Wibbely Wobely Timey Wimey...

trevf

27-06-2010

Spoilers

I fully understand that:

Spoiler

But...

Spoiler

Is this a self generating paradox?

mdtauk

27-06-2010

I imagine that River Song gave him the Vortex Manipulator before he got sealed in.

tingramretro

27-06-2010

Originally Posted by trevf:
“Spoilers

I fully understand that:

Spoiler

The Doctor gave Rory the future Sonic to get him out of the Pandorica.
Rory put the future Sonic in Amy's pocket when she was sealed in the Pandorica.
Doctor Void Jumps to future.
Amelia releases Amy from the Pandorica.
Future Doctor Void Jumps back to Rory to give him the Sonic.

But...

Spoiler

How did the Doctor get out originally to give Rory the Sonic?

Is this a self generating paradox?”

Yes. It's an established convention of the genre.

trevf

27-06-2010

Originally Posted by mdtauk:
“I imagine that River Song gave him the Vortex Manipulator before he got sealed in.”

Possibly but with his hands shackled he would not have been able to operate it.

CD93

27-06-2010

Predestination Paradox

/end 10,000th thread on the subject

iaindb

27-06-2010

trevf, the answer to your question is your thread title.

freezboob21

27-06-2010

Originally Posted by trevf:
“Spoilers

Is this a self generating paradox?”

yes