Originally Posted by wizzywick:
“Fair do's! I appreciate your viewpoint. I will just add though, that when I asked my late wife to marry me I never even thought she might keep her name. She didn't, but it was assumed, that by marrying me that she would be joining my family so by having my surname seemed normal. I asked her father for permission and her parents gave her a splendid day. Her dad "gave" her away, so technically physically her family name by giving her to me.”
That sounds very nice and as you say it was the traditional way of doing and IMO there is nothing wrong with it, particularly if both partners are happy with it

.
Originally Posted by wizzywick:
“I don't have a problem with people who choose different names, keep their own names or hyphernate their names.”
Me neither, and if it turns out that Amy has become Amy Williams, I would't occur to me to question it.
Originally Posted by wizzywick:
“With regards to my friend, she had a very wicked and unmentionable childhood due to terrible things her father did to her. Therefore it came out totally out of the blue that she would choose to keep her father's name especially when the hatred she has for him is oh so apparent!”
Sorry to hear it, but in this case there are all sorts of psychological reasons why she might have done it. I think what surprises me most about some couples who get married today (not necessarily your friends) is that they actually don't discuss
essential things.
To bring the thread back on track, I'm sure that the whole Amy Pond/Williams issue will be resolved (and I don't think there will be a Rory Pond/Williams issue).