Can Cher sing? You decide

4 of 4

spannerandpony

29-10-2010

Originally Posted by researchshirley:
“She can gurn, she can dance like an awkward chimney sweep's transvestite child assistant and she can use eyebrow tweezers. But she can't sing.”

Hello Shirley! Haven't heard from you in a while!

spannerandpony

29-10-2010

Originally Posted by RichmondBlue:
“Come to think of it, she does look like some deranged child prostitute from a Dickens novel. I could see her doing a new twist on " You've Got to Pick a Pocket or Two ".. with Cheryl as Nancy and Simon as Fagin.”

In the immortal words of Fagin: Shut up, and drink yer gin

researchshirley

29-10-2010

Originally Posted by spannerandpony:
“Hello Shirley! Haven't heard from you in a while! ”

Hey S&P! Hope all well. Seem to have less time on my hands this series but am no less enthralled. I do miss DanylFan baiting though!

spannerandpony

29-10-2010

Originally Posted by researchshirley:
“Hey S&P! Hope all well. Seem to have less time on my hands this series but am no less enthralled. I do miss DanylFan baiting though! ”

I'll bet you do! Those were the days...

Nobody that marmite-ish for me this series; i.e. someone I really like and you detest (or vice versa)?

researchshirley

29-10-2010

No - me neither. Don't like Cher at all but it's not the same thing!

Lizzy11268

29-10-2010

Originally Posted by researchshirley:
“Hey S&P! Hope all well. Seem to have less time on my hands this series but am no less enthralled. I do miss DanylFan baiting though! ”

Originally Posted by spannerandpony:
“I'll bet you do! Those were the days...

Nobody that marmite-ish for me this series; i.e. someone I really like and you detest (or vice versa)?”

Oh don't remind me the pair of you!

Do we actually like the same people this series I wonder

Odd Socks

29-10-2010

She can sing. Just not in tune.

researchshirley

29-10-2010

Originally Posted by Lizzy11268:
“Oh don't remind me the pair of you!

Do we actually like the same people this series I wonder ”

Lizzy! Ooh I wonder!

Love Matt & really like Treyc, hate Cher & Katie. All kinds of otehr opinions in between!

You?

spannerandpony

29-10-2010

Originally Posted by Lizzy11268:
“Oh don't remind me the pair of you!

Do we actually like the same people this series I wonder ”

lol Lizzy

Good point! I like most of them this year but there's nobody like Danyl. I like Rebecca, Matt, Mary and Aiden and strongly dislike Cher and Katie, but there's nobody I'd feel strongly enough to have a good bit of banter about like last year!

XxRebirthxX

29-10-2010

Miss Frank > Cher Lloyd

Lizzy11268

29-10-2010

Originally Posted by researchshirley:
“Lizzy! Ooh I wonder!

Love Matt & really like Treyc, hate Cher & Katie. All kinds of otehr opinions in between!

You?”

Originally Posted by spannerandpony:
“lol Lizzy

Good point! I like most of them this year but there's nobody like Danyl. I like Rebecca, Matt, Mary and Aiden and strongly dislike Cher and Katie, but there's nobody I'd feel strongly enough to have a good bit of banter about like last year! ”

My top 3 are, in no particular order, Aiden, Rebecca, Matt.
Bottom are Cher and Wagner.
Warmed up just a little eeny weeny bit to Katie as I quite like the tone of her voice
The rest I can take or leave.

katiemack

29-10-2010

Very average, and quite a bit of it was out of tune she's a lot more style than substance though!

SlimSim

29-10-2010

I can't say she can't sing but its nothing you don't see in a pub karaoke at the weekend, not deserving as a recording artist IMO

bookclub10

29-10-2010

I loved her first audition but haven't been impressed with her performances since. Must admit that the girl has great stage presence though.
I'm looking forward to seeing this 'ballad' tomorrow night!

4 of 4