling that part of the reason why Moz has signed up Sam Matterface, who has a pretty neutral, accent-less voice, is because he perhaps wasn't comfortable with having two West Midlands voices making up their commentary team.
talkSPORT will almost certainly receive some of their biggest ever audiences when doing exclusive commentaries this season, but many of these listeners will be people who have rarely if ever tuned in to the station before and are only doing so because it is the only place to listen to these games.
Unfortunately there is a bit of stigma about West Midlands accents, they are frequently deemed to be unpopular and there might be a feeling that having another one on top of Stan Collymore's voice might prove to be a turn-off for some of the more snobbish new listeners that come their way.
You only need to look at 5 Live - I'm sure I'm not the only one who has noticed the complete absence of a West Midlands accent of any sort from their roster of football presenters, commentators and summarisers (a line-up which has been partly shaped by Moz Dee down the years).
So perhaps this was part of the reason why he has gone with Sam ahead of Ian Danter and Nigel Pearson.
Another less controversial reason could simply be that Sam Matterface is a known name and face from TV, and since the UTV Radio takeover talkSPORT have always liked to sign up "names" to their station.
You mention how it looks like talkSPORT is heading in a new direction when it comes to their football coverage, well I would make you right with the caveat that they have been moving in this new direction since Moz Dee became their programme controller two years ago.
As someone who has waited patiently over the past ten years for talkSPORT to finally win exclusive Premier League commentary rights, I have to be honest and say I am slightly disappointed that it looks like their coverage team will chiefly be made up of former Sky and 5 Live broadcasters, rather than the people who attracted me to their football commentaries in the first place.
The likes of Alan Parry, Jim Proudfoot, Alvin Martin, Graham Beecroft, Ray Houghton, Chris Cooper, Gary Stevens, Nigel Pearson and Ian Danter have all left or have been marginalised by the station, which is a shame given all they have contributed over the past decade.