Will Katy return to Emmerdale in a year with a baby in tow?
Who would make the better father?
Andy or Robert?

If they do a storyline like that I'll murder the writers myself

Andy,

Robert is too selfish to be a dad and although Andy went a bit berserk after the affair came out, he's generally an ok person.

Has Katie left for good, though? I'm expecting her to come back a lot sooner than a year. Andy would be a better father and he and Katie were better together even though she didn't love him

Well Robert wouldn't give a damn, that's just the person he is. I'd give any money if this were to happen, he's be the dad.