Hang on a second....

How does starting a second big bang put everything back how it was? That makes no sense.

If the Doctor was on the 'wrong side' how did remembering him bring him back? That makes no sense.

Why would 'someone' make the Tardis explode to destroy reality? That wasn't explained. That makes no sense.

Please someone explain....

Loved it, more than I could have asked for.
I'm blown away by it to be honest, I'm still 'squee'ing I'm crying with joy..

So happy that Rory's still alive, and has joined the TARDIS again, I thought Arthur outshone Matt and Karen tonight (as fantastic as they were). AK was fab as River, and I love how blatant they were in saying she's gonne come back, I simply adore Alex and Matt together (so much more chemistry between them, then AK and DT IMO..)
I'm so excited for the Christmas special now (SOMEONE INVENT US A TIME MACHINEE!!! xD haha)


Also, lol'd hard at Karen climbing over the table in Amy's wedding dress.

5 char

Honestly, it rather sounds like you missed every single important conversation this series. The whole plot was clearly explained in the dialogue. It'd be simpler for you to watch it again than have someone explain the entire story arc.

Didn't like it tbh.

Not action packed enough.
Bad backing music.

Just didn't feel big and bold enough to be a finale episode tbh.

Part 1 beats Part 2 big time. Very anti-climax too this too.


On the positive note, it was very well written and acted. I liked the scene with the Doctor talking to Ameila in bed. I wish there was emotional backing music which was good as Doomsday etc to add more emotion.

I loved it when the doctor sat up in the tardis and felt his head and said "I can buy a Fez"

Terry Pratchett got it right! wave a magic wand science fiction...

Don't think this year's final has been helped by the last four we have had at all. Especially in terms of "big" "bold" and "action packed."

Please read the explanation put forward by CD93 - explains a lot.

Absolutely! And Dr Who hasn't always been like that. It used to make a lot more sense. Hopefully S Moffat will realise that and come up with some more coherent plot.

And to whoever it was that patronised me on missing conversations...

I'm not saying I don't get it, I'm saying it's a incoherent mess. Yes, it supposedly went back and 'tied up' the ends. But it didn't make a pretty bow, it made a Gordian knot.

It's not a incoherent mess because people understood it. You didn't so I'm suggesting you've missed important bits of dialogue along the way.

Anyone?

I felt rather disapointed tbh and just didn't feel like the finale episode.

I thought the music was a let down. The scene when Doctor was talking to Ameila in bed was good but would of been much more finale like if it had emotional music which is as emotional as Doomsday etc.

Wasn't action packed enough either.

Very confusing too.


The only positives was the writing, plot and acting.

One word. Confusing.

Did you not watch it or what ?

How does that work then? Are we talking atoms? Memories? Quantum mechanics? How does keeping a few 'bits' work? What is a 'bit of the Universe'?


Oh right, so we use a convenient plot point to spin a whole series on even though it makes no sense? Verbal version of the screwdriver. Fixes everything.


Ok, I'll wait and see if it all becomes coherent in the next series. But I won't hold my breath....

Sorry you didn't like it. Although I find it funny how you didn't like it but liked the writing, plot and acting. Surely they are three of the most important things in a piece of TV?

There is a main discussion thread though where I am sure you will fine other people with similar opinions.

I was disappointed when it finished.


If anything though the end it go on a wee bit but apart from the fact I didnt' keep up with the story I liked it lol.

Of course I watched it otherwise I wouldn't be asking, would I? Stop being silly.

I'm not saying I didn't get what was going on. I did. But the actual plot itself, the whole story-arc of the series was incoherent and confused. The story, not me. I'm not confused.

I just can't believe so many people consider such incoherency to be either believable or good.

youre not allowed to say that apparently because a few of us didnt like it ,we dont get it -hence we should all watch it again

or something

Moffat is not a "action packed" finale guy like RTD, RTD likes blowing shit up and making everything better again at the end where this series finale was fantastic as it was confusing but at the same time brilliant in its own way,

And has left things open for the next series of Who.

Amazing episode. !

Several people seem to have disappointed judging by the main episode thread. I'm not one of them though, I loved it. I have to admit to not understanding how it was confusing?

I disagree. It just felt like an ending. The Pandorica Opens was way better than this.

I wasn't scared by it at all. I would of been blowen away if it wasn't for the crappy music.

I wasn't. Not because I didn't like it. I was happy because it was such a good episode!

Now I'm disappointed it's over, but not immediately when it finished lol

It is perfectly coherent. You're just not accepting it. The 1 or 2 answers remainign were explain in confidential and it was explained that unanswered questions will be attended to in Series 6

Tell me about it! Everyone seems to think the fault must be in us rather than the programme. Because Dr Who can never be crap, can it? Obviously!

You know, I used to look forward to the Doctor all week. This series has killed it for me.