ooo ok hate to bitch and I think I've said this in my rewatches actually but I'll answer you. Ok so who should have been in the top 11? Well I quite liked Tasheka and Emma. If one of them had gone through instead of Emilie I would have been a lot happier. I don't think Emilie should ever have got as far as she did. I also don't think Dani was at all strong enough and I didn't see her appeal even though she was my age. Amy had a good voice which I've appreciated more recently since re listening to otr songs but I hated her image. She probs should have been there though so I guess the judges got that right. So for me Tasheka and Emma should have really been there and Dani and Emilie shouldn't have been there.

I don't think Amy ever had a serious chance of being Dorothy, even though I think she was really talented. It was just the wrong role for her.

As for the wildcard, I liked Tasheka. I think she had a great voice and stage presence.

I liked the girl who was like passionate about village life in the 1970's. becuase she would have been funny in the live shows.

Was she called Sarah? It was certainly an interesting thing to say. I have no idea what she meant by it!

yes she was called sarah she called graham dude :P ok im off now back saturday nighttt

Arrividerci Burnttoastsad. Talk Saturday.

I think Sarah could have rivalled Jessica for quirkiness!

Aww, shall miss talking to you.

We'll keep up the debating.

Yeah I agree, I don't think Dorothy would have been right for her, even though she is really talented!

Yeah we will miss chatting! Debating will be kept up!

Hmmm, I'd either say Claire Harbourne or Sarah, from the short time they were on, I thought they were pretty good (can't really give a full review - wasn't much to go on).

Amy and Emilie were the wrong people to go through. Amy was quite talented but there was no way she was going to be Dorothy. Emilie just wasn't strong enough - its that simple.

Amy looked too old for the part. I think Dot always needed to be a teenager. I suppose Steph or Lauren could have got away with it, as they look young for their years.

3 cheers Consigliere. Another Harbourne fan! I can vouch for her qualities.

Hip hip hurray
Hip hip hurray
Hip hip hurray

Its a pity we didn't see more of her

All this OTR talk makes me wish it was on again even more!

Oh, they were good times

At least all this talk is keeping us busy until March. Don't ask me whats happening that month??? Everyone just seems to keep mentioning it

Haha I know! Not like Danielle is playing Dorothy or anything!

Strange, I always thought Sophie was Dorothy this is quite a shock......I'm sure this....Danielle you speak of is quite talented

Claire wasn't given a chance to make the most of herself. Talking of Claires, what about the Hillier? Now there was a character...

The Hiller is a legend. Deserved a standing ovvvaaatttiion

I know I already said this but i seen her at the palladium.

Oh the Hillier could you imagine if she actually became Dorothy, that would be freaky!!!!

Well, Consigliere, you are close to landmark posts both here and on the forum. I will expect a speech! (I am already preparing for my 500th post on here).

Well I never thought about giving a speech for my DS posts as people are higher than me. The forum is another matter when I reach 'superstar' I shall give you a speech!!!!

Her version of OTR would be immense. Sooommeeewheeeree Ovvveerrr Thhhheee Raaainnbbow......

You are entitled to give a speech every 500 posts. I got this protocol from the Siophie thread. And I will use it, so be warned!

Ah, Hillier... I liked it when she flirted with the audition chief (was he called Grindrod?) She was the only girl who had that chutzpah. Well, she was more of a woman than a girl, I suppose.

Haha lol. It would indeed be immense, not as good as Danielle's of course!!!!