• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • Gadgets
  • Mobile Phones
iPhone 4 reception problem?
<<
<
42 of 42
>>
>
Steve™
17-07-2010
My favourite article to date from The enquirer:

The emergency press conference had everyone wondering how Jobs would explain away a fundamental design fault that has been demonstrated hundreds of times. It needed the master of ceremonies to be on top form, and boy did he put on a show.

For those reading on an Iphone 4 we'll cut to the chase before you lose connectivity. As we predicted, Iphone 4 users will be given a free Bumper wrap-around. Rejoice in knowing that the once sleek device you shelled out hundreds of pounds for will be encased in a rubber band. Apple might just as well send out strips of duct tape.

Learning about this act of generosity came at the price of having to endure 90 minutes of Steve Jobs' reality distortion field. The press conference was, for the most part, a patronising lecture, with Jobs repeatedly saying that Apple "loves its users". We think any company would if it could get away with selling its customers faulty gadgets at high prices and repeat that cycle in an infinite loop.

Not surprisingly Apple knew it was under the gun, and it gave access only to friendly journalists. Our application was denied, with our reporter being told that the company was "Limited on space for tomorrow's event and can not accommodate your request." A fair reason, until you notice that there were plenty of empty seats at the event. Maybe Apple had a lot of last-minute cancellations. Sure.

Instead of doing the right thing and admitting Apple's mistakes, Jobs, seemingly living in a state of denial, decided to gracelessly lay the blame on the entire mobile phone industry.

After trying and failing to justify the dismal wireless reception capabilities of the Iphone 4 by holding a Blackberry Bold 9700, HTC's Droid Eris and Samsung's Omnia II, Jobs proclaimed that "phones aren't perfect". Well yes, but for the Iphone 4 perfection is a dot on the horizon. Not content with blaming competing mobile phone manufacturers, Jobs also appealed to science by saying that Apple hadn't found a way "around the laws of physics", as though that could explain his blunder of putting a bare metal antenna on the outer edge of a mobile phone that, by its nature, is designed to be handheld.

Acting like a schoolboy reeling off lame excuses, Jobs, who proudly claimed that the Iphone 4 was the best phone ever, said that it, like all phones, fell prey to "weak spots". This was, in effect, to blame Iphone 4 reception problems on the mobile networks, including Apple's exclusive partner AT&T in the US.

Apparently Jobs also likes to think that the problem is due to the fact that there simply aren't enough cases available for the Iphone 4. He said that the firm's previous Iphone, the 3GS, didn't face this problem because cases designed for the Iphone 3G would fit. And, according to Jobs, only 20 per cent of those who buy the Iphone 4 don't buy a matching rubber band.

Holding the phone, Jobs repeatedly called the Iphone 4 reception problem a non-issue, affecting merely a small minority of users. But Apple claims to have sold 1.7 million of the things. If the so-called fix is to wrap a tacky piece of rubber around a £500 phone and 20 per cent of users don't have these, then that small minority of users affected by Antennagate is about 340,000 people. But let's not get hung up on figures, we're talking about the iconic Iphone 4 here.

The truth of the matter is that Apple's loyal customers are getting hoodwinked with a third rate solution to a major issue. Many of those who spent hours queuing and forking over hundreds of pounds did so for a mobile phone that could at least make phone calls without having to be wrapped in a tacky loop of rubber. Instead what they are ending up with is a manufacturer that insists on defacing their expensive device, which it sells based on its clean lines and sleek, seamless style, in order to cover up its flawed engineering and consequent inability to meet its most basic functional requirement.

Jobs noted that Apple is "not perfect", a point few would argue against. However despite his protestations that his mob of shiny toy merchants care about the people who line Apple's pockets so handsomely, his behaviour should be seen as the gold standard of corporate irresponsibility in the consumer electronics industry.

Faced with a billion dollar bill for doing the right thing, Steve Jobs chose the cheap and easy way out, an option that belies his claim that Apple is "an engineering company".


Has to be my favourite article yet. How anyone could retain their iPhone 4 and allow themselves to be mugged off by Apple any longer is utterly beyond comprehension.

The whole conference was nauseating, self congratulary, self obsessed and frankly I didnt believe a word of it
JS477
18-07-2010
Originally Posted by Steve™:
“ How anyone could retain their iPhone 4 and allow themselves to be mugged off by Apple any longer is utterly beyond comprehension.”

I do ...it's called "blind devoted faith to a brand". Even though deep down the fanbois know that what they've shelled out hundreds of pounds for isn't everything they were lead to believe they will still proclaim undying allegiance to their 'brand master' and when Apple bring the next generation out next year guess what, yes they'll buy into all the hype and shell out even more money just to get that minor modification or whatever they will have changed.

Sad I know but 10/10 and respect for their undivided loyalty
pocatello
18-07-2010
Originally Posted by Steve™:
“My favourite article to date from The enquirer:
[i]
The emergency press con”

http://www.anandtech.com/show/3794/t...one-4-review/2
looking at the signal strength degredation while holding naturally..its not as bad as claimed. But what are facts when you have hysteria. Once in a case it actually out performs a hexus 1.

Mostly this is a horrible issue affecting those who would never buy an iphone in the first place.
tdenson
19-07-2010
Originally Posted by Steve™:
“Where its likely signal is the best it will be anywhere

It appears you have been bitten by Apple mania - the phone is seriously flawed if it cannot be used consistently as a phone”

This is news to me that it cannot be used as a phone. I have had mine for a month and never dropped a single call. what a load of hysterical rubbish.
David Tee
19-07-2010
Originally Posted by tdenson:
“This is news to me that it cannot be used as a phone. I have had mine for a month and never dropped a single call. what a load of hysterical rubbish.”

So because you personally haven't dropped a single call - everyone else is talking hysterical rubbish?

Mac fans - gotta love 'em....
Steve™
19-07-2010
Originally Posted by David Tee:
“So because you personally haven't dropped a single call - everyone else is talking hysterical rubbish?

Mac fans - gotta love 'em....”



I know and whats worse is this BS that Steve Jobs has sprouted about ALL smartphones suffering from the same antenna issues!

That, frankly is just about the biggest lie Apple have told.

All phones experience reduction in signal when held, but the issue with the iPhone is caused by putting a bare metal antenna(s) on the outside of the phone, where by its nature, its designed to be held, and when touched it bridges wifi antenna with GSM/Cellular antenna, and that is very different to what happens when you hold ANY OTHER PHONE

Of course, none of that matters when you put a fruit on the product
David Tee
19-07-2010
Splendidly irreverent piece from the Register
jim_uk
19-07-2010
Reality distortion field remains strong with Steve Jobs after antennagate

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tn-YesqzvNk
alanwarwic
19-07-2010
Steve Jobs signs for BP.

"But as for the oil leak, well that affects only a very small percentage of our nation’s residents. I myself have gotten over 5000 emails from Americans telling me that their beaches from Maine to Michigan to California look fine, and they can’t figure out what this is about. I agree. I was in Hawaii just yesterday and the beaches at my estate on the restricted island of Niihau have never looked better."

http://www.dailygoat.com/2010/07/ste...solve-problem/
d'@ve
19-07-2010
Originally Posted by alanwarwic:
“Steve Jobs signs for BP.

"But as for the oil leak, well that affects only a very small percentage of our nation’s residents. I myself have gotten over 5000 emails from Americans telling me that their beaches from Maine to Michigan to California look fine, and they can’t figure out what this is about. I agree. I was in Hawaii just yesterday and the beaches at my estate on the restricted island of Niihau have never looked better."

http://www.dailygoat.com/2010/07/ste...solve-problem/”

That's quite a good analogy in fact. I've just checked the BP claims total - the number of people who have claimed they are financially affected by the Gulf oil leak, it's 114,000.

114,000 is 0.08% of the taxpaying population of the USA so the Gulf oil spill is apparently 7 times less of a problem in the USA than iPhone 4 (with 0.55% complainants, assuming it's uniform globally). Put another way:

The iPhone 4 antenna problem appears to be seven times more serious in the USA than the Gulf Oil spill. Oh, the wonder of statistics.
moox
19-07-2010
Originally Posted by d'@ve:
“ Oh, the wonder of statistics. ”

Perhaps your example will show the fanboys how easily things can be manipulated to suit your viewpoint.

Much like the entire "press" conference ("press" in quotes because only those who speak favourably of Apple or Jobs' regime got invited. Bit like a dictatorship really)
alanwarwic
30-07-2010
A consulting group has produced test reports.

http://www.paconsulting.com/our-thin...-test-results/

"The iPhone antenna performance is comparable with the performance of the other mobiles when handled or hands-free, though at the lower end of the range.
All the mobiles suffer attenuation when handled. The so called “death grip” gives a substantial further drop in performance for the iPhone to the point where we could not quantify it using the same test method.
Putting a rubber band around the iPhone, similar to but not the same as Apple’s plastic bumper, gave a significant improvement in performance."

I wonder who paid for that?
Or was it done seeking free publicity?

Reading it though, the iPhone is quite 'acceptable' and does not need a recall.
Especially as the lower performing iPhone 3 sort of 'got by'.
<<
<
42 of 42
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map