Originally Posted by Glenn A:
“ITV will be laughing all the way to the bank as, for all the matches were dismal, these two games will be their biggest rated programmes of the year now that BGT fell short of last year's 19 million. They did right to bag the two evening kick offs as this is where the biggest audience will be.”
Exactly. Plus, I think we'd all prefer the latter stages to be on the BBC anyway - it works out for both broadcasters really.
There's something traditional about Gary Lineker introducing the match, and I think the BBC has more resources and more man power to ensure that mistakes don't happen, and that the quality is top notch.
There is also the thing about not having adverts. It works for ITV, and it works for the BBC - the former trying to sell ad space at the highest price, the latter trying to justify its licence fee with important national events.
FA Cup Football is also traditionally linked to the BBC, while Champions League is more glamorous and will always be suited to ITV. The Premiership has been treated very well over the years, with Sky Sports and BBC holding a monopoly which has pleased viewers on the whole. Sky's live matches are always top notch, and Match of the Day is the perfect highlights format.
There needs to be some kind of reform with football on BBC and ITV. For me, it needs to compliment what is already their other programmes during the week, and forward planning is a must because it can lead to very, very messy scheduling.
If there was any way to do this, I would propose this:-
Saturday's - Match of the Day Live, BBC One/Two
- FA Cup 3rd Round, 4th Round, 5th Round, 6th Round, Semi-Final, Final
- England v ? (Friendlies, Qualifiers)
- Premier League early/late kick-offs
- Championship/League One/League Two
Tuesday's - Match of the Day Live, BBC One/Two
- Midweek Premier League
- FA Cup Replays
- England v ? (Friendlies, Qualifiers)
- Carling Cup
- Championship/League One/League Two
Wednesday's - The Big Match Live, ITV
- FA Cup Replays
- England v ? (Friendlies, Qualifiers)
- Midweek Premier League
- Carling Cup Live
Sky would own the well-branded Super Sunday and Monday Night Football matches, as well as most Wednesday Premier League clashes.
This will never happen, mind, but it would solve nearly all of the scheduling worries for both channels that we have identified in the last few months - and would be far better for all viewers on the whole in my view.
It could mean potentially:-
- EastEnders, Holby City and female skewed dramas would play out on Wednesday nights against ITV's football.
- Coronation Street to find a permanent 7.30pm slot on Tuesday's after Emmerdale, with award ceremonies and various other female-skewed shows from 8pm against BBC One's football.
- BBC One can offer an alternative against ITV's early evening entertainment on Saturday's, which will also mean that Doctor Who will move to 7ish, which I'm sure will please all fans.
All in all, BBC One would once again have a great package of football rights, being able to put less preferred games on BBC Two and broadcasting movies on BBC One ad hoc. It also means that the corporation can challenge Sky. Meanwhile, ITV would only air stuff on Wednesday's, which suits most viewers as they tend to hate the broadcaster.
It would be more consistent for all broadcasters, and we need some regulation so something like this can be put into place. It will mean fair competition between all broadcaster. Alas, things have the ability to shuffle around, but an around-the-table agreement would suit everyone.
I've always been a fan of having more football on the terrestrial channels, even though I'm also a fan of Sky's coverage.
Does anyone else share my thoughts? Or, more likely, have obvious qualms about it? There is a lot of fantasy about the above post, I'm only suggesting that something like this would be a great idea (IMO), I'm not suggesting that this is GOING to happen.