Originally Posted by
mindset:
“It must be a girl thang... 
But in my eyes the player I would compare with Janelle, is evel Dick. They both competed well and they were both very much in your face people. But neither had the kind of ingenious subtlety demonstrated by Will or Dan.”
Yeah, I see what you mean. I think the only real difference is that Dick was actually a lot sharper strategically and just in general than Janelle was.
I rooted for Janelle to win in both her seasons because I didnt care for her opponents but when it comes down to it, she didnt really deserve to win either for making poor decisions.
People say that Janelle is the best never to win at BB and I find that a bit laughable.
Her game in BB6 was admirable for her honesty and loyalty to her allies, but like most players that season, her strategy was basically "get rid of who I like least."
Her first HoH was a fabolous show to watch, but strategically it was atrocious gameplay. The Friendship hated her regardless, but she still didnt even attempt to go for the glue that held them together, she went for the low rung who betrayed a friend earlier in the week.
And lets not even start on her BB7 game. When you win 4 HoH's you deserve credit for being a fighter, but in an Allstars season, when your evictees are Alison, Diane, Marcellas and Chicken George, you know somethings not right.