Originally Posted by diva_moon:
“I deeply suspected that John's resignation from the show was designed to give him the most publicity possible. There's an inevitable comparisonbetween him and Anne of course, but Anne has not been playing on the public sympathy the way John did. John was out to prove a point and to kick start his media career. I think Anne is just out to have a laugh. She probably won't last very much longer, but she's really enjoying it and so are most of us.
On the other hand, I do hope she goes before people turn against her. I turned hugely against John after he kept arguing with the judges and trying to tell everyone what the show should be about. I found him slimey, unpleasant and self-serving and I went right off him. I do not find Anne anything of the kind. Her self-mockery is just her, no agenda. She doesn't quite old cheese like "The public will save me". Oh John used to make me want to vomit when he did that.”
I don't think that John was out to prove a point as such: the impression I got was that it began relatively innocently with him answering the judges back which secured his popularity with the audience. I think what happened then was that he got caught up in his own hype and 'The public will save me' rather reflects that (not that I'm defending him saying it - it made him look extraordinarily arrogant). But the judges (especially Arlene) and the anti-BBC media were as much to blame as he was for turning his appearance on the show into something that nearly killed it. I think the penny finally dropped for him and that's why he left (not to mention the speaking engagement on a cruise he already had booked ...).
Ann hasn't played to the public as overtly as JS did, but played to it she has, absolutely. She knows her dancing is pretty ropey and she is going out of her way to play the 'entertainment' card as much as possible (quips to Tess, answering the judges back, comedy routines that don't require her to do much). She may give the impression of being out to have a laugh, but it's just an act, along with the self-mockery. Politicians are a dishonest breed at the best of times and Ann is just saying what she thinks people want to hear.
What's different about her and JS is that she has clearly been engaged to perform in this way. She has been given a brief. I don't enjoy watching Ann but, at the end of the day, she is doing the job Moira Ross and her team hired her to to do. And it's this I have the biggest issue with: we are headed towards schizo Strictly, with all the other contestants inhabiting the programme as we know it (albeit served with lashings of cheese) and Ann the sole star of 'Let's Dance For Comic Relief' (except Ann is the only person benefitting from her efforts).
JS never had the BBC hype machine behind him when he claimed the public would support him. Ann does. And that's what's most worrying about all this. There is a very clear agenda to keep her in the competition for as long as possible. I just wonder who is going to let their discontent about this slip first: a celeb, or a pro?