• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Doctor Who
Companions Vs Companions
<<
<
1 of 2
>>
>
Face Of Jack
17-09-2010
With all this publicity about Katy Manning (Jo Grant) appearing in the SJ Adventures, I wonder how they will get on? PLUS is the Doctor there as well - Matt Smith - how will they react to him?
Anyhow I digress.... what I've thought since then is how would other companions react to each other. We've seen it all in the Multi-Doctors tales, and more recently the reactions of Sarah-Jane and Rose/Martha/ Donna etc...
I'd love to see how Jamie gets on with Ace!
How about Donna and Tegan in the same room?
What would Ben Jackson do with Peri
I think Victoria would have got on well with Nyssa.

Any more ideas (loads to choose from)?
Tigger-Roo
17-09-2010
Originally Posted by Face Of Jack:
“With all this publicity about Katy Manning (Jo Grant) appearing in the SJ Adventures, I wonder how they will get on? PLUS is the Doctor there as well - Matt Smith - how will they react to him?
Anyhow I digress.... what I've thought since then is how would other companions react to each other. We've seen it all in the Multi-Doctors tales, and more recently the reactions of Sarah-Jane and Rose/Martha/ Donna etc...
I'd love to see how Jamie gets on with Ace!
How about Donna and Tegan in the same room?
What would Ben Jackson do with Peri
I think Victoria would have got on well with Nyssa.

Any more ideas (loads to choose from)?”

Hmmm

Adric with Barbara and Ian
Ace with Jamie
Donna with Tegan
Amy with Turlough
Leela with Capt Jack
Mel with Jo Grant

Ooh I see we have two the same. I didn't read your list properly until I'd done mine.
spiney2
17-09-2010
The Master and Capt Jack in love (as per RTDs rainbow agenda).

The master has reformed, and is now "good", but we all know that cant be true, tee hee hee .......
leosw4
17-09-2010
Originally Posted by spiney2:
“The Master and Capt Jack in love (as per RTDs rainbow agenda).

The master has reformed, and is now "good", but we all know that cant be true, tee hee hee .......”

Yeah that sounds interesting.

Capt Jack would end up getting shafted though
spiney2
17-09-2010
As he should, that would be morally and sexually appropriate.


Also, Susan and Leela in love (as per RTD), should get a few more men watching .......
Abomination
17-09-2010
A more modern stance... Rose and Amy. I can envision blonde and ginger (metaphorical) fireworks going off now.
spiney2
17-09-2010
Capt Jack, Mel, Dancing Dr Who, (Tennant), Nyssa (nice costume); "Let's put on a musical in the Tardis" .........
DavetheScot
18-09-2010
I can imagine Tegan and Amy producing a bit of friction. And I can just imagine a perplexed Jamie trying to work out just why Captain Jack is winking at him in that strange way
Face Of Jack
18-09-2010
Zoe and Adric (two mathematical geniuses) : perfect match?
Capt. Jack and Peri - "well, HELLO babe, whereabouts from the states are YOU?" ".....And by the way, who's your gorgeous step-father?"
spiney2
19-09-2010
K9 & Dalek Caan.
daveyboy7472
19-09-2010
I'd personally love to see Donna and Peri, now that would be a great pairing...or should that be pairings!!!!!
G. Fieendish
19-09-2010
Originally Posted by Face Of Jack:
“Zoe and Adric (two mathematical geniuses) : perfect match?
Capt. Jack and Peri - "well, HELLO babe, whereabouts from the states are YOU?" ".....And by the way, who's your gorgeous step-father?" ”

Why do I get the feeling that Capt. Jack is just about to receive a knee to his groin from Peri, with the following.reply...?
"In case you're wondering Buster, I come from California, Via Baltimore...!"
nebogipfel
19-09-2010
Ace and Rose were pretty good fun. (The Ten Doctors).
broadshoulder
20-09-2010
Leela and Donna.

One stupid remark from Donna and out comes the blowpipe and janus thorns.
Tigger-Roo
20-09-2010
Originally Posted by daveyboy7472:
“I'd personally love to see Donna and Peri, now that would be a great pairing...or should that be pairings!!!!! ”


With which Doctor? Five, Six or Ten? Or maybe one of the others.

Donna and Peri with Four would be good.
daveyboy7472
20-09-2010
Originally Posted by Tigger-Roo:
“With which Doctor? Five, Six or Ten? Or maybe one of the others.

Donna and Peri with Four would be good. ”

Interesting one, not really sure!!!

Peri should have had longer with 5 though I can't see Donna getting on with the 6th.....MMMMM.......

I think Peri would have got along with 10 so I'd go for that, but I think Donna would have got on with 5.......

Dammit, sod The Doctor. let's let em have a show of their own.....Donna and Peri I mean!!!!!!!!
JohnnyForget
20-09-2010
I would have liked to have seen the following Tardis crews:-

1. The First Doctor, Ace, Tegan and Donna.
2. The Second Doctor, Captain Jack and Leela.
3. The Third Doctor, Amy and Peri.
4. The Fourth Doctor, Mel, Jamie and Martha.
5. The Fifth Doctor, Ian and Liz.
6. The Sixth Doctor, Rose and Adric.
7. The Seventh Doctor, Dodo and Rory.
8. The Eighth Doctor, Sarah Jane and Steven.
9. The Ninth Doctor, Polly, Vicki and Jo.
10. The Tenth Doctor, Barbara and Nyssa.
11. The Eleventh Doctor, Zoe and Ben.
Tigger-Roo
20-09-2010
Originally Posted by JohnnyForget:
“I would have liked to have seen the following Tardis crews:-

1. The First Doctor, Ace, Tegan and Donna.
2. The Second Doctor, Captain Jack and Leela.
3. The Third Doctor, Amy and Peri.
4. The Fourth Doctor, Mel, Jamie and Martha.
5. The Fifth Doctor, Ian and Liz.
6. The Sixth Doctor, Rose and Adric.
7. The Seventh Doctor, Dodo and Rory.
8. The Eighth Doctor, Sarah Jane and Steven.
9. The Ninth Doctor, Polly, Vicki and Jo.
10. The Tenth Doctor, Barbara and Nyssa.
11. The Eleventh Doctor, Zoe and Ben.”

Some really interesting configurations there Johnny. Going to go away and have a think about this myself and see what I come up with.
daveyboy7472
20-09-2010
The Ultimate Crews:

Loud: The Sixth Doctor, Tegan and Donna

Irritating: Adric, Mel and Vicki

Action: Third Doctor, Sara Kingdom and Ace

Loved up: The Tenth Doctor, Rose, Martha and Amy

Funny: 2nd, 4th, 8th, 10th and 11th Doctors

Mechanical: K9 and Kamelion

Crazy: 11th Doctor and Jo Grant

Tigger-Roo
20-09-2010
Okay I've thought about this long and hard and I've come up with the following:

1. The First Doctor, Tegan,Donna and Captain Jack (just to see how he will deal with two headstrong girls and a..well Jack)
2. The Second Doctor, Amy and Grace ( a nice steadying influence I thought)
3. The Third Doctor, Ian and Harry (a bit of kickass action)
4. The Fourth Doctor, Victoria and Martha (Can imagine Four being driven to distraction by Victoria and Martha picking up the pieces)
5. The Fifth Doctor, Susan and Ben (Ben and Five will be good together, and I think Five will be a good father figure for Susan)
6. The Sixth Doctor, Jo and Ace (Just think this would be interesting)
7. The Seventh Doctor, Polly, Sarah Jane and Peri (I love Seven and think he deserves these three great girls)
8. The Eighth Doctor, Vicki and Dodo (The mellow team)
9. The Ninth Doctor, Zoe, Leela and Nyssa (All these girls know their stuff. Would be great to see them interact with Nine)
10. The Tenth Doctor, Barbara, Steven and Adric (Would just love to see how Ten deals with Adric and Barbara/Steven would be a great infuence on him)
11. The Eleventh Doctor, Jamie, Mel and Rose (just for the fireworks)
G. Fieendish
23-09-2010
Originally Posted by Tigger-Roo:
“Okay I've thought about this long and hard and I've come up with the following:

1. The First Doctor, Tegan,Donna and Captain Jack (just to see how he will deal with two headstrong girls and a..well Jack)
2. The Second Doctor, Amy and Grace ( a nice steadying influence I thought)
3. The Third Doctor, Ian and Harry (a bit of kickass action)
4. The Fourth Doctor, Victoria and Martha (Can imagine Four being driven to distraction by Victoria and Martha picking up the pieces)
5. The Fifth Doctor, Susan and Ben (Ben and Five will be good together, and I think Five will be a good father figure for Susan)
6. The Sixth Doctor, Jo and Ace (Just think this would be interesting)
7. The Seventh Doctor, Polly, Sarah Jane and Peri (I love Seven and think he deserves these three great girls)
8. The Eighth Doctor, Vicki and Dodo (The mellow team)
9. The Ninth Doctor, Zoe, Leela and Nyssa (All these girls know their stuff. Would be great to see them interact with Nine)
10. The Tenth Doctor, Barbara, Steven and Adric (Would just love to see how Ten deals with Adric and Barbara/Steven would be a great infuence on him)
11. The Eleventh Doctor, Jamie, Mel and Rose (just for the fireworks)”

Re The above teams...
1) The Tardis doors somehow open in flight, sucking Jack (at least) into the Time Vortex...
2) Take 2 Doctors into the TARDIS...?
3) Enter Team TARDIS...? The Delgado Master might receive a "jolly good thrashing", metaphorically, if not physically, from this grouping...
4) It depends on what season, this grouping is set in...
5) Given Susan's apparent fascination with the 5th Doctor, in the 5 Doctors, I have the suspicion that this grouping might end up with the Doctor praying she falls in love with Ben, rather than him...(This could end up potentially quite farcical, IMO)
6) I agree with you here, though the thought of the 6th Doctor discovering a can of Nitro-9 in the fridge, is somewhat disturbing...
7) I can imagine the rows between Sarah-Jane Smith,& The Doctor, if the 7th Doctor decides to be manipulative for any reason... Certainly Ghost Light would end up this way, if she found out he was using Peri ,or Polly as "pawns"...
8) Agreed...
9) I have the sneaking suspicion, given that both the 9th Doctor & Nyssa are respectively "the last of their kinds", that some sort of romantic relationship (marriage ?) would spring up between them, as a result...
10) Agreed, though I suspect that Barbara would treat Adric as a "Unruly Schoolboy" & react accordingly...
11) I don't think so some how, as I can imagine a Mel/11 Doctor pairing, & a Jamie/Rose pairing forming up over time....
Tigger-Roo
23-09-2010
Originally Posted by G. Fieendish:
“Re The above teams...
1) The Tardis doors somehow open in flight, sucking Jack (at least) into the Time Vortex...
2) Take 2 Doctors into the TARDIS...?
3) Enter Team TARDIS...? The Delgado Master might receive a "jolly good thrashing", metaphorically, if not physically, from this grouping...
4) It depends on what season, this grouping is set in...
5) Given Susan's apparent fascination with the 5th Doctor, in the 5 Doctors, I have the suspicion that this grouping might end up with the Doctor praying she falls in love with Ben, rather than him...(This could end up potentially quite farcical, IMO)
6) I agree with you here, though the thought of the 6th Doctor discovering a can of Nitro-9 in the fridge, is somewhat disturbing...
7) I can imagine the rows between Sarah-Jane Smith,& The Doctor, if the 7th Doctor decides to be manipulative for any reason... Certainly Ghost Light would end up this way, if she found out he was using Peri ,or Polly as "pawns"...
8) Agreed...
9) I have the sneaking suspicion, given that both the 9th Doctor & Nyssa are respectively "the last of their kinds", that some sort of romantic relationship (marriage ?) would spring up between them, as a result...
10) Agreed, though I suspect that Barbara would treat Adric as a "Unruly Schoolboy" & react accordingly...
11) I don't think so some how, as I can imagine a Mel/11 Doctor pairing, & a Jamie/Rose pairing forming up over time....”


I like your response thank you. You've got some good thoughts there on how it could pan out. So what pairings would you put with each Doctor?
CoalHillJanitor
23-09-2010
Originally Posted by JohnnyForget:
“I would have liked to have seen the following Tardis crews:-

1. The First Doctor, Ace, Tegan and Donna.
2. The Second Doctor, Captain Jack and Leela.
3. The Third Doctor, Amy and Peri.
4. The Fourth Doctor, Mel, Jamie and Martha.
5. The Fifth Doctor, Ian and Liz.
6. The Sixth Doctor, Rose and Adric.
7. The Seventh Doctor, Dodo and Rory.
8. The Eighth Doctor, Sarah Jane and Steven.
9. The Ninth Doctor, Polly, Vicki and Jo.
10. The Tenth Doctor, Barbara and Nyssa.
11. The Eleventh Doctor, Zoe and Ben.”

I do like that Ian-Liz combination. Very scientific. I'd like to see both of them return sometime. Although it would get awfully nerdy in the TARDIS if they were with Eleven!
G. Fieendish
23-09-2010
Originally Posted by Tigger-Roo:
“I like your response thank you. You've got some good thoughts there on how it could pan out. So what pairings would you put with each Doctor?”

Right, here goes...
1) The First Doctor, Nyssa & Steven (Three refugees travelling together, apparently fleeing disaster for various reasons. Given his apparent age. will the Doctor metaphorically regard Steven & Nyssa as the children that he never had...?)
2) The Second Doctor, Tegan & Jamie
(Reason, with minor re-working, The Faceless Ones becomes Tegan's intro story, rather than Logopolis or even Xeraphin, which later & with far less budget, became Time-Flight).
3) The Third Doctor, Martha & Turlough
(Turlough wants to get off Earth, a/k/a "This Miserable Rock" as he thinks of it, & if he can help The Doctor repair his travel machine, might even get a chance to do so...)
4) The Fourth Doctor, Rose & Adric
(The catch here, is that it's the 4th Doctor, circa season 14, rather than the 4th Doctor, circa Season 18, which means Adric might work better, while Rose acts as a substitute sister)
5) The Fifth Doctor, Mel & Leela
(The 5th Doctor might listen to Mel for a change, while Leela's glad to get off Gallifrey, if she originally left in The Invasion of Time...).
6) The 6th Doctor, Zoe & Donna
(What happens when 2 differing versions of the future merge...? According to Zoe's version her present time,(2020 ?) a e-newspaper, The Hourly Telepress, with The Karkus comic strip has been in existence for at least 20-30 years,
In Donna's present time of 2008, the concept does'nt even exist...) .

7) The 7th Doctor, Romana 2 & Ben...
(Would Romana be able to control the Doctor's manipulatiive,urges, or will she end up as a pawn in his metaphorical "Great Game"...?
If so, is Ben then regarded as a potentially "expendable asset"...?).

8) The 8th Doctor with no assistants (This event has only happened for 1 story. What happens if it carries on for longer & what happens to the Doctor's personality, as a result...?)
9) The 9th Doctor, Romana 1, & Susan...
(Gallifrey has fallen, but can the Doctor "save something from the ruins", so to speak...?)
10) The 10th Doctor, Jo Grant & Peri
(The Doctor has apparently been lumbered with 2 "Bimbettes", so to speak, or has he...?
Some lifeforms may regret finding out the answer to this question...).

11) The 11th Doctor, Sarah Jane Smith & Susan
(The Doctor returned for them...).
Tigger-Roo
24-09-2010
Originally Posted by G. Fieendish:
“Right, here goes...
1) The First Doctor, Nyssa & Steven (Three refugees travelling together, apparently fleeing disaster for various reasons. Given his apparent age. will the Doctor metaphorically regard Steven & Nyssa as the children that he never had...?)
2) The Second Doctor, Tegan & Jamie
(Reason, with minor re-working, The Faceless Ones becomes Tegan's intro story, rather than Logopolis or even Xeraphin, which later & with far less budget, became Time-Flight).
3) The Third Doctor, Martha & Turlough
(Turlough wants to get off Earth, a/k/a "This Miserable Rock" as he thinks of it, & if he can help The Doctor repair his travel machine, might even get a chance to do so...)
4) The Fourth Doctor, Rose & Adric
(The catch here, is that it's the 4th Doctor, circa season 14, rather than the 4th Doctor, circa Season 18, which means Adric might work better, while Rose acts as a substitute sister)
5) The Fifth Doctor, Mel & Leela
(The 5th Doctor might listen to Mel for a change, while Leela's glad to get off Gallifrey, if she originally left in The Invasion of Time...).
6) The 6th Doctor, Zoe & Donna
(What happens when 2 differing versions of the future merge...? According to Zoe's version her present time,(2020 ?) a e-newspaper, The Hourly Telepress, with The Karkus comic strip has been in existence for at least 20-30 years,
In Donna's present time of 2008, the concept does'nt even exist...) .

7) The 7th Doctor, Romana 2 & Ben...
(Would Romana be able to control the Doctor's manipulatiive,urges, or will she end up as a pawn in his metaphorical "Great Game"...?
If so, is Ben then regarded as a potentially "expendable asset"...?).

8) The 8th Doctor with no assistants (This event has only happened for 1 story. What happens if it carries on for longer & what happens to the Doctor's personality, as a result...?)
9) The 9th Doctor, Romana 1, & Susan...
(Gallifrey has fallen, but can the Doctor "save something from the ruins", so to speak...?)
10) The 10th Doctor, Jo Grant & Peri
(The Doctor has apparently been lumbered with 2 "Bimbettes", so to speak, or has he...?
Some lifeforms may regret finding out the answer to this question...).

11) The 11th Doctor, Sarah Jane Smith & Susan
(The Doctor returned for them...).”


I like your idea for the First Doctor, would have like to see that.

Also Eight with no companions...interesting.

Also Nine with Susan and Romana I like the idea behind your thinking.

Ten, haha, yes just for the fun of it.

and also like your idea of Eleven returning for Sarah Jane and Susan.
<<
<
1 of 2
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map