Girl Groups

1. Spice Girls – 83%
2. Girls Aloud – 72%
3. Sugababes – 67%
4. All Saints – 63%
5. Atomic Kitten – 59%
6. Mis-teeq – 57%
7. Eternal – 53%
8. The Saturdays – 49%
9. B*Witched – 38%
10. The 411 – 36%

Boybands

1. Boyzone – 86%
2. Take That – 85%
3. JLS – 78%
4. Westlife – 74%
5. Blue – 70%
6. Busted – 64%
7. McFly – 62%
8. East 17 – 61%
9. 5ive – 53%
10. A1 – 46%

http://www.responsesource.com/releas...hp?relid=56910

Do you agree? personally I think Sugababes belong way ahead of Girls Aloud, hell even the Saturdays should be before Girls Aloud.

Boyzone are obviously only ahead of Take That because of Stephens death.

Misteeq and The Sats should DEFO be higher than Atomic Kitten

And all the boybands should be higher than JLS. They've only been around for 5 minutes!

Atomic Kitten actually sold a hell of alot between 2001 and 2003, people under etsimate them nowadays and I feel they get wrongly tarnished by having that trailer trash Kerry Katona as an ex member despite her not even being present during their heyday.

Very true. I LOVED You Are. Such a sweet song

Girl band should be

Spice Girls
Sugababes
The Saturdays
Girls Aloud
B*Witched
Atomic Kitten

(The others I'm not as fimilar with to make a disiscion)

Boybands should be

Take That
Busted
McFly
Blue
5ive
East 17

(The others i dont no that well, and Westlife and JLS suck)

Where are One True Voice and Fe-m@il?!

I would put B*witched above the Saturdays (even tho I fookin hated them at the time).

I am surprised by Boyzone ranking above Take That though, especially considering how successful Take That's come back has been.

I loved that song too! I prefered the band when Kerry was in it.

I remember when Kerry left, the first 4 weeks after she left, the band were at number 1 because they replaced her with Jenny the week Whole Again was released. Just had a look and they sold 6 million singles and 4 million albums which is pretty impressive. I always liked them, they were a fun band and I loved some of their songs like Last Goodbye and Cradle.

Not sure I'd bother with The 411 in the top 10, not surprised Sugababes are below Girls Aloud, they've been well and truly ruined now and that is still what people will be remembering.

Would have placed 5ive about JLS by a long way as well.

I wouldn't call McFly a boy band. I'm not really a fan of theirs but, while they may have some cheesy songs and their fan base are mainly pre-pubescent girls, they are a proper band. They all play their own instruments, play live and sing, compose and write their own stuff, so to lump them in with all those shit 'sit on stool, get up from stool, key change, big note, sit on our arses again' "bands" (*cough WESTLIFEcough*) isn't fair, imo.